Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte, desistierte lesbische Frau, die sich sozial zum Mann transitionierte, aber nie Hormone oder Operationen in Anspruch nahm. Meine Transition wurde getrieben von lebenslangem Mobbing wegen Geschlechtsnonkonformität, Trauma wegen meines jungenhaften Körpers, internalisierter Misogynie und Homophobie und dem Wunsch, der Objektifizierung des Mädchenseins zu entkommen. Ich detransitionierte, nachdem ich diese Wurzeln erkannt hatte, und identifiziere mich heute als gender-kritisch, in der Überzeugung, dass Transition fälschlich als Heilmittel für Trauma und Misogynie angeboten wird. Ich setze mich aktiv für Räume nur für Lesben ein und warne Mädchen vor dem, was ich für einen schädlichen Trend halte. Ich habe keinen laufenden medizinischen Bedarf und arbeite daran, meinen Körper und meine Weiblichkeit anzunehmen.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and I have always been a tomboy. Growing up, I was bullied relentlessly for being gender-nonconforming, and I never really related to other girls. When other girls entered puberty I still looked like a little boy, and both girls and boys bullied me for my appearance. I have basically no curves, I'm really skinny, and I have really small breasts, and I carry a lot of trauma related to my figure. Seeing how girls started to be objectified by men once they hit puberty — and how some of them willingly took part in it — made me sick to the point of being repulsed by my own body. I also have an intense Adam's apple, which I never got from transitioning.
Because of all this, I romanticized the idea of living as a boy. Turning into a handsome teen boy who didn't have to deal with the problems of womanhood, who could be himself without being tortured for it, and who could perform femininity without being associated with a woman, felt like the perfect escape from the trauma of being a girl. I socially transitioned and lived as a man. Luckily I couldn't access gender-affirming treatment, so I was never on testosterone and never had any medical interventions — only social transition. I later learned that the term for what I am is "desisted."
Coming to terms with my sexuality was also part of the process. Realizing I was a lesbian took a lot of introspection and was a traumatic process. When I identified as trans I did insane mental gymnastics to convince myself I was a gay trans man: I was in denial about being a lesbian because of internalized misogyny, but I obviously didn't like men either, so I gaslit myself into thinking I only liked transmasculine twinks — women who kept many feminine characteristics, including their genitalia.
What moved me toward detransition and gender-critical views was a combination of recognizing internalized misogyny and homophobia, childhood trauma, and undiagnosed disorders as the real roots of my discomfort. I came to the conclusion that masculinity and men have been glorified for centuries, so misogyny is heavily imprinted in all of us, and that some people have found a way to disguise their misogyny as "gender dysphoria." I believe transition is being presented as the only solution to an amalgamation of internalized misogyny and homophobia, childhood trauma, and undiagnosed disorders. I also think being gender-nonconforming is not about your body but about behavior, expression, and interests, and that the right response is to be a gender-nonconforming woman and tell people it doesn't make you any less of a woman.
I am a med student, and I've looked at older psychiatry textbooks which describe that homosexuality was, among diagnosed gender-dysphoria patients, even less common than in the general population — a trend I think is worth noting given how common it is now. I consider myself gender critical. I believe there are two sexes and two genders (made-up expectations) for those sexes, that you don't have to comply with the gender expectations assigned to your sex, but that you shouldn't "change" your sex. I do think that if someone is trans, has a genuine diagnosed gender dysphoria, and there is no other way to stop their suffering, it makes sense to transition — but I think it's a bad idea to transition if you don't have gender dysphoria, and I've said "transition is turning into conversion therapy."
I am a lesbian, and a lot of my activism has been about lesbian spaces. I wrote a strongly worded post about being sick of males invading lesbian spaces, arguing that most "transbians" are autogynephilic men fetishizing being a lesbian, that lesbians are being pushed to transition to men or identify as non-binary to conform to heteronormative expectations, and that transgenderism is turning into rampant misogyny and male supremacy. I later walked back the intensity of it, saying I was "kind of deranged" when I wrote it and that I don't think all transbians are autogynephilic or intentionally infiltrating, but that it still deeply hurts lesbians. I've also expressed frustration about the main lesbian subreddit being flooded with trans women. I believe trans gay women and men exist but are such a coincidence they shouldn't be a topic of polarization.
I had a difficult childhood socially: I was that weirdo who didn't know how to communicate with people, I had no friends because I was so socially awkward I was always left out, I spent my whole childhood picked last in PE and walking alone in circles during lunch breaks while the other kids played together. I have lived as both genders and passed as a guy, and I was equally lonely in both — I reject the idea that women get more attention by default. I also note that in my culture everyone works and there is no such thing as a stay-at-home mom, which informs my view that traditional gender roles are cultural rather than biological.
I still feel uncomfortable with my period, but I slowly learned to accept it by first accepting my womanhood. I'm learning to accept my masculine features — broad shoulders, minimal curves, facial and body hair — as simply how I'm meant to be. I want a family in the future and I find my job fulfilling as a central part of my life. I'm against having a detrans flag, though I feel the symbol resonates with me, I don't want to appropriate it. I don't regret any medical changes because I never had any, but I do regret the time and identity spent living as a man and the romanticization that led me there. I advocate for girls and young women, saying "all we can do is spread the word to open people's eyes and save girls from this craze."