Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin selbst nie transitioniert, aber eine Frau, die über 12 Jahre lang die Antibabypille genommen hat, eine schwierige Schwangerschaft und Geburt durchgemacht hat und jetzt eine Tochter hat, die ich über alles liebe. Ich bin zu einer lautstarken Kritikerin von Online-Trans-Communitys geworden und dränge zweifelnde junge Menschen, diese Gruppen zu verlassen, eine Therapie ohne Gender-Fokus zu suchen und bis mindestens 21 zu warten, bevor sie dauerhafte medizinische Veränderungen in Betracht ziehen. Ich glaube, dass Körperunbehagen ein normaler Teil der Pubertät ist und dass Transition kein Heilmittel gegen Depressionen oder Angst ist. Meine aktuelle Identität ist die einer Frau und Mutter, die der Detrans-Community nahesteht und nie medizinisch transitioniert ist.
Vollständige Geschichte
I never transitioned myself, but I have spent a lot of time in online spaces watching other people's stories unfold, and I have my own experience with long-term hormones in the form of the contraceptive pill, pregnancy, and motherhood.
I was on the contraceptive pill for over 12 years, starting from a young teen, for multiple reasons. I took consecutive pill packets so I only had about four periods a year. Coming off it took many months before my cycle was even roughly regular — by 'regular' I mean the length could still vary by two weeks — and well over a year before I became pregnant. It was heartbreaking at the time: it seemed everyone around me was getting positive pregnancy tests or accidentally falling pregnant while it wasn't happening for me. My doctor was about to start me on some medication to help regulate things when, coincidentally, I became pregnant just before I was due to start it.
I assume coming off testosterone would be a similar wait for natural hormones to regulate and kick in. I never transitioned and I wouldn't say I had severe dysphoria, but the return of periods and the pregnancy itself were really tough. I hated the whole pregnancy and birth. I couldn't face breastfeeding and hated waiting for the milk to dry up. It was six months after birth before I even felt anywhere close to being 'me'. My body changed too, which triggered a whole new set of dislikes — I hated my nipples getting darker, I hated my stretch marks, I hated my 'mum tum'. I view those changes as battle scars now. But having this little human who thinks I'm the best thing in the world made it impossible to hate myself as much; it's so important to me that I don't pass on self-esteem or body-confidence issues to her by her learning bad things from me, and in turn I've come to accept myself more. Now she's the best thing that's ever happened to me and I don't regret a thing — though I've said I'm not doing it again to have another.
Parenting is hard work, not going to lie. There are times when you cry, times when you're so worn down and tired you don't think you can go on, times when the monotony gets too much. But then there are amazing times — her giggles, her childlike perspective on things I'd never notice, cuddles, splashing in the bath, sharing, reading stories. It's worth it.
In online spaces I've become quite vocal about cautioning young people against rushing into transition. I've told a young person struggling with anxiety and depression that those are huge 'except' conditions, and that changing gender may not be the magic answer — they could transition fully and still feel the same way because of depression or GAD. I recommended getting therapy, but explicitly not a gender therapist, to explore issues beyond gender. I've argued that feeling uncomfortable about your body is a normal part of puberty, tied to the realisation that you're on the way to adulthood and its responsibilities. I've listed questions I think people should ask themselves: whether it's about disliking the role or stereotype females play in society, disliking the sexualisation that comes with female body part development, uncertainty about one's own sexuality, traditional beauty ideals, comments from others affecting self-esteem, friendships, or comparing yourself to the way males are treated.
I've been blunt about the permanence of medical transition — 'Permanent, irreversible changes to your body you could regret' — and I've used my own example of being adamant as a younger person that I'd get a huge ankle tattoo, and being glad years later that I didn't. My rule of thumb is to wait at least a year for any big change, and if you're young, wait until 21.
I've strongly criticised trans groups for giving biased or skewed views, describing 'propaganda, pressure and idealisation about being trans', and I've said that group members may seize on aspects of someone's experience and declare 'you're trans' when many other teenagers feel the same without jumping to that conclusion. I've urged people to cold-turkey from trans groups, comparing it to depression groups where everyone just talks about how unhappy they are — nice for feeling less alone but unhealthy long-term and only serving to spiral lower. I've also urged dropping self-harm subreddits in favour of things like r/aww and real hobbies and interests.
I've reacted with anger to advice given to a questioning young person, saying I felt 'so so angry' at some of it and that I was 'pretty much begging' them to leave trans groups, worried they'd go down a painful route unnecessarily and regret it. I compared the grooming-like quality of that advice to 'a peadophile grooming someone underage'. I've rebutted slogans like 'Trans with doubts doesn't equal cis' by insisting that if you have doubts you have them for a reason, and 'Dysphoria doesn't necessarily mean you're miserable' by arguing that if you don't mind being a girl you should stay a girl rather than transition with severe side effects. I've said questioning your gender does not mean you're trans, and that trans is completely separate from sexuality.
I've also advised keeping parents and friends as the main allies and support network, warning that some groups might play parents or friends as enemies for daring to question transitioning, and cautioning against isolation from family in future relationships too. I've encouraged someone to talk to their mum, ask for a hug when feeling down, and told them they might end up being trans but most likely won't. I've asked a detransitioner what made them detransition, and I've apologised when my non-transition-related replies landed in a 'detrans replies only' thread, offering to delete. I've also given practical advice about contraceptive placebo pills and periods returning, deferring to prescribers for medical questions.