Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter/desistierter Mann, der sich innerlich als nichtbinär identifizierte, aber als Mann auftritt, und nach einem „Egg-Crack“-Moment, in dem ich beinahe Östrogen in Mikrodosis erwogen hätte, entschied ich, dass ich mit meinem Körper, so wie er ist, glücklich bin. Ich bin cis-hetero, in Detrans- und gender-kritischen Räumen aktiv, kritisiere sowohl die Transgender-Ideologie als auch Teile des medizinischen Establishments und stütze mich für mein Weltbild auf Samkhya, Buddhismus, Yoga und Vedanta. Ich habe kein nennenswertes medizinisches Bedauern, da ich nie transitioniert bin, bin aber frustriert über den Verlust des ehrlichen Dialogs über Geschlecht. Ich setze mich für Körperpositivität und Selbstreflexion als Alternativen zur Transition ein und bin mit meinem Leben im Allgemeinen zufrieden.
Vollständige Geschichte
I've never really fit into the gender-critical box people expect, and I've never fit into the trans box either. I internally identify as non-binary, but externally I present and pass as a man for all intents and purposes. I was born male and I'm cis-het as far as anyone else is concerned — though in a perfect world I sometimes joke I'd have been born a woman running a lesbian separatist organization, maybe a militia.
I had what people online call an "egg crack" moment and almost considered microdosing estrogen, but I found the detrans communities here and realized no one really knows what they're doing. I don't think I would have gone through with it anyway, because my views on ontology are rooted in Asian metaphysics rather than Western gender theory, Freud, or the Abrahamic idea of a soul. In the end I'm actually happy with my body — I like looking like a lanky, flat man with a skinny feminine face. I don't think estrogen would have been what I wanted.
Part of what complicated things for me was how I look. I lost a lot of weight during the pandemic and my face got thinner, and I've always been lanky. My hair is below my shoulders and I wear it in a ponytail out of convenience. Delivery drivers and cashiers have called me "ma'am" even when I let my beard grow out a little. I walked into a men's bathroom at the airport recently and got looks of surprise. From straight on I doubt anyone would read me as female, but from certain angles — my cheekbones, jaw, lanky figure — I get "ma'am" occasionally. The older I get, the more of it I get, which is the opposite of what people warn about with "twink death."
There's a family dimension too. I always remembered the way my grandma adorned her face in feminine gold and diamond jewelry, common among religious Hindus and usually passed down to daughters and daughters-in-law. I used to gaze at her features enviously when I was young. Once I can afford it, I intend to get the same piercings and feminine jewelry she wore. My mom recently asked me if I'm "trying to be a woman," and I told her I literally don't care about gender theory, I don't believe in any of it, I'm just me — whatever anyone else sees me as, I don't care.
I came to these communities partly because I thought I might have AGP, but my experiences don't match what others with AGP report. I've read the research — the study on GAMP describing it as an unusual form of heterosexuality correlated with autogynephilia — and I've engaged with those ideas, but they don't describe me. When I lived in cities I hung out with GBTQ friend groups and went to a lot of electronic music clubs and concerts. My friend group was diverse in interests, career, and sexuality. I noticed the community was fairly promiscuous and serious relationships were rare — mostly two masculine gay guys, or an older guy with a basic twink. I never put it together until later that the feminine males likely never ended up in serious relationships.
I've thought a lot about what drives people toward transition. My working theory is that transgender ideology is a curse on women — men want to look like the "perfect" woman and perpetuate unrealistic standards, while women who feel far from "perfect" think they'll have an easier time as a man. It's the same play on women's insecurities taken to the extreme. I think many MtFs are drawn to stereotypical female roles as portrayed by male writers and animators — anime characters, video game characters — and that many are gay or have AGP and want a straight man to treat them like the woman of media stereotype. I've argued that FTM detransitioners can ideally yoke themselves out of that psyop, find support among other women, practice body positivity, delete Instagram, and unfollow beauty and fitness influencers. I've said MTF detransitioners are more pathologically latched onto it.
I'm critical of the medical side but not uniformly. I've defended top surgeons against being lumped in with everything else — top surgery seems fairly transactional and among the most benign interventions. I've said bottom surgeons give me the heebie-jeebies and that the secondary effects of bottom surgery and HRT are probably still mostly unknown. I'm skeptical of the financial-conspiracy framing — I've asked what the evidence is that specialists are making that much more, and argued physicians are probably just as confused as everyone else, comparing it to psychiatry where no one knows how the medications really work. I doubt doctors are getting massive kickbacks like it's OxyContin; hormones can be manufactured at home relatively easily.
I've also gotten into the weeds of feminist separatism. I've described second-wave lesbian separatism as a strategy feminists theorized could force radical societal change quickly — the most radical form involving convincing all women to embrace lesbianism and physically separate from mainstream society. I've said this scares men because women technically only need a source of sperm, and I've framed the mainstreaming of "radial gender ideology" as a kind of MKUltra-style social conditioning pipeline — a deliberate sabotage of radical feminism. I've speculated that men in power struggle to confront their "profound uselessness" and so psyop radical transhumanism into the mainstream.
Spiritually, I lean on Samkhya, Buddhism, yoga, and Vedanta. I've recommended Samkhya to others as a logical approach to metaphysics and psychology thousands of years older than Freud, and Buddhism if Samkhya is too esoteric. I've quoted Vivekananda's Parliament of Religions translations about all paths leading to the divine, and told someone expressing a wish to "cease existing" that it sounded straight from the Buddha's mouth and that other perspectives exist. I see ontology as a superset that includes gender, and I say I study ontology, not gender.
I'm not a civil rights activist and I don't pretend to be. I've said the trans movement is widely seen as people creating problems for themselves and then complaining, and that these issues could probably be handled more effectively with standard therapy and Buddhism. I'm critical of both political "sides" and skeptical of gender-critical spaces too — I've noted that Genspect has good talking points but lacks diversity, being mainly old white people who talk sense about gender but have other conservative qualities that gatekeep the community. I've recommended Buck Angel's channel as touching on trans men, lesbian women, and cis women. I don't experience dramatic regret because I never medically transitioned — my main frustration is with the broader discourse and the loss of honest dialogue, which I blame on the backlash against "TERFs." Overall I'm in a decent place: comfortable in my body, close to my family, engaged with ideas I find meaningful, and content to just be me.