Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die als Mann lebte und jahrelang Testosteron nahm, bevor ich um 2020 aufhörte. Heute identifiziere ich mich als maskuline Butch-Frau und bereue es nicht, meinen Körper so zu belassen, wie er ist, auch wenn meine Stimme nie ganz zu ihrem Klang vor dem Testosteron zurückkehrte. Zur Detransition kam ich, als ich erkannte, dass meine Dysphorie mit anderen Problemen zusammenhing, darunter familiärer Druck, Männer zu daten, und der Wunsch, der Sexualisierung als Frau zu entkommen. Ich kritisiere, wie bereitwillig Hormone und Operationen angeboten werden, besonders jungen Menschen, und trete dafür ein, bis 25 zu warten, bevor man solche Entscheidungen trifft. Ich glaube nicht an eine angeborene Geschlechtsidentität, wohl aber, dass Geschlechtsdysphorie ein reales Leiden ist, das sich mit Therapie auflösen kann.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female, and I came to identify as trans and live as a man for a period before detransitioning. My own story is tangled up with a lot of the things I now write about on r/detrans, so I'll try to lay it out as honestly as I can.
Growing up, I struggled with my body and with how people treated me because of being female. I don't have exact ages for when the dysphoria first showed up, but by the time I was an adult I had come to understand myself as transgender and I began medically transitioning. I took testosterone for a number of years — long enough that my voice dropped noticeably and stayed that way — and I lived socially as a man during that time. Part of what had pushed me toward transition was pressure from my family to date men; I've said before that "when I had the pressure my family was putting on my to date men removed via transition I never forced myself to date men again, and I've never looked back. So for me transition was an escape from the pressure/coercion to be straight." That realization came later, but in retrospect it was one of the clearest motivations I had.
I eventually stopped taking testosterone. As of March 2022 I had been off hormones for about two years, and I posted a recording of my voice asking the community whether I was "deluding myself" or whether I sounded female again. A surgeon had told me that without testosterone some muscles atrophy, including throat muscles, and that the medical community still doesn't know everything about how hormones affect the body, vocal cords included. I've accepted that my voice won't fully return to what it was — I've told others in the same position that after a long enough time on T they'll probably get some lightening and lose some bass, but that they'll have to make peace with it because "it will never go back to what it was." For my own part, I'm still butch, and I've said I don't want to sound like an "anime cat girl" — I just wanted to sound female again.
I don't regret keeping what I kept, though. When someone told me I looked like a "cute butch," I replied that I felt lucky I kept it. That's roughly where I've landed: I'm a masculine woman, and I've come to believe that's enough. I've written that "taking testosterone isn't making you a man: just giving you the appearance of one. You're a masculine woman either way: might as well just embrace that."
What moved me toward detransition was a slow accumulation of thinking and reading, plus seeing patterns in other people's stories. I've become convinced that gender dysphoria is a real disorder but that it often stems from or co-occurs with other conditions, and that it can alleviate without surgery or hormones by addressing the underlying issues. I've written that "the only difference between a trans person and a Detrans person is that the source of the detrans person's dysphoria was resolved." I don't believe in an innate gender identity or a gendered soul; I've said explicitly, "I believe gender dysphoria is a real condition: I don't believe in an inner gender identity that trumps biological sex." I've also compared the body dysmorphia we call dysphoria to anorexia — delusional thinking, an endless list of body changes needed before you'll be happy, and a community that affirms body hatred — and I've noted that a lot of detransitioners, myself included by implication, struggled with eating disorders before identifying as trans.
I don't have a formal diagnosis I've shared, but I've discussed bipolar disorder (mania leading to delusional thinking and impulsive decisions) and borderline personality disorder (not having a solid sense of self, making people susceptible to social contagion) as frameworks that explain what happened to people like me. I've described transition itself as something that can become "a black hole" — always a new surgery, a new revision, a new sexuality to come out as.
On the whole I'm critical of how transition is currently offered, especially to young people. I've argued that mentally ill adults susceptible to manipulation can't truly consent when there's an echo chamber of affirmation and self-diagnosis, and that clinicians "aren't just hormone dispensers and surgery machines." I've advised a younger person questioning their gender to wait until 25, when brain and body stop developing, before making an informed decision. I don't think transition should be shamed for everyone, but I clearly think it's pushed on people whose dysphoria has other sources.
My mental health has improved since detransitioning, though I don't have specific diagnoses or treatment details to share. I'm not currently on any hormones or medical interventions related to transition. I still present butch and I'm comfortable with that. I haven't described suicidal ideation or self-harm in these posts.