Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine desistierte Frau, die heute maskulin auftritt und ohne Hormone oder Operationen als Frau glücklich ist. Ich desistierte, indem ich erkannte, dass Behauptungen der Trans-Community nicht stimmten, und indem ich begriff, dass soziale Ansteckung mich unbewusst in einen Körperhass getrieben hatte, den ich vorher nie gehabt hatte. Ich habe eine Autismus-Diagnose, die ich nach der Desistenz erhielt und die ich für falsch halte, und ich leide darunter, wegen meines maskulinen Auftretens und meines natürlichen Schnurrbarts ständig nach meinen Pronomen gefragt zu werden. Ich sehe die Trans-Bewegung kritisch, verweise auf schwache Detransitionsbelege und habe eine nichtbinäre Schwester, von der ich mich leise entfernt habe. Ich habe keine angegebene Vorgeschichte mit Operationen, Hormonen, Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung.
Vollständige Geschichte
I desisted from identifying as trans and I am now really happy as a woman presenting masculinely. For a long time I felt so strongly that I wanted hormones and that I would love being a man and looking male, but I wasn't actually trans. It took a long time to slowly become more comfortable with my body as it is; I realised I can do anything that a man can, express myself however I want, and still be a woman — I don't have to be the version of a woman that anybody else says.
What moved me toward desisting was realising that many ideas perpetuated in the trans community were not true — for example the claim that if you're questioning your gender you must be trans because cis people don't question their gender. I also believe social contagion played a big role: from experience, I somehow subconsciously pushed myself to have dysphoria. I had no body image problems before, even through early puberty, and I liked being feminine; somehow this social contagion pushed me into feelings of hatred for my body. I reckon if you start thinking things enough they get wired into your brain. I also agree it can't just be social contagion — there's got to be another issue happening that means the social contagion works on that person, in the same way suicide can be a social contagion but there's still a lot of issues happening with the person.
After desisting, I was pressured into having an autism assessment after struggling with mental health issues. I didn't want to because it felt like the same path as I went down with the trans stuff. Now I have this autism diagnosis and I feel like it's not correct.
I currently present masculinely: men's clothes, I don't shave, and I have a fairly pronounced moustache which is genetic and runs in my family — I've had it since I was about 11 and I've always seen it as part of myself, even as a teenager, though it makes people more likely to assume I'm trans. I think I mainly just look like a lesbian. I'm not a very confident person, so I don't show who I am through words as much as I'd like to. I find it frustrating that because I wear masculine clothing people assume I'm part of the whole queer movement, and I hate being asked my pronouns over and over — people do it in that annoying 'I'm being such a good ally' way, saying 'oh, just wondering what your pronouns are?', which shits me so much. I also relate to feeling this in female sports teams and in the lesbian dating space.
I have a sister who is nonbinary. We were so close when we were young, but I've had to slowly drift apart from her, which is really hard. She dresses very femininely and never had any issues with her gender when she was younger; it just feels like she's doing it to be special and to feel part of a community, and she's in some victim mentality mindset of almost liking when people 'misgender' her and can get annoyed at people for it. She has no idea that I don't 'agree' with the whole trans movement, because I'm sure she would completely cut me off, bad mouth me, and create family drama. I have a friend who I think may have gender-sceptical thoughts, but I'm going slow before I talk to her about it.
I follow the debate closely. I think the main issue in the debate about transition is that there is not good enough evidence about the detransition rate; I've cited a study showing a 9% (or 22%, depending on how you look at it) desistance/detransition rate after between 4 and 9 years. I posted about Trystan Reese, a trans influencer, whose daughter appeared to have typical ROGD, was introduced to the internet as trans, and is now no longer identifying as transgender. I used to follow Trystan when I was in the whole trans bubble. I was really worried about that child given she had been introduced to the whole internet as trans and might find that a barrier to changing her mind. I was really glad and relieved she was able to change her mind, and I noted that it's another example of detransitioning/desisting not being given a platform, which leads the public to think it's very uncommon. I hoped that it happening in Trystan's own family might open his eyes a bit, but it seems not.