Alle Geschichten

Ihr gefiel der Klang von „er/ihm“ – und sie transitionierte nie

Weiblich · Desistiert140
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine der Detransition nahestehende Kritikerin und keine Detransitionierte: Ich bin weiblich, nie transitioniert und identifiziere mich als „TERF“, die medizinische Transition kritisch sieht, besonders bei Minderjährigen. Als Kind nannte ich mich männlich, einfach weil mir der Klang von „er/ihm“ gefiel, und ich bin dankbar, dass man mich nie wegen so etwas Banalem hat transitionieren lassen. Ich habe Mitgefühl für Menschen, die aus internalisierter Misogynie oder Homophobie nichtbinäre Labels annehmen, bin aber wütend darüber, dass Frauenräume durch geschlechtsneutrale ersetzt wurden, da ich persönlich zwei nichtbinäre Menschen berücksichtigen musste. Ich glaube, dass Therapie vor einer Transition verpflichtend sein sollte, nenne Gruppendruck als Treiber der Transition und bezweifle, dass Mann-zu-Frau-Transitionierende wirklich durchgehen. Ich habe keine persönliche Geschichte mit Hormonen oder Operationen und berichte von keiner eigenen Reue.

Vollständige Geschichte

I am female and I have never identified as trans, but I have thought a lot about gender and transition because of people around me and because of things I experienced as a child. When I was about six years old, I used to refer to myself as male — not because I felt dysphoric, but simply because I liked the sound of "he/him" and "boy" better than "she/her" and "girl." I genuinely thought it was optional, that we just got to choose what we called ourselves. I have often reflected on how badly that could have gone if adults around me had taken it seriously and allowed me to transition over something so trivial. I cannot imagine the "absolute shitstorm" that would have occurred later in my life if I had been allowed to transition because of such an odd thing. I have a lot of sympathy for people who pick up a non-binary label because of internalized misogyny or internalized homophobia — I can see how a young woman who is uncomfortable with sexualization or with being a woman in a misogynistic society might land there. At the same time, I feel that the push for they/them or a third gender harms women: women's spaces are being replaced by "gender neutral" spaces, and I have personally had to suffer because I was forced to accommodate two non-binary people in a women's space. I described how the sympathy I feel is immediately overtaken by rage, even though I recognize it is a societal problem rather than their individual fault. I am critical of how quickly transition is offered, especially to minors. I have read about cases where doctors seem to face professional consequences for not prescribing hormones, but I still think choosing their own careers over the health of minors is wrong. I have said plainly that people should have to go through therapy before such a drastic decision, and I have expressed disgust at friends who respond to concerns with "well it's their body, not mine" — I find it disturbing that people will not even pretend to care about others. I have cited research suggesting that a lot of transitions are spurred by group pressure, and I know someone with a condition preventing normal puberty who, despite being comfortable with their body and going through appropriate procedures to reach puberty, is repeatedly told by friends to transition. I identify as a 'terf' — though I do not use slurs like 'tranny' myself — and I have defended moderators on detransition forums for trying to consider both sides. I am skeptical of claims that male-to-female transitioners pass: I believe the images posted online are heavily edited with intentional lighting, and that even in person women can tell based on mannerisms, physical gait, and movement. I have never described undergoing transition myself, so I do not have a personal medical timeline of hormones or surgeries, nor do I describe regret about transition. My engagement with this community comes from concern for others, from my own childhood experiences with gendered language, and from frustrations I have had living in women's spaces.