Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierende/desistierte lesbische Frau, die sich 2018 mit 16 als trans identifiziert hat und etwa drei Jahre lang sozial transitioniert war, bevor ich Ende 2021 erkannte, dass mir Geschlecht egal ist und ich froh bin, weiblich zu sein. Ich hatte nie Hormone oder Operationen, teils aus finanziellen und gesundheitlichen Gründen, und ich komme mit meiner Geschlechtsdysphorie durch Tagebuchschreiben, Therapie und den Austausch mit anderen Frauen zurecht. Ich bereue die fünf Jahre, die meiner Meinung nach von etwas zutiefst Sinnlosem verzehrt wurden, und diese Reue ist Anfang 2022 noch täglich da. Ich unterstütze Transition weiterhin für manche dysphorische Menschen, sehe aber die Online-Trans-Kultur, den „Gender-Envy“-Diskurs und den Druck, den ich in GSA-artigen Räumen gespürt habe, kritisch. Ich arbeite daran, mein soziales Leben rund um die Lesben-Community und feministische Freundschaften neu aufzubauen, nachdem ich mich aus LGBT-Räumen zurückgezogen und meine Social-Media-Konten gelöscht habe.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and I'm 20 years old as of autumn 2021. I first started identifying as trans at 16, in 2018, after years of shame about being a lesbian. Looking back, I had crushes on girls from a young age — it felt like something I'd always known — but I ended up identifying as a masculine lesbian first and dressing like the men I admired around 14 or 15. Instead of being happy when I dressed in men's clothes at that age, I would get increasingly frustrated that it wasn't exact and that I didn't pass flawlessly.
A big driver of my transition was jealousy. The constant posts on trans subreddits and wider social media about 'gender envy' were, I think, extremely harmful to me. I'd always identified as a masculine lesbian, but seeing people undergo medical transition while citing images of men they wanted to look like confused me a lot and made me think it was normal to strive for an image other than yourself. This normalisation of jealousy-driven behaviour stoked the flames of distress and anger at the world in my teenage heart. I was responsible for it too, giving examples of people that made me want to be a boy. When I told a friend I wanted to look like a male actor, I was told I was trans. I also think transness being presented as more of an option means a lot of people who don't need to transition are more likely to do so.
I also had OCD, and I know how the ruminations work — they always come from something you're worried about, which I think is proof you don't want to transition. I've given advice to others with OCD-like fears about gender, telling them to accept the feelings as thoughts created just to torture you and to strip them of their power by going 'alright, so what?'
I came out socially and was out for around 3 years by late 2021. Before coming out I would argue with people on Twitter, but after telling the first person I wasn't cis I became really awkward about the subject, even with close friends — I think there are only two people I've properly been able to talk to about it. People asking me about it is uncomfortable. I'm still interested in gender nonconformity and transness, but in an academic way — I'd rather read about it than tell anyone my actual opinion.
I moved to college in a new city and established a friendship group of mostly trans people. I was worried they'd abandon me if I desisted. I felt very pushed to transition and 'prove myself' within GSA-type scenes rather than having my identity celebrated. Around the last two months of 2021 it hit me that I don't give a fuck about gender — I'm indifferent to gender and just like to dress masculinely, but I'm realising that being female or feminine isn't so bad. My dad apologised for calling me 'she' but I didn't care.
What moved me toward desisting was realising that the way I feel towards women is acceptable and doesn't have to be the same way men feel. I think I was pressuring myself to be a boyfriend, the man in the relationship, from the second I worked out I was a lesbian, and never gave myself space to explore it as a woman without wanting to position myself as a more masculine partner and enforce heteronormativity. Also, being a terribly unconvincing man — I previously thought myself so masculine and alienated from other women, but I am still quite clearly female and I'm experiencing life and relationships as a butch lesbian would. I have all these experiences and a nice community and sense of solidarity that I don't want to throw away just to try and conform.
I was looking into hormones and surgery to correct my dysphoria until recently, but transition isn't viable for me no matter how much I struggle with my identity — I don't have the money and I have health issues, though I fully support my FTM friends. I've found that speaking to other people about how I view myself, and taking small steps such as journalling reflectively and seeking therapy, has helped just a little. I asked whether it was okay to join a space if you're considering desisting but haven't come out to anyone about it yet, because I was looking for a place to discuss it. I also asked whether a certain book was worth checking out as someone who hasn't desisted but is considering doing so.
I feel I lost 5 years I could've used. Life is so short and I feel I've been consumed by something that was so deeply pointless. I experience regret every day now I'm beginning to re-identify with my lesbian identity. I had a lot of shame in my lesbianism for years.
I've deleted social media and stepped back from LGBT spaces, though I'm still part of the community. I'm working on finding friends who will encourage me to work on myself, and I purposefully seek the advice of older people with different life experiences. I want to connect with other women in my area, talk to them about the issues close to my heart and the importance of pride and self love, and hopefully pull a few people out of the self-loathing spiral I went down.
I struggle with extreme behaviour in radical feminist and gender critical communities where some people actively bully trans folks just because they disagree with their views on gender. I think it's a nuanced topic that needs compassion. I am still pro-transition for some dysphoric people and don't think anyone should be threatened or targeted for their looks just because they identify as trans. That said, I've found solace with the more reasonable people who post about radical feminism because I finally feel represented, whereas in LGBT circles I'd just agree with others to avoid a fight and feel I'd compromised my feminist morals.
I want to go into the film industry, which is still rife with sexism. A lot of my moviemaking heroes are men, but that's because equally or more talented women aren't really given the chance. I think I didn't see myself having a successful career or the same cult following a lot of those men have. I also noted that there are no lesbian bars or events in my city or even my country that I'm aware of, and I don't know how to make gay female friends even though I know a lot of lesbians on the internet.
I've been active in detrans and desister communities, offering support to others — including a 16-year-old worried about TOCD, and someone whose 13-year-old sister was considering transition, where I said 13 is SO young and there's no need to introduce her to trans communities or commit to one option yet. I've praised detransitioners' videos as the first ones that encouraged me to question my transition. I've also criticised posts that treat adults as if they can't be manipulated, saying so many who detrans are autistic, mentally ill, or outcast in some way. I criticised the idea that a woman's pain and self-hatred is inherent dysphoria, saying that takes all the blame away from our patriarchal society. I've compared egg_irl content to a horoscope or psychic reading — based on feelings and suspicions the majority of people have, and through that is right every time. I've argued against generalising all retransitioners, and I've advised someone identifying as FTM to think long term about surgery and hormones and to talk to a therapist because transition is a permanent decision.
Current status: I am a desisted/detransitioning lesbian woman, re-identifying with my lesbian identity, having been out socially as trans for around three years and never having had hormones or surgery.