Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Butch-Frau mit einer angeborenen Nebennieren-Hormonstörung (NCAH), die mit sieben Jahren die Pubertät auslöste und die meine Mutter absichtlich unbehandelt ließ, damit ich für Männer attraktiver sein würde. Ich transitionierte im College, nahm etwa 3,5 Jahre lang Testosteron, entwickelte Bluthochdruck Stufe 2 und andere Komplikationen und ging als erwachsener Mann nie durch. Ich detransitionierte aus gesundheitlichen Gründen und weil ich mit den Ergebnissen nicht zufrieden sein würde; mein Leben ist jetzt viel besser, mit einer Freundin, einem rein männlichen Freundeskreis und besserem Stand bei der Arbeit, auch wenn etwas Dysphorie bleibt, die ich bewältige, während ich weiterhin maskulin auftrete. Ich vertrete eine Ansicht nahe am Transmedizinalismus: Ich unterstütze den Zugang Erwachsener zur Transition für Menschen mit echter Dysphorie und sehe Trends zu nichtbinärer Identität kritisch. Ich wurde aus r/butchlesbians verbannt, weil ich über Detransition gesprochen habe.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and I have a genetic hormone condition — NCAH, an adrenal gland disorder — that caused increased sex hormone production and pushed me into puberty at age seven. That early puberty shaped everything that followed. I had to wear a bra four years earlier than average, I smelled like a teenager in elementary school, I gained weight too quickly, and I developed teenage anger and depression long before my classmates. I stopped growing while everyone else went through normal puberties. Doctors strongly recommended hormone treatment to my mother to delay puberty and protect my adult height; she refused. Later she told me she had worried about my future attractiveness because I always acted and dressed like a boy, and that she withheld the treatment because she was afraid I'd turn out a lesbian and wanted me to be appealing to men — she said this way men would want to pick me up and protect 'a cute little girl.' My parents hated my masculinity and would say 'girls don't do that,' making every attempt to make me feminine. I was a masculine kid who spent the first decade of my life with the boys in my class and on my street; I never wanted to fit in with girls. I didn't face real social rejection until age 16, when classmates found out I was dating a girl. I'm gay — still gay and still gender nonconforming after detransition. I remember living in a dissociative state, waiting for my 'real puberty' to come, where I'd grow tall, get real facial hair, a deep voice. When I discovered what being transgender was, I knew immediately that's who I was. I transitioned during my sophomore year of college and was on testosterone for about 3.5 years. I loved the hairiness, the deep voice, rough skin, thicker hands — and I still miss those. But T didn't change my hips, height, or facial structure. When I passed, people read me as an 'early bloomer' 12-15 year old boy at 22, after three years on T. I failed to pass as an adult male because of my stunted height and skeletal frame, and not going through a 'real' male puberty made my dysphoria worse rather than better. Socially transitioning was a mistake I regretted even at the time: as a butch woman I got more of a 'cis guy' treatment than as an openly trans man. People knew I was trans and it was offputting; I couldn't make new friends in college. I didn't relate to LGBT people my age because my interests and mannerisms were almost strictly male. I couldn't find any women willing to date me, despite plenty of luck before transition. Medically, T gave me stage 2 hypertension after about a year, despite being around 20, an athlete, and in excellent physical health. It also caused panic attacks and raised my cortisol; my doctor assumed it was my adrenal disorder, but my blood pressure returned to normal within several months off T. T also caused complications with my hormone disorder and prolonged bleeding. I detransitioned because of the health problems and because I wasn't going to pass — I wasn't willing to risk my longevity for something I wouldn't be satisfied with. Detransitioning was the only thing that helped; I was sick of being stuck in the uncanny valley between male and female. My life is significantly better now. I have an all-male friend group that treats me as one of them, a long-term girlfriend, and I'm better respected at work. I still dress in men's clothes, get men's haircuts, and 'act' like a man — I believe personality and dress shouldn't change based on whether you transition. I still have dysphoria, but it's much less painful once you learn to cope with it, and being seen as a butch woman is better than being a non-passing trans man. I work out and, as a 5'0 woman, have built enough upper body strength to outlift untrained 5'10+ gym newcomers. I shop at brands for short men like Ash & Erie and Under 510 and get athletic-fit pants tailored. I got banned from r/butchlesbians for discussing detransition, which frustrated me since I'd defended trans people there. On transition for others, my position is nuanced: I'm adjacent to transmedicalism — I think medical transition genuinely helps some people with real gender dysphoria, that an able-minded adult shouldn't be legally barred from making decisions about their own body, and that I'll use preferred pronouns for trans people as a courtesy of respect. At the same time I'm critical of nonbinary identities and what I see as internet-driven identity exploration, and I tell people considering transition that if they don't 100% pass, it will give them a hard life. I advise siblings of trans people to stay supportive and ask guiding questions rather than confront, since that's the only path that leaves room for the person to reach their own conclusions.