Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau – ich habe mich im College etwa sechs Monate lang als trans identifiziert und dann aufgehört, ohne es jemandem zu sagen, und heute identifiziere ich mich als Lesbe, Christin und Mutter. Meine Zweifel begannen nach einem LGBT-Vortrag im College über ein „Trans-Spektrum“ und wurden verstärkt durch sexuellen Missbrauch in der Kindheit, eine dysfunktionale Familie, eine konservativ-religiöse Erziehung, die Frauen abwertete, und eine Butch-Identität, die mein Selbstvertrauen stärkte. Ich habe desistiert, nachdem ich über Kinderehen gelesen und begriffen hatte: „Das hätte ich sein können, wenn ich woanders geboren worden wäre.“ Das hat mich wieder mit meiner Weiblichkeit verbunden, was durch Schwangerschaft und Geburt noch tiefer wurde. Ich habe nie Hormone genommen oder mich operieren lassen, und ich lehne heute Transition bei Minderjährigen ab, was mich Freundschaften in der LGBT-Community gekostet hat. Ich bin mir meiner Identität als Frau sicher, in meinem Glauben aktiv und unterstütze andere unabhängig von ihrem Weg.
Vollständige Geschichte
I came out as a lesbian over half my life ago and I'm a woman in my early 30's, married for over a decade with a child. I'm also technically a desister — or at least an ex-very-serious questioner. I identified as trans for about six months or so back in college, when gender identity theory was not nearly as developed or widespread as it is now.
I started questioning when my LGBT group in college was given a presentation about the 'trans spectrum' and told that if you were anywhere on the spectrum other than 'totally male' or 'totally female' you were trans. At that time I had just started presenting as butch — beginning to wear men's clothes, cutting my hair, and taking on a more masculine persona boosted my confidence drastically. So when the presentation suggested a trans spectrum, it seemed clear someone like me must be on it. I came out to several friends and my girlfriend at the time (now my wife) as trans-identified, pondered a name change, and researched medical transition.
I realized medical transition wasn't for me one day when I was reading about child marriage — the practice in some parts of the world of marrying off very young girls to older men. The undeniable thought hit me: 'this could have been me if I had been born somewhere else.' That got me in touch with a sense of feminism bigger than the minutiae of US gender politics, and it made me feel differently about the reality of my womanhood. I pretty much just stopped identifying as trans but didn't really tell anyone, which made for funny moments years later when someone would call me my trans name and it would take me a second to remember what they were talking about.
I grew up in a really dysfunctional family and had a bad relationship with my mom. On top of that, we were members of a very conservative religious group where men have a lot of institutional power and social respect in comparison to women. That combination made it tough to reconcile with being female — it was very complicated. My sister is older than me and had a very classic, very intense case of childhood gender dysphoria that persisted after puberty. Gender dysphoria wasn't talked about when we were kids and she never got treatment for it. She had a really hard time and struggled to fit in her whole childhood and adolescence. Eventually she grew up and joined a male-dominated profession where her masculine traits were common for women and valued, and she married a guy a little outside the norm socially. She told me recently she is very glad she didn't transition — she's become happy with who she is. She's straight and married to a man, though many people who meet her would read her as gay.
I was also sexually abused when I was growing up, and I know how much shame and confusion is built into that experience and how much it can affect the way you see yourself. I was never the kind of girl growing up who cared about bras or twirling my hair, and it made me feel like I wasn't much of a girl. It really wasn't until my pregnancy that I started to feel really in touch with my womanhood.
I had a baby a couple of years ago, and the whole process of pregnancy and childbirth was one of the most profound things I have ever experienced. It was so powerful to watch what my female body could accomplish, and it made me so proud to be a woman. I was not someone who was good with kids or knew I wanted kids growing up, but I absolutely love being a mom now. The fact that the puberty blockers/hormones treatment path takes the opportunity to have a biological child away from kids before they can possibly make this decision in an informed way is one of the things that upsets me most about it.
I was butch for a decade, but since my pregnancy I have presented more femininely again. I don't wear makeup, but I grew out my hair and wear women's clothes now. Two things motivated this: pregnancy changed my body and my butch clothes stopped fitting as well, and butch women face quite a bit of rudeness and hostility, which I found a little bit scarring and made me feel separate from other people. I didn't want my daughter to be exposed to that, and when during my pregnancy I found I felt okay in my maternity clothes, I decided to switch to a feminine style full-time. The people in my life were a little puzzled, but most people have just shrugged and moved on.
I am a convert to Christianity and my faith informs how I think about issues of identity. I believe fundamentally we are beloved creatures of God, who will walk with us wherever we go — including towards or away from transition. Knowing we belong to God can liberate us from the burden of having to define our identity in order to feel rooted in something. Self-understanding is good, but that is different from attaching too tightly to identities, which are constructs and should be held lightly. I've gone through many of the challenging questions around fitting into Christianity as someone with a complex experience with gender or sexuality, especially being in the 'middle' — not an LGBT activist, but not against same-sex relationships or transition for well-informed adults either.
I have always had trans friends (many) and supported trans causes without issue until a couple of years ago when I learned about the reality of pediatric transition. Because the LGBT community has been such a big part of my identity, having this fundamental difference with the community about what I see as a moral issue has been very painful for me. I posted on Facebook about a year ago that I oppose pediatric transition, and the reaction was incredibly swift and aggressive. Nearly everyone who publicly commented was upset with me, but I got a lot of private messages from folks who agreed but were too scared to say so. I lost a couple of friends and several other relationships have been strained. If you disagree you're basically told you want trans people to kill themselves — it's become so toxic.
I believe blockers followed by cross-sex hormones results in infertility essentially 100% of the time, since the gametes never fully develop, and that this could potentially interfere with sexual functioning. I really struggle with the reasoning of advocates who say things like 'some 11 year olds know they never want to have sex or have children' or that kids can't consent but their suicide risk is so high parents have to make that call.
I find this detrans group does a much better job than so many places of actually supporting real humans and having real conversations that allow multiple perspectives, unlike much of the dialogue on reddit which is either ideological pro-trans activism lacking nuance and facts or ideological anti-trans activism lacking nuance and compassion. I do think there are some pretty shitty GC types here, but also people who want better dialogue. I've advised others to use the name and pronoun an adult child asks for, to try counseling with a non-LGBT oriented counselor, and to give themselves time before medically transitioning.