Alle Geschichten

Eine katholische Erziehung ließ Femininität schlimmer erscheinen als Trans-Sein

Männlich · Desistiert495
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein femininer schwuler Mann, der sich kurz als sie/they nichtbinär identifizierte und eine Transition erwog, aber nie medizinisch transitioniert ist, und ich identifiziere mich heute als desistierter schwuler Mann. Ich wurde in einem starren, homophoben katholischen Umfeld erzogen, das mir beibrachte, ein femininer schwuler Mann zu sein sei der schlimmstmögliche Ausgang, und mich glauben ließ, ich sei als Transfrau besser dran. Ich komme aus der Transitions-Denkweise heraus, kämpfe aber noch mit etwas Geschlechtsdysphorie, die mit meiner Sexualität, internalisierter Homophobie, der Angst vor dem Älterwerden als Mann und tiefer Einsamkeit beim Dating zusammenhängt, und dem Umstand, nie Sex mit einem Mann gehabt zu haben. Ich hatte nie eine Operation und war nie auf Hormonen. Ich setze mich für Raum für schwule männliche Desistierende und Detransitionierende ein und wehre mich gegen Geschlechterstereotype.

Vollständige Geschichte

I am a 25-year-old gay man, very feminine, and a virgin, and I've struggled throughout my life with both my sexuality and my gender identity. I went to a conservative Catholic elementary school, and at age 8 I was punished with detention along with the rest of the boys in my class because two boys threw food (a pastry) at a teacher, while the girls received no punishment. I went home and cried to my conservative parents that I wished I was a girl. That was the first major event that planted the seed that being a boy was something to escape. Before that, I remember being shunned and disciplined at various times for doing "girl things," wearing "girl clothes," or speaking with the "wrong" inflection. I grew up in a very Catholic environment where girls were called "beautiful flowers" by teachers and religious leaders and treated like they could do no wrong, while boys were punished collectively. There is also a lot of trauma from later things, including a homophobic family — especially my fanatically religious mother — and an even worse religious high school experience that I don't feel comfortable going into in detail. A friend told me I have internalized homophobia and religious trauma. My rigid, conservative upbringing led me to believe that my love for men and my feminine attributes meant I'd be better off as a trans woman. God was what made me hate myself as a gay male and see my only option as transitioning to fit the heterosexual standard. About a year before my December 2023 post, or a little more, I started privately identifying as "she/they nonbinary" to some pro-trans friends. Most of them were very supportive in a backhanded way, saying things like "oh this makes sense, you wear crop tops and have long hair and have a pretty face so we knew it was only a matter of time." Looking back, that makes me angry — I had expected increased trans acceptance to liberate gender nonconforming people too. I still use those pronouns with some friends, but I have started making it increasingly clear that I am a feminine gay man who just presents femininely. I never medically transitioned; I am glad I didn't go through with transition, and I don't think medically transitioning is worth it to me at this point. I'm mainly talking about how I look and present myself. I now realize I thought I was trans because being a straight woman would be a more desirable existence than being a feminine gay man. To a degree I still think this, but I now realize I was running away from something and not truly gender dysphoric. I still struggle with a bit of gender dysphoria that I think is related to my sexuality, and I have a lot of trouble wrapping my head around being perceived as a man. I have realized I'm extremely homophobic in the sense that I viewed — and to a degree still view — being a feminine gay man as the worst, most dismal possible outcome for my life. I'm glad I never went that far, but I'm still very much struggling with being a feminine gay man, because I was always taught that's pretty much THE recipe for a bleak outcome. I feel like such a joke. I actually like my male body most of the time and don't want to be a woman specifically. I love looking femme, having long hair, and wearing crop tops — it feels the most "me." I just wish I could be comfortable being that without the added baggage of being gay and feminine, and without people pressuring me to transition because I don't conform to gender stereotypes. I'm not willing to compromise on my appearance because I genuinely look horrible masc, and my mannerisms are mostly innate — I'm not going to "butch up" for someone else's sake. I am gay through and through and am not attracted to masc women or trans men. I've been doing well lately with getting out of the transition mindset, but I'm still scared of aging as a man and as a feminine gay man, and I really don't like thinking about it. I already feel really unwanted and undesirable as a single gay man and I fear it's only going to get worse. I've had one boyfriend in my entire life — a short-term, long-distance relationship over half a decade ago — and I have still never had sex with a man, as the idea terrifies me. I'm watching all my straight friends get partnered up and advance in life while I feel lonely and stagnant. I have trouble connecting with gay and bi men: most I've encountered want to have sex with me but don't see me as a valid partner. Gay men only want sex, and bi men treat me as a fetish until they find a woman to settle down with. I think about sex constantly and hate myself for not being able to bring myself to just do it. All I want is a male partner to love me unconditionally — I've never felt that before — and I daydream about wild, passionate sex with a man who loves me. I hope I can find a boyfriend who gets it someday. Men on dating apps often assume, rather than ask, that I'm trans — most of the time they think I'm FTM, sometimes MTF — which upsets me given how frequently it happens. I have a fairly small and feminine build and a feminine face. I've also been called transphobic by multiple trans men who propositioned me on dating apps, some very sexually aggressive, even after only a polite "sorry, not interested," and I've seen trans men on Twitter refer to gay men as "cissies." I proposed that there should be a space for gay male desisters and detrans people as well, because I have gotten hate in existing communities too. I've told another feminine gay man that I find him inspiring and asked to DM, and I've reached out to others in a similar position to offer support. I'm still working on my internalized homophobia. I believe men can be pretty, clean, and soft with or without body hair, and that we don't have to conform to standards either way — whether that means transitioning to fit feminine standards or forcing ourselves to look rugged to fit a masculine role. Embracing my innate gender nonconforming qualities helped me fall in love with being a man and appreciate both my masculine and feminine traits, and I push back when others enforce the stereotypes that got many of us here in the first place.