Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der sich ab etwa 25 als trans identifizierte, mit etwa 30 Östrogen begann und nach ungefähr sechs Monaten aufhörte, als mir klar wurde, dass ich nie eine Frau sein würde und es gar nicht hasste, männlich zu sein. Ich kehrte zu einem maskulinen Auftreten mit Bart und einem Job auf dem Bau zurück, und ich sage jetzt, dass ich mich festgefahren fühle und in beide Richtungen etwas vorspiele. Das Absetzen von Östrogen brachte eine intensive zyklische Hypersexualität zurück, die ich ohne Trinken kaum in den Griff bekomme, dazu 35 lb Gewichtszunahme in vier Monaten, auch wenn meine psychische Gesundheit mit und ohne Hormone in etwa gleich war. Ich sehe kritisch, wie Transition heute gepusht wird, und nenne es einen gefährlichen Trend, und ich rate anderen zu pausieren, bis sie keine Zweifel mehr haben. Ich lebe derzeit als Mann und identifiziere mich nicht als Frau, gebe aber zu, dass ich mich für das Frausein entschieden hätte, wenn ich könnte.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male. I learned about trans people when I was 20 and gave it serious thought at 25, when I had what I called an identity crisis and decided I was trans — although I was never uncomfortable as a male, I just would have rather been female, which is still true. I've always known I was bi but never really experimented much on the gay side of my bi life; I pulled up my man pants and did what I felt was expected of me. Around 25 I decided I was trans.
By the time I was 30 it was time to transition. I was working as a butcher, a hard, physically demanding, very manly job, and during that time I had a very strong feeling that something was wrong. I was in a relationship that was somewhat generic — not an emotional loving relationship but more of a business relationship, like upgraded roommates/best friends; we were good parents but bad partners, but it's all we knew. I split with my partner, moved out, and things honestly felt great — great like mania. I started estrogen. After 6 months I kind of just had a massive realization that something still wasn't right: I was never going to be a woman and I didn't even hate that I was a man. I hated being stuck trying to be manly to the point I felt the need to overcompensate. I didn't want people to think I was a woman — I just wanted to wear makeup, tight clothes and feel good... sometimes. And other times I wanted to not shave, drink beer and go fishing.
Since life isn't a fairy tale, I completely reverted back into the lifestyle that drove me into crippling, self-destructive levels of insecurity. I covered up my transition with a beard, a job in construction and a few extra pounds. I stopped transitioning because I'll never be a woman, but I don't think I'm ever going to be a man either. I feel like I wanted to transition to stop pretending, then stopped transitioning to stop pretending, but still feel like I'm pretending.
On the medical side: I was very slim when I started E and stayed slim right up until I stopped. I gained 35lbs over 4 months in my stomach and thighs after stopping E. My boobs got bigger after stopping E than when I was on it. After a month off hormones everything was back to normal sexually; I quit porn as well and everything went back to normal, although there is a short period of time that comes up every so often where I get uncontrollably horny for extended periods — insatiably horny all the time for like 2 weeks at a time. It interferes with my work, home life, hobbies and interactions with people, and I tamper it with drinking, which brings its own problems. This was cured during my transition but returned with furious vengeance since stopping my transition, and it's intolerable.
My mental health didn't improve or get any worse regardless of my hormone status — it changed but was mostly the same. As a male with male hormones I'm horny, I drink a lot, I get into trouble and have more anger. When I was on estrogen I was sad but content, calm but less effective and more submissive, and this depressed me in its own right. Both had their mental health burdens; but as myself, a male, I control my actions better while I succumb to my addictions with stronger urges. On E I didn't succumb to my urges but that made me feel less human — I would rather feel flawed but human than complacent and existing.
I now think that simply stopping your transition to consider whether it's right for you gets you labelled as a transphobe, and that if anyone tried to stop you they'd be 'lynched by the mob' long before you'd be mentally clear enough to vindicate them. I have a friend who is mid-transition, started after I did, never mentioned it during my transition and went through some trauma; suddenly one day they were transitioning. I would like to warn them but everyone is supporting them and if I even whisper doubt I'll be ostracized and labelled a transphobe. I have no doubt they will be here one day but it's not my place to bring them.
I've told others that a woman isn't what you look like or how others perceive you, and it's the same with men; I think the approach a lot of trans people and communities take to gender is archaic, and that makeup and skirts going spinny are validating but wildly superficial. Transitions are destination-focused and we focus so hard on the end that we don't realize we're on a dynamic, living path. I've said you don't need to identify yourself as anything at all — you're just a human being on a journey. I've also said I want to be a woman as well, that I'm a 30-year-old guy who tried to become a woman but the reality is that it's not possible, and that if I was given a character creation screen at birth I would certainly select 'female' but I wasn't. I'm also very attracted to females, so attracted I think it makes me want to be one. I've advised that you can transition and be valid, or not transition and still be valid, and that a lot of it comes down to self-love — chasing physical changes to complete yourself runs a high risk of leaving you feeling vacant. 'You can't make a wrong decision but your decision will have lasting consequences.'
Later I've been more blunt: 'Stop transitioning, fuck. Not only is it a stupid trend, it's a dangerous trend... At least pause until you no longer have doubt.' I've also said I think a lot of potential femboys transition and then regret it. In December 2022 I said I was 'not at wits end anymore, not even close,' and in January 2023 I encouraged someone else that therapy is like paying someone to be a passenger and read you directions — helpful, but you can still get where you need to go without it — and that broken people need to pick up some glue and start reassembling their pieces.