Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau (butch/maskuline Lesbe), die mit 13 sozial transitionierte, in meinen Zwanzigern die Diagnose Geschlechtsdysphorie bekam, ab 21 knapp ein Jahr Testosteron nahm und mit etwa 22 mit der Detransition begann. Meine Transition wurde durch sexuellen Missbrauch in der Kindheit, Autismus, verinnerlichte Homophobie und Misogynie, PCOS, Mobbing wegen Geschlechtsnonkonformität und starken Einfluss der Tumblr-/Yaoi-Kultur angetrieben. Ich habe T von heute auf morgen abgesetzt, und im Laufe von ~6 Jahren bildeten sich die meisten Veränderungen teilweise zurück, aber mir bleiben dauerhafte Probleme, darunter Stimmveränderungen, Halsschmerzen, vaginale Atrophie, Hypothyreose und Probleme mit dem Immunsystem. Meine Dysphorie hat sich nach der Detransition deutlich gebessert, ist aber nicht ganz verschwunden, und an meinen schlimmsten Tagen hatte ich Suizidgedanken, die mit der Erschöpfung zusammenhängen, als sichtbar geschlechtsnonkonforme Frau zu leben. Ich gehe jetzt offen mit meiner Detransition um, stehe radikalfeministischen Positionen nahe und bin kritisch gegenüber der Art, wie Transition an verletzliche Menschen vergeben wird, während mir meine trans Freunde weiterhin am Herzen liegen.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female and grew up in a Korean family in Hawai'i, in a religious household. My dysphoria started very young — I was the tomboy from early childhood, hated skirts and dresses, and before I even knew what a binder was I would bind my developing chest with saran wrap, sleep on my stomach hoping to flatten my breasts, and go to sleep wishing I'd get breast cancer so I could have them removed. I had folders of bookmarks about bottom surgery. I identified as trans and socially transitioned at around age 13, and I'd describe my experience as textbook — dysphoria from a very young age, marked opposite-sex behavior, attraction to girls. My family was vehemently anti-LGBT and never accepted me; they saw me as a "turbo butch lesbian that went too far." I was professionally diagnosed with gender dysphoria (GID) in my 20s, only because I needed the diagnosis to pursue medical transition after struggling with dysphoria most of my life. I went the WPATH route: I saw a gender specialist for about 3 months, was referred to a trans health clinic, and left the same day with testosterone — they did my first injection on the spot. I started T at age 21 on a starting/low dose (0.3 mL subQ weekly) and was on it for just under a year. My changes were rapid: my voice dropped to cis-male range within about 3 months, most of the bottom growth I'd ever get happened in the first 3-6 months, and I went from passing about 90% of the time to essentially 100%. I was stealth. I stopped T cold turkey around age 22 (about four months before my first post here in May 2019) and began detransitioning. I briefly identified as nonbinary as a stopgap — it took me about half a year to decide I was ftmtf, and about two years total to fully decondition myself and accept I was a woman. I went back to my birth name. I never had any surgeries. I'm now a detransitioned woman — a butch/masc lesbian — in my late 20s, about 6 years off T.
In terms of what led to transition: I have autism (diagnosed as an adult; I would have been called Asperger's), ADHD, a history of childhood sexual abuse (CSA) at the hands of males, and I'm same-sex attracted. I was bullied relentlessly growing up for being gender nonconforming — called a dyke to my face, told I was too manly, chased out of women's spaces. I grew up in a very religious Christian Korean family and would cry for hours begging God to make me straight. Internalized homophobia and internalized misogyny were huge factors. I found comfort in physical "tells" like facial hair and a deeper pre-T voice (I later learned I have PCOS, which I had pre-T and still have). I was very active on Tumblr as a teen and was into m/m fic and yaoi, and I believe social contagion and online culture played a big role in digging my heels into a trans identity. I also think transition was partly escapism — a way to run from being a masc lesbian, from the sexualization I feared as a visibly female person, and from the shame of being same-sex attracted. Being perceived as a slightly feminine Korean boy got me positive attention from women in my friend circles, whereas as a woman I've mostly gotten negative, sexualized attention.
On T I genuinely liked many of the changes — I felt stronger, more confident, more energetic, and T had a noticeable antidepressant effect for me. I enjoyed being perceived as male. But I became increasingly aware that I was chasing something impossible: I looked and sounded cis male but knew I wasn't and never would be, and what I wanted (a penis, to actually be male, to be able to impregnate a wife) was unattainable. That dissonance was painful. I also had to unpack that my genital dysphoria was partly about mourning not being able to have PIV sex with women, internalized homophobia associating PIV with "real" sex, and CSA trauma.
What moved me toward detransition was a slow accumulation of doubts, therapy that didn't help (gender-affirming therapists kept trying to spin me as nonbinary or insisting I was trans in denial), and eventually just no longer believing the ideology — I stopped believing HRT changed my sex or that full transition was possible. Coming out as detrans was very hard: trans friends accused me of being brainwashed by TERFs, questioned whether my family was pressuring me, and several friendships ended or rotted. I was stealth for most of high school and college, so detransition felt like a kind of social suicide; only my best friend of 7-8 years and people who already knew I was trans found out.
Medically, I stopped T cold turkey (not recommended, but I had no issues). Over time: my period came back within a few months, body fat redistributed back to chest and hips within about a year (my chest actually grew larger than pre-T), my face lost the angularity I'd liked on T, my voice lightened somewhat on its own (from ~120Hz on T to ~157Hz by March 2021, still in male range), bottom growth partially shrank (to maybe 75%) and sensation normalized, facial hair grows back slower and thinner but I still shave every couple of days, and my hair thinned somewhat but partially came back. Things that did not fully revert: persistent vaginal atrophy (improved a lot but still present; estrogen cream didn't do much for me), some hair thinning, throat tightness/pain that started a few months into T and has gotten worse recently (I'm planning to see an ENT; my vocal range is limited and it can be painful to talk or sing), and a lingering "boyish" look to my face. About a year after stopping T I developed hypothyroidism, severe allergies, and immune system issues — my immunologist said T basically "kicked the hornets nest" of my system. I also had elevated hematocrit and hypertension on T, which improved off T but my heart health doesn't feel the same. I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism at 21. I also have PCOS, which I had pre-T.
Mentally, my mood improved almost exponentially coming off T. My dysphoria lessened significantly after detransition — for the first time in my life — though it hasn't fully gone away. I still get random waves of dysphoria, and recently a woman flirting with me triggered intense shame and an impulse to hide my chest, which shocked me because I thought I'd worked through that. I've struggled with dissociation and depersonalization related to PTSD. On my worst days I've had thoughts of ending it, because living as a masc woman on the defensive is exhausting, but I'm generally in a much better place. Body neutrality — learning to see the female body neutrally rather than through a lens of shame — was transformative for me, along with exercise.
Socially, most of my trans friends cut me off or I cut them off. My family's reaction was a quiet "return to normal" — Asian families sweep things under the rug. I've been called "fembrained" by an mtf, told I'm lying or in denial, blocked by acquaintances for being openly detrans, and made to speak for all detransitioners. I still get mistaken for ftm or afab nonbinary constantly because I present masc (short hair, men's clothes, sports bras, no makeup, unshaved body hair). Even my gyno and therapists have asked if I'm nonbinary. Finding therapists who don't either insist I'm trans in denial or that I must be nonbinary has been very difficult.
Sexually, I'm a lesbian. On T I identified as "queer" and briefly dated/was involved with mtfs, but off T I have no interest in men whatsoever — my theory is HRT affects libido, not orientation. I've dated happily as a lesbian and women haven't been put off by my masc presentation or my history.
I regret transitioning young and for so long. I wish someone had told me my dysphoria was common among girls and lesbians, and had helped me unpack my trauma and autism in relation to gender instead of affirming me. I liken it to getting a large, hard-to-hide tattoo as a teen — not a cringey phase but something with permanent consequences. The regret is intense and I wish almost daily I could undo it, though it's becoming more manageable with time. I'm vocal about detransition — I post openly, engage in these discussions, and consider myself radfem-aligned. I support the idea that people should be able to do what they want with their bodies, but I'm critical of how transition is administered, especially to vulnerable people (autistic, traumatized, same-sex attracted youth), and I think medical transition should be a last resort. I don't hate trans people and still have trans friends, but I've set hard boundaries.