Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter bzw. desistierter Mann, der sich um 2020–2021 kurz als trans identifizierte (laut eigener Aussage „ROGD wie aus dem Lehrbuch“), aber nie Hormone begann, vor allem weil mein Freund es mir ausredete. Anfang 2022 wurde bei mir eine bipolare Störung Typ 1 diagnostiziert, und nach der Behandlung verschwand meine Geschlechtsdysphorie, auch wenn ich weiterhin gender-nonkonform bin und mich als autogynäphil identifiziere. Ich hatte eine psychiatrische Krise, die zu einer Zwangseinweisung führte, nachdem meine Mutter die Polizei gerufen hatte. Heute schreibe ich kritisch über Gender-Identitäts-Ideologie, Bejahung und medizinische Transition bei Jugendlichen und setze mich dafür ein, Detransitionierten und Zweifelnden abweichende Perspektiven zu bieten.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male, and I'm 29 years old as of my most detailed account in September 2022. I had a childhood ADHD diagnosis and was medicated for it from middle school through college. I also describe myself as neurodivergent and as having bipolar 1 disorder (manic depressive), which I was diagnosed with about eight months before September 2023 — so roughly January 2022.
Around two years before that account (roughly 2020), I developed what I call Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria. I became obsessed with my body and my mannerisms and began questioning my gender. A year before the account (roughly 2021), I discovered the subreddit r/egg_irl, which I said was "a particularly toxic place in 2020 that directly influenced my decisions regarding transition" and which "substantially increased my distress." That led me to go to my doctor convinced I was secretly intersex; I demanded genetic testing from a "very bemused primary care physician," and I called that day "among my biggest traumas" because I felt insane. I also recall a period where I was so "effed in the head" that I believed I had a vagina inside me all along and that surgeons only had to dig it out — which I now recognize as irrational.
I never actually started hormones. I "very nearly" started estrogen, but my boyfriend talked me down and showed me literature on the dangers. I've described him as "actively opposed to my transition" and as "a voice of reason" — I said I wasn't being reasonable at the time and I'm happy he intervened. I identify this pattern as textbook ROGD: I was reading "really toxic stuff on the internet" that compounded with stress and my mental illness "into one hell of a whirlwind."
I also describe myself as an autogynephile: "I do suffer from a touch of autogynophilia as well, so it all compounds together." Elsewhere I wrote, "I am an autogynephile, but I have not transitioned, and I have no plans to," explaining that I wish I were a "4 foot nothing chick" while I'm a "6 foot something penis-haver," and that pursuing that fantasy would only lead to disappointment because it isn't fulfillable. Instead, I say, "every day I choose to be a good man."
I also describe internalized feelings of inadequacy about performing the role of my gender as where my problems started. I've said my marriage was failing and my job was failing and I was "desperate for a reason for that to all make sense" — I thought gender explained it, but it was many things coming to a head. In another comment I said I was being ousted from a career of 10 years while my wife was seeing other men, and that "it completely broke my brain." I later said I left my marriage for a guy. Separately, I mentioned being married for 5 years to a woman who preferred "new sexual conquests" to a stable relationship.
After starting treatment for bipolar 1, my dysphoria went away. I wrote: "I am still gender-non conforming, but I care a lot less about how I present to others, and I suffer from no gender dysphoria. I am in a much better place now." What helped was shifting from worrying about how I needed others to see me to how I'd like to see myself, plus therapy and self-improvement. I also had a serious mental health crisis: after losing sleep, not eating, and becoming increasingly erratic, my mom called the cops, I was deemed a danger to myself, and I was sectioned and involuntarily held for treatment at a psychiatric hospital. I've said, "Not saying all trans people are nuts, but I know I was, literally."
I also found religion around roughly the same time I believed I was trans. My current gender I describe as "complicated"; I've had long-term relationships with both men and women, and during each I preferred to express my gender differently. At one point I was "somewhat romantically involved with a lesbian."
On sexuality, I've suggested internalized homophobia may be at play for others in similar situations, and I've noted that I like masculine women more than most men. I describe myself as a man who previously felt inferior to self-assured figures and "almost became a woman because I thought I couldn't hack it as a man," but after therapy and self-improvement I concluded I'm "the best man I know."
I'm now quite critical of transition as currently practiced, especially for minors. I call trans an "idealogy" rather than science, argue that affirmation and overvalidation can push people toward medical intervention they'd otherwise talk themselves out of, and say "encouraging them all to go on hormones is child abuse." I've argued that not everyone who thinks they are trans is trans, that gender identity ideology erases detransitioners by definition, and that sex is not a spectrum. I've recommended the book TRANS by Helen Joyce. I've also done some research-style commenting, working through sources on suicidality statistics and on claims about sex being changeable after birth. I describe my advocacy as trying to give dissenting opinions to people considering transition so they "go in with your eyes open."
I regret how long it took me to realize the direction I was being pushed was wrong, and I've said "damn I didn't need this" about the whole pursuit — that it was more about what I was chasing than what I wanted.