Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and grew up in what I now describe as a very abusive, narcissistic family in northern Spain. My mother was, in my words, a "disturbed and narcissist toxic person who needs to control and damage everyone around her," and my father was a henpecked man she used as a weapon against me. From the time my little brother was born I became the focus of her abuse — insults, humiliations, threats, blackmail — and my father simply obeyed her, even telling me "don't make me choose between her and you because I am choosing her with no doubt." I was their emotional punchbag. I also suffered bullying at school for several years, so I had nowhere to go.
As a kid I never played with dolls or wore dresses, but I wasn't like the other boys either: I played with girls and did figure skating for many years, which brought bullying. I was ashamed of my genitalia from a young age and never wanted anyone to see it. When my puberty arrived, my mother started using my sexuality as a tool — dirty comments about masturbating — and when I reached an age where I didn't want them to see me naked, she became obsessed and forced me many times to show my genitalia to them, including forcing me to shower with my father as a teenager. Nothing sexual happened but I "felt totally RAPED" and I still feel rage about it. I consider this a form of sexual abuse even though it wasn't intended sexually. My father also walked around naked at home, which I found repulsive. They even called the police once after I reacted to her dirty comments, and my mother claimed to have a document proving I was insane — I later found it and it was fabricated.
I discovered I was gay as a teenager, which felt like something really wrong I had to hide. Around 16 I forced myself to go with the boys to stop the bullying, which didn't make me happy. I never felt gay or fit with the gay world — I never understood the way gay guys think, act or react — and I've struggled with what I call "inner homophobia" and "gayphobia" my whole life. I listed my symptoms of that: disgust at camp gay men, disgust for the gay world, envy of straight people, worry about loneliness, anger that straight people can have families easily, hating being seen as "gay" because it makes me feel weak, having considered conversion therapy, and hating that gay culture often seems to be only about sex.
Around age 20, after years of emotional and psychological abuse at home, I started noticing something was wrong with me and that I was different from other people, and I began thinking I would have been happier if I had been born female. I used videogames, especially online ones, as a refuge throughout those years. Around 23-25 I was about to come out as "trans" (I couldn't even name what I felt) but then I met my boyfriend and came out as gay instead. That relationship lasted almost 7 years; he inspired me to finish a degree and get a job. During that time I repressed the gender feelings.
After we broke up I moved back in with my mother, lost my job about a year later, and spiraled into a deep depression. All the trans feelings I had repressed came back. After watching many videos about transgender people I felt I related, so I went to a trans organization in my city. I had 2-3 months of therapy with a gender therapist — the sessions were focused only on transition, not on the rest of my life — and I could have gotten hormones on the first visit but chose to wait. I started mtf HRT in November 2018 at age 33: first spironolactone, then switched about a month later to cyproterone (Androcur), plus estrogen.
At first it felt right — "I finally found myself." Within about three days of starting, my long-standing depression, daily emotional ups and downs and mental "fog" vanished; I felt mentally balanced for the first time in my life, and I slept better. But as the months passed I became uncomfortable: watching my breasts grow gave me reverse dysphoria (my chest turning into tits was "awkward AF" and "kind of disgusting"), I felt shame at losing my muscles and physical strength and speed, and I started becoming dysphoric about things that never bothered me before (height, hands, shoulders, feet). I couldn't refer to myself as "she," couldn't pick a female name, and couldn't imagine myself living as a woman after so many years of living as male — my native languages (Spanish and another) mark gender in articles, adjectives and pronouns, which made it impossible. I also realized how much inner homophobia I had, and I saw what I considered the toxicity and manipulation of the trans community. I was "recluted at home most of the time during the transformation."
I stopped HRT cold turkey in March 2019 after 3.5 months. About 1.5-2 months after stopping I developed a huge telogen effluvium — massive hair shedding (30-50 hairs in the shower, shedding all day) — which my doctor attributed to the drastic estrogen drop; it lasted about a year and my hair fully recovered. My blood tests showed high DHEA and androstendione, later normalized, but FSH was 28.58 (normal 1.40-18.10), raising fertility concerns. My libido, which was already low, disappeared on HRT; after stopping, ejaculation was initially almost absent with a burning sensation, and everything returned to normal over roughly 2 months. My chest went back to its original size except for some tissue and enlarged nipples; I had a small, non-invasive nipple reduction surgery about 2 months after stopping HRT. I also had another minor surgery around that time (unspecified) plus an infection afterward, which together with stress contributed to the hair loss. I had no SRS or orchiectomy, which I consider "the (very) good part." I've also had laser hair removal on legs, armpits, neck and genital area, and got my ears pierced after stopping HRT.
About 1.5 months before April 2019 I made a suicide attempt, which I attribute to my mother. I stopped talking to her after that; I haven't seen my father in years. I was kicked out of the family home at some point. I later moved to another country to start again but my mental issues came with me — mood swings, the void, suicidal thoughts — so I returned. Stranded at an airport after losing a flight, I read about Borderline Personality Disorder and it felt like "reading the entire biography of my adult life." I booked a psychologist and psychiatrist, who confirmed the diagnosis after testing: I have BPD (all 9 criteria), and I've also been diagnosed with APD (avoidant personality disorder), PTSD and AVPD. I believe the BPD developed from my abusive childhood. I started DBT (dialectical behavior therapy) around mid-2020 and have been in it since; I've been in therapy generally for years.
Timeline of my identity: first dysphoric/traumatic feelings at puberty (teens); first "I wish I was born female" thoughts around age 20; almost came out as trans around 23-25 but came out as gay; started HRT November 2018 at 33; stopped March 2019 at 33/34; diagnosed with BPD in late 2019 at 34; nipple reduction surgery 2019; DBT started mid-2020; I was 35 in November 2020 and 36 in November 2021.
On causes, I believe my trans feelings came from childhood trauma and abuse, the resulting BPD and its identity disturbance, inner/repressed homophobia, and using transition as a way to escape my life and become someone else. I wrote: "I was trying to fix my inner traumas and my existential crisis by transitioning." I also think strict societal gender roles played a big part. I have never experienced anything sexual related to transition — no AGP, no crossdressing arousal; I never even crossdressed and find watching myself as a man in women's clothes "kinda gross." I'm only attracted to men.
On detransition process: what moved me was the physical changes feeling wrong, the realization I couldn't imagine living as a woman, discovering my inner homophobia, seeing the toxicity of the trans community, and understanding how my parents affected me. I "kicked out" my therapist because she only focused on transition. I found the BPD diagnosis later, on my own, which reframed everything. I've read detrans forums, watched a video on trauma and trans feelings that I called "one of the most useful videos I've ever seen," and DBT has helped: "the more I go into DBT the less often that feelings come."
Mental health: severe depression and daily mood swings before and after HRT (resolved only while on estrogen), chronic emptiness/"the awful void which is like a black hole," rage, identity disturbance, suicidal thoughts, one suicide attempt, self-harm tendencies associated with BPD. After years of therapy and DBT, my gender dysphoria has diminished "like 90 or 95%" and comes and goes, worsening under stress. I still say I would have been happier born female, but I no longer believe transition is for me. I describe myself as feeling like "a soulless person because of the BPD and the abuse."
Sexuality: I'm a gay man, only attracted to males. I had a 6-7 year relationship with a man. I've never been attracted to women and never experienced sexual arousal related to being female. I struggle with internalized homophobia. I isolated myself after stopping HRT and haven't been in a relationship since.
Regret: I explicitly say I do NOT regret trying HRT — "I don't regret the experience" — because it taught me about myself. What I regret/feel bad about: the enlarged nipples (fixed with surgery), the telogen effluvium, and the time lost. My main ongoing distress is the persistent gender feelings and identity confusion, not the medical changes. I have no irreversible surgical changes from transition itself.
Current status: I live as a gay man, detransitioned, and do not plan to transition again. I'm in DBT for BPD, dealing with PTSD and avoidant traits. My life is in "an awful standby mode" — I'm isolated, lost my job years ago, and struggle with daily functioning. I've said things like "sometimes I just think I will end up killing myself some day" (March 2020) and "I feel like I want to die" (November 2020), though by 2021 I reported things are better and more manageable.
Attitudes toward transition for others: I believe genuine transgender people exist and that transition can save lives for them, but I'm highly critical of what I call the "trans cult" — I was banned from a trans subreddit for saying "biological girls and trans girls." I argue many people transition for the wrong reasons (AGP, trauma, homophobia, misogyny, BPD, autism) and that hormones are given too easily. I've advocated for detransition awareness, criticized gender therapists for only affirming transition, and argued LGB should be separated from T. I regularly advise young people to seek non-gender therapy and explore trauma before transitioning, and I've told people with doubts to cancel life-changing surgeries.