Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte, nicht-binäre/genderqueere Frau, weiblich geboren in Deutschland, die 14 Monate lang (Dez. 2017–Jan. 2019) Testosteron nahm, eine Mastektomie und eine Hysterektomie hatte (Eierstöcke behalten) und im Februar 2019 teilweise zu detransitionieren begann. Ich erlebe echte Geschlechtsdysphorie und habe eine Vorgeschichte mit Essstörung, und meine Transition ging mit Dissoziation, postoperativer Depression und einem Zusammenbruch etwa vier Monate nach der Operation einher, von dem ich mich mit neuer Medikation (Sertralin), dem Absetzen von T und unterstützender Therapie erholte. Mein Bedauern ist ambivalent statt total: Ich liebe meine tiefe Stimme und das Wachstum im Genitalbereich, empfinde die Mastektomie als neutral bis positiv, vermisse aber manchmal meine Brüste und wünschte, mir wäre eine Verkleinerung angeboten worden, und ich wünschte, ich hätte mehr Wahlmöglichkeiten und Informationen gehabt. Heute lebe ich als androgyne, soft-butche „nicht-binäre Frau“, die weiterhin die Pronomen er/ihm benutzt, arbeite als Peer-Beraterin für trans und geschlechtsvariante Menschen und unterstütze trans Menschen weiterhin, während ich Gatekeeping, die rechte Vereinnahmung von Detrans-Räumen und die Feindseligkeit gegenüber trans Menschen in manchen Detrans-Communities kritisiere. Seit der Detransition habe ich keine Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung beschrieben, wobei ich beschrieb, dass ich bereit war, vor ein Auto zu laufen, als mir vor der Transition zunächst Hormone verweigert wurden.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up in Germany, in Hamburg. I was a gender-nonconforming child and I was never really pushed into a gendered box except at school, which I have described as hell-ish. I am attracted to men (I have described myself as bi- or pansexual, and at one point as male-attracted), and I also identify as being on the autism spectrum and as having borderline personality disorder. I have also described myself as intersex, saying 'I'm intersex too' and that my mother had a surgery against her will or better knowledge, though I have not described my own difference of sex development in detail.
I first came across the idea of transition as an adult. I have said I started at 25 and that I was 26 'and that was 2 years ago' (said in November 2020). I began testosterone in December 2017 and stopped in January 2019, so I was on T for 14 months. Before being allowed to start, hormones were denied to me at some point and I was so distressed that I was 'ready to get hit by a car, because I have fight so long for this.' In Germany at the time, I needed at least 6 months of testosterone to get top surgery and a hysterectomy, and I have said I was 'forced going on T to get this surgery' — I do not regret the changes, but I wish I could have had a choice. I had a mastectomy and a hysterectomy (I kept my ovaries; no oophorectomy). I said I took T 'for a deeper voice and a larger clit.' I began partially detransitioning in February 2019, but not to live as a woman again. In 2020 I legally changed my first name to a gender-neutral one (I had been changing my female birth name into one neutral and two male ones), and I was in the process of changing my legal gender marker to male under the German TSG, which I noted allows you to change everything back again.
I have described my transition as 'kinda traumatic' and said I dissociated most of the time while medically transitioning: when I try to remember how I felt then, there was just 'stress', nothing else. I had post-surgery depression after my surgeries — I did not take my medication (I already had a history of depression) and had a bad mental breakdown about 4 months post-surgery, with unbearable regret. I got new meds, stopped testosterone, and my body healed and my mental health stabilized. I began taking sertraline when I detransitioned and had very good experiences with it. I have also described having an eating disorder in the past, and a younger sister who went from diet to diet, which I tried to force into therapy, causing her to stop opening up to me.
I have been open about ambivalence rather than clean regret. I have said I don't really regret my top surgery but wish I had had the option of a radical reduction; that I don't regret the voice drop and bottom growth but feel ambivalent about the mastectomy and hysterectomy; that I sometimes miss my breasts and am often sad I never managed to love them; and that I see my transition as 'equally a loss and a gain.' I have said I sometimes think I made a big mistake, even two years into detransition, but mostly I am glad I did it, and that I don't regret it as a whole because it was 'a necessary step to become myself.' My biggest fear was becoming 'a mutilated, crazy woman' or a 'mutilated woman' who looks grotesque and is only attractive if fetishized — an idea I refuse. I have said the idea that cut bodies are less complete or healthy is rooted in several marginalisations, and that healing from the feeling of being ruined or subhuman is what I am working on, noting that this feeling comes from outside, not inside.
Physically, after stopping T I noticed my facial and belly hair got lighter and thinner, and some shrinking of the clitoris, though it is still bigger than before and I am happy about that. About a year off T my testosterone level was still higher than before I started; my ovaries are working again (I stay in contact with my endocrinologist), but because I had a hysterectomy I do not know my cycle. The only negative side effect of stopping was bad facial skin. I never wear a bra after my top surgery because nobody really notices; I get gendered as female all the time, and for swimming I use a sports top that looks like a binder. I enjoy my deep voice — I had nightmares where it got higher again — and I am not planning to change it. I like the bottom growth and the fuzz on my belly, chest, face and butt; people are confused when they see me and I love that. I now live in a grey area where people read me as a masculine woman or a transfeminine person, and sometimes people think I am a trans woman, which doesn't bother me. I describe myself as androgynous, soft butch, genderqueer, nonbinary, a 'nonbinary woman,' and a 'queer dyke'; I still use he/him pronouns because they feel more right, and I have said I am not cis or a woman but relate to women because I was born female. I have said I am 'more in touch with being female at birth' now, and that now my breasts and uterus are gone I am dealing with being female without the traits society uses to define it — which gives me empathy for trans women, because 'we are seen as wrong women.'
I have said I experience genuine gender dysphoria, and that I accepted my dysphoria as something I cannot escape from. I have described living as a man as meaning wearing ugly, unfeminine clothes, pressure not to be too feminine, and the danger of being seen as a threat by men at night or women... by other men during the day and women at night; and I hated most effects of T: being horny 24/7, emotional disconnection, sweat smell, acne, and the hair. I was envious of skinny white trans men who got handsomer on T and had to accept I just got hairier, sweatier and fatter. I have said living as a woman feels better for me now. I have also said I never planned to take T for more than a few years and only wanted a few changes.
I have reflected on what led me here: I idealized thin, attractive trans men and realized I could never be one of them; I have pointed to patriarchy, gatekeeping, and pressure from other trans men (the pushing I experienced came mostly from other trans men) as factors; and I have criticized misogyny, homophobia and femmephobia in ftm communities, including trans guys telling each other not to get eyebrow piercings or wear baggy pants because they would look like a lesbian. I have said I was 'forced going on T' by the requirement structure and wish I had had a breast reduction covered instead of a mastectomy, and tubes tied instead of a hysterectomy.
Mentally, I have said reading detrans stories often feels like harming myself, fueling panic that I am just a mutilated, crazy woman. I have had nightmares about my voice rising. I have described feeling stressed and unsafe in this detrans subreddit because of the amount of hostility toward trans people — I said I was 'literally crying' because discovering the sub had been an enormous help but the hate against people I love was unbearable, and that I am too often silent and too stressed to read here. I have said I don't trust people who use 'transgenderism' or 'trans ideology,' and I have pushed back hard on right-wing and conspiratorial framings ('Trans Cult', 'Trans Empire + Big Pharma'), on the claim that T inevitably destroys the uterus (calling it a dangerous myth with a eugenic flavour that forces trans people to sterilize themselves out of fear), and on detrans spaces being used as a political battleground to recruit destabilized people. I have said I feel very uncomfortable with 'ally' outsiders taking up space in detrans communities.
Socially, I have been supported: my community was always there for me; my endocrinologist and psychiatrist were very supportive and never pushed me in any direction, and they were among the first to know when I decided to stop T; I am still working with my therapist and endocrinologist. I am friends with three other detrans people and some questioning people in my town, and I have a supportive nonbinary community. I work as a peer consultant for gendervariant and trans people, and I integrate a session on detransition into my education for clients because I am detrans myself. My boss is a trans woman who transitioned 35 years ago. I have a little sister. I have said dating is complicated because for the rest of my life I will have to out myself as detrans at some point and my body is visibly altered, but that it doesn't stop me from living an authentic life as a queer dyke; I recognize my body as mine when I stand naked in front of a mirror, and that is everything I wanted.
On transition for others, I am broadly supportive and pro-choice: I believe in bodily autonomy, I am against gatekeeping and forced medical interventions (including for intersex people, and I criticized Germany's pre-2011 sterilization requirement), and I want more options — no T required for a mastectomy, reductions covered, tubal ligation instead of hysterectomy. I say 'trans men are men and trans women are women,' that being trans is a real but complex and individual experience, and that detrans people are very individual — not all of us regret anything. I advocate that detrans spaces support all detrans people and let us speak for ourselves, and I want more resources for detransitioning males and more information about gender-nonconformity and alternative ways to transition. I have also said I don't like hollow 'I support detrans people' comments or 'you are beautiful' fishing posts, but I welcome neutral questions asked in good faith. I have said I wish I had more options and knowledge at the time, but that I am at peace with myself and glad I had the experience.