Alle Geschichten

Reversibel, hieß es – jetzt versteckt sie den Beweis unter Schals

Weiblich · Detransitioniert149
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die als Frau geboren wurde und einen Teil ihres Lebens als Mann lebte. Mir wurde gesagt, Hormone seien reversibel, und ich nenne das heute eine Lüge; manche Veränderungen gingen nie weg, und ich verstecke sie unter Schals. Was mich bewegte, war die Erkenntnis, dass es keine wissenschaftliche Forschung hinter den Behauptungen gab, die man mir gemacht hatte – keinen belegten Gehirnunterschied zwischen trans und cis Menschen und keine soliden Diagnosekriterien für Geschlechtsdysphorie –, was bei mir kognitive Dissonanz auslöste. Ich greife auf mein Wissen über Sucht zurück, um zu überlegen, wie man Menschen erreicht, die noch in der Transition stecken, und glaube, dass öffentliches Sprechen Leben retten kann. Genaue Daten zu meinen eigenen Transitionsmeilensteinen habe ich in dem, was ich geschrieben habe, nicht genannt, daher bleiben sie offen.

Vollständige Geschichte

I'm writing this from where I've landed after going through transition and coming back out the other side. I was born female, and I came to identify as trans and live as a man for a period of my life. I was told, along the way, that hormones were totally reversible — I now describe that as a lie I was told, and I'm in the same position as other people who were told the same thing: the changes don't just go away or reverse themselves. I've had to learn to live with what's permanent on my body, or hide it; these days I wear a lot of scarves, and I don't mind that. The thing that broke the spell for me was realising there was no scientific research to back up what I'd been told. I came to believe there is no brain difference between trans and cis people, whereas there are slight, scientifically documented differences between straight and gay people's brains. I also don't think there's a proper diagnostic criteria for gender dysphoria — I've watched therapists quote contradictory things at people, saying things like "you don't need GD to be trans" while others disagree, and vice versa. Without set procedures and heavy research, nobody really knows what they're talking about, and once that illusion breaks it's highly noticeable. The word I'd use for what I felt when it broke is cognitive dissonance — and when someone else used that phrase, I said "me too." I've drawn on my knowledge of addiction in thinking about how to help people who are in transition now: what I know from addiction is that people need to want to help themselves, otherwise they won't accept help from anyone else. I'm not sure we can reach people who aren't ready. I also know from the other side that you're going to get a lot of shit when you speak about this, but also a lot of support, and you should lean on that support. I believe a person's voice and experiences could potentially save lives, which makes speaking out extremely important — that's advice I gave to someone else and it's how I feel about my own position too. On being female, I've thought a lot about what femininity even means: nails, hair, make-up, dresses? I don't use any of those things and I'm no less female for it. Being female is just existing, as is being male — it's just being human. I've told others, and I hold to it, that even females don't "know how to be female," and that we change and grow and aren't the same person at 5 as at 16 as at 30. I've also reacted strongly — "this hits home so hard" — to other people's accounts of regret and reversal. At the same time I don't think we should police language: I've argued that woman, girl and female are just descriptive words in a language, and that we shouldn't tell someone what they can and can't call themselves, especially among people who've been through this. I don't have explicit dates in what I've written for when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, when I started hormones, or when I detransitioned, so I'm leaving those blank rather than guessing. What I can say plainly is that I'm detransitioned, I'm female, and I'm speaking about it because I think the truth about what transition does — and the lack of evidence behind what I was told — needs to be said out loud.