Alle Geschichten

Ein Jahr „Was, wenn ich trans bin“ – und nie daran geglaubt

Männlich · Desistiert493
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein cisgender Mann, der nie transitionieren wollte, aber etwa ein Jahr lang in zwangsähnlichen, aufdringlichen „Was, wenn ich trans bin“-Gedanken gefangen war, getrieben von Depression, einer Essstörung, kindlicher Unsicherheit wegen meines Vaters, starren Geschlechterrollen-Erwartungen und pornobefeuertem Neid darauf, wie Mädchen scheinbar geliebt und begehrt werden. Ich sehe mich als Desister/Hinterfragenden: Ich habe nie Hormone genommen oder mich operieren lassen und sage durchgehend, dass meine Geschlechtsidentität männlich ist – ich wünsche mir nur, dass die Gedanken aufhören. Ich gehe zu einem zugelassenen Gender-Therapeuten, der nicht denkt, dass ich trans bin, und der mir geholfen hat zu sehen, dass Überzeugungen wie „nur Frauen werden geliebt“ nicht auf der Realität beruhen. Im September 2020, an meinem Tiefpunkt, hatte ich kurz das Gefühl aufzugeben und erwähnte, dass ich mich nicht im Sinne eines Suizids umbringen wollte, sondern eher im Sinne von Drogen und selbstverletzendem Verhalten. Im Moment arbeite ich an Gedankenwahrnehmung und Atemtechniken und daran, von Reddit wegzukommen, um den Kreislauf zu durchbrechen.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male and I have consistently understood my gender identity to be male — I've never genuinely believed I was a girl, and I've never wanted to transition. For the past year (roughly autumn 2019 through autumn 2020) I've been caught in an exhausting cycle of intrusive 'what if I'm trans' thoughts that I describe as OCD-like rather than real gender dysphoria. I consider myself a desister/questioner rather than someone who transitioned and came back. The first episode happened a couple of years ago after I saw trans porn for the first time — I was scared I might be trans for about a week, then it went away and I laughed about it. A few months later, after my girlfriend and I broke up and I moved out, another wave hit lasting a couple weeks; I tried wearing women's clothes while depressed, then lost interest entirely. About nine months after that the thoughts came back and never left — I've now been constantly obsessed for almost a full year, intensity fluctuating between about 40% and 100%. I've spent that time on trans forums, egg_irl, reading long academic works, and filling my notes app with reflections, challenges, and internal dialogues, always needing more. What drives the thoughts, as far as I can tell, isn't a female gender identity but a deep dissatisfaction with the male gender role. I feel enormous pressure to be strong, stoic, confident, self-assured, a provider — and I feel I'm failing at it. I look around my college campus and see other guys who seem so much more comfortable, more attractive options for the girls I'm interested in, and I feel ashamed for even being interested because I assume they want a different guy. I don't care about my degree, which makes it hard to be motivated. In my head, if I were an attractive girl I wouldn't need luck to be wanted; I'd be allowed to be sensitive, insecure, submissive, soft — I'd be allowed to be taken care of and loved. 'In my head the alternative to being a guy is being loved.' I've told myself that only women get to be loved, which my therapist has helped me see is not based in reality. I think a lot of this is rooted in my childhood. I grew up in an intense home where I felt very unsafe because of my dad, and I developed a poor relationship with masculinity and fatherly support. I was picked on for being a sensitive kind of guy without a father figure to help me develop a backbone. I've carried depression for about the last five years. I also have an eating disorder — I've joked that maybe it's keeping my testosterone levels low, and I've spent days lying in bed starving myself trying to figure out what gender I am. I've had health OCD before: I was once petrified I had a brain tumor, obsessed over it, had a panic attack that looked like a stroke, got an MRI that came back fine, and just in time my brain shifted focus to my gender identity. My therapist has noted my OCD tendencies and pointed out that his trans clients typically feel stressed living as their assigned gender, whereas imagining themselves as the other gender feels like something they want — for me, the opposite is true. Sexual factors are part of it too. I've said a huge portion of this is fueled by early exposure to porn and jealousy of the female body — the sense that girls feel better during sex, don't have to perform, can be submissive, are desired. I've described a FOMO about what I'm missing sexually by not being a girl, and almost a need to 'get inside the head of a girl' to understand them. I've framed pursuing transition out of sexual fantasy as pursuing a fetish as a life purpose, which I think feeds mental illness long-term. When I think about my exes or girls I want to date, the thoughts spike — it's almost negligible when I think of girls in general, especially ones I'm not attracted to. It seems tied to when I feel most critical of my place in the world and most self-conscious. I've never wanted to actually transition. I wouldn't press 'the button' unless I could go back. The idea of a bottle of HRT scares me; I'd take it for a week, see nothing happened, and stop. I don't have hatred of my penis. I do think I would become genuinely dysphoric if I transitioned to female. Yet around mid-September 2020 I hit a low point where I felt like giving up — I'd fought the thoughts for a full year, I wasn't eating, sleeping horribly, hated my major, didn't want to grow up, and briefly thought maybe becoming a girl would remove some pressure. I've prayed, cross-dressed, gone out with friends, and still couldn't get back to being myself. At that low point I mentioned not wanting to kill myself in terms of suicide, but in terms of drugs and self-harm behaviors. I've been seeing a therapist — a licensed gender therapist who works with lots of trans clients — since this began. He doesn't think I'm trans; he thinks I have a super rigid idea of gender roles, and his best advice has been to figure out which of my motivations to be a girl are based in reality (like 'only women get to be loved'). We've gone through what defines being a boy versus a girl and challenged the idea that certain traits are gendered. He's also recommended I just do things to keep my mind from torturing me — gender expression is maybe 10% of life. I've practiced breathing techniques to calm panic, tried agreeing with the intrusive thoughts as a kind of exposure ('okay, I am trans, we can stop now'), and worked on thought awareness. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't; it feels like a band-aid. I've noted that posting to Reddit and trying to prove my gender online actually fuels the OCD and leaves me more confused, and I've worried I'm manipulating the story to fit what I want to hear. I've reflected a lot on how online trans communities and 'signs you're trans' lists contribute — I noticed a list where 8 of 10 'signs' were just standard depression symptoms, and I've said they treat gender like a Buzzfeed quiz. I've also been critical of therapists who push gender-affirming pills after a couple of sessions, and of abstract concepts like 'internalized transphobia' that can't really be proven overcome. My current understanding is that when I have confidence and believe in myself, the thoughts go away — but that feeling has been gone so long I barely recognize it. I want to get back to genuinely laughing at the distress these thoughts caused me, because that's the only way I feel I can get back to being me. Right now I identify as a cis male dealing with OCD-like gender questioning, not as trans, and I'm still working with my therapist to break the loop.