Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der etwa sieben Jahre lang mit Hormonen als trans Frau lebte, ohne Operationen, und der inzwischen wieder als mein ursprüngliches männliches Selbst lebt. Meine Transition wuchs aus sexuellem Missbrauch in der Kindheit mit 7, einem abwesenden und unzuverlässigen Vater, dem Tod meines einzigen wirklichen männlichen Vorbilds, intensiver internalisierter Misandrie, gewichtsbezogenem Körperhass und jahrelanger unverarbeiteter Trauer, was ich alles allmählich in der Therapie aufarbeitete, bis der Wunsch, transitioniert zu bleiben, verblasste. Die Recherche zu Bottom-Operationen, der Wunsch nach leiblichen Kindern und das Erkennen meiner wachsenden Isolation und Angst führten zu meiner Entscheidung zu detransitionieren, die ich etwa 2019 mit einem Fehlstart begann und bis 2023 voll umsetzte. Ich bereue die Transition selbst nicht, weil sie mir half zu verstehen, was mich wirklich zerfraß, wünschte aber, ich hätte drei bis vier Jahre früher aufgehört; meine psychische Gesundheit und mein Sozialleben haben sich seit meiner Rückkehr deutlich verbessert. Ich unterstütze weiterhin die Transitionen anderer, bin aber kritisch dagegen, dass beide politischen Seiten Detrans-Menschen ausnutzen, und setze mich für Ehrlichkeit, Therapie und Selbstakzeptanz statt äußerer Bestätigung ein.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and grew up in a rural southern small town in the 1990s. As a mildly to moderately effeminate boy I was bullied hard for just being me, and I developed what I'd later recognize as intense internalized misandry — a loathing of masculinity as society performed it, which reflected back onto me. My biological father was completely absent for the first 18.5 years of my life; he later made what looked like a genuine push toward reconciliation, but it turned out to be mostly driven by his then-wife, and he resumed his behavior the second they divorced. He has kids by at least half a dozen women. My stepdad was emotionally distant and stoic — a trucker who taught me how to drive and seems to genuinely care for my mom, but with no framework to express anything except anger. Uncle #1 was an abusive alcoholic with things I won't discuss publicly. Uncle #2 was the closest thing to a father figure I ever had: he bought me my first car, taught me to drive, once drove 50 miles while battling what would become terminal lung issues to rescue me when I was stranded, and worked on my car in the middle of summer. He was big on personal responsibility and taking ownership of your choices.
My dysphoria and slide into what I now call 'transville' started almost immediately after Uncle #2 died — at almost exactly the time my biological father reappeared and then chose to be a deadbeat again. An already low opinion of manhood got lower. On top of that was a ton of unprocessed grief I felt I couldn't mourn, compounded later by childhood sexual abuse at the hands of that uncle when I was 7, other body image issues around weight, parent issues too lengthy to list, and absolutely intense self-loathing. Mix in some self-loathing and stir for 2-3 years and boom — transition. I also developed disordered eating when I didn't fit into what society expected of male people.
I transitioned (male to female, i.e. identifying as a trans woman) roughly a decade before my 2023 posts. I took HRT — spironolactone, estradiol, and progesterone — for about seven years total (elsewhere I said 'just about five years,' and later '7 years of T-blocker/estrogen/progesterone'). Spiro and I never got along; my overall T levels never dropped entirely, and I occasionally briefly desisted allowing T to spike. I had no surgeries, thank God. I did electrology. During transition I worked out in full face makeup with my long curly hair down because going without made my face look more masculine. I was bi before, bi during, and bi after — there was never anything remotely fetishistic about my transition and I never 'got anything' out of it; no AGP, not even remotely.
About two years into transition, and just north of 30, I started really wanting kids someday. I told myself 'well, there's always adoption,' but the thought of kids never left. Meanwhile I got really successful in my career — a creative-technical field that was mostly a boy's club. I was the first person hired into that position who wasn't an 'OEM standard normal dude.' When they later hired an actual woman onto the team, I finally identified my own feelings: she was the one who had to fight and claw from childhood against social bullshit and gender norms and bias, while I just showed up late to the party and got the credit. They tried to stiff her on pay compared to the guys; I was being paid somewhere between the two. It genuinely bothered me that I got credit for the trail she blazed.
Then it came time to think about bottom surgery. I did my due diligence — researched stories, spoke to friends — and the only word I had was 'butchery.' The procedure, the level of involvement, the aftercare, the risk of complications: barbarism. It would have been a huge procedure with real risk of severe complications, and a reproductive dead end, because the 'lil swimmers' had held on. Another trans woman I knew in real life had major complications after hers. Researching MTF bottom surgery methods was one of the single biggest moments where my brain went 'WHOA' — why am I exploring how to carve up perfectly healthy tissue just because it makes me feel bad to be perceived as a guy? As I came to terms with the limitations of surgery, it became 'Do I even want this,' and as soon as I said no it became 'so what am I really doing here, then.'
I also noticed my own retreat inward into anxiety. I was avoiding interactions, creating rot under the surface, working so hard to validate this second self that I wasn't really leading a life outside work. Anxiety, paranoia, and depression were sky high. There was a stretch in 2019 where the only human beings I saw for weeks were DoorDash and Instacart drivers — I even went on medical leave from work as my anxiety and social phobia grew. I lived between New York City and Boston and never visited either. I spent most of two years as a recluse. I pushed my family away when they didn't understand my coming out; twenty-year friends reduced to a memory of a memory. Other friends told me how brave I was, then were joyful when I recently fessed up to having reservations.
The process of moving toward detransition was gradual. It started about two years in — around 2017 — with realizing I'd never be female and that the whole thing was striving after a whole lot of nothing. I reached out to my endocrinologist in April 2019 as a first step, though a big part of me was honestly over the medical side of all of it; I knew throwing my endocrine system into unmonitored chaos was risky, so I wanted to do it right. I lost a nonbinary friend over my fears about their health surrounding transition. In therapy and counseling I gradually worked through the underlying issues: coping with my massive internalized misandry; learning that the choking, constrictive expressions of masculinity weren't the only paths (both my sisters married great men — one brother-in-law is a stay-at-home dad); dealing with how complex the subject was with my parents and elders; realizing most of my body hatred came from how I felt about my weight; coming to grips with what happened with my uncle when I was 7; and recognizing that the reasons I hated myself weren't fixed by transition and required different, harder work. Each issue I worked through decreased the desire to remain transitioned. It took about five years from the realization to detransition.
I had a false start: I came off hormones and testosterone was already beginning to reassert, but I had to temporarily stop detransition for a social reason, not medical. About a year later I started weaning back off hormones again and could already feel T coming back at least a little. In May 2022 I posted about becoming isolated and withdrawn, noting that the closer I got to full detransition — integrating more masculine aspects back into appearance and behavior, less 'acting the part,' and drawing down HRT — the more self-assured I felt and the more willing and able to deal with people I was. By August 2023 I had committed and taken steps toward reverting to my birth gender, resumed existing as my original male self in most settings, and expected to have records and name changed back by year's end. I'd considered using a different first name since I had issues with my original birth name long before transition, but I accepted the original me.
Reactions fell into three categories. People who knew me before all this started a decade ago were relieved — 'Oh thank God, dude' — and I reconnected with friends and family (the exception being my mother, whose issues with me run far deeper and involve non-trans matters; she wound up hating my transition not because of the gender aspect but because it broke her control over my life). People who met me in the last 10 years went through a short awkward re-filing period and then immediately lowered their shields; people had been keeping me at a distance with kid gloves and pity without my realizing it. Trans people and those heavily invested in gender politics saw it as almost a betrayal — 'You basically passed / your voice was perfect / WHY?!' — with immediate distancing by the vast majority, including nearly every MTF trans person; FTM folks were a little more chill.
On medical specifics: HRT did a bit of a number on my face and it's taking time to undo; I'll probably always be a bit babyfaced. I bind when I need to (I love winter). At some point I'll probably look at chest surgery to remove what female HRT did, but I want to work out the rest of my issues before letting any surgeon at me for anything cosmetic. I'm concerned about fertility — I'd like to have kids if I can and there's sorrow that HRT may have 'shot the shot to hell,' though my T levels never fully suppressed. If chest or back hair returns I'll probably get every last one zapped — personal preference. Skin and body composition changes take years; facial changes from testosterone happen over a timescale of years.
Mental health: anxiety, paranoia, depression, and social phobia were sky-high during my most withdrawn phase, leading to medical leave from work. As I detransitioned, isolation lifted substantially. I developed disordered eating first when I didn't fit male expectations, then a different set of disordered behaviors during transition as a coping mechanism; in 'take three' — focusing on what my body can do and the verbs and adjectives of my life — my relationship with food has been the most normal it's been.
On regret: I don't regret transition itself because it helped me contextualize what was really eating at me — I just let it go on too long. I wish I'd cut bait 3-4 years earlier. I hold that a lie begets two more and eventually becomes unsustainable; building a smaller house on a more solid foundation beats a palace that falls in the first stiff breeze. I'm wary of swapping one narrative for another — exchanging the trans narrative for the detrans narrative still feeds the system from the other side. Grief is healthy, regret is sensible, but a life lived perpetually stewing in trauma is rarely lived fully. I don't dwell on the years burned or the physical changes as my home and identity.
Attitudes toward transition for others: I wholeheartedly still support people in their own transitions. I'm not an evangelist for detransition; if folks want to know, I'll tell them, and if they have an issue, that's their issue. I've advised others to be honest but kind when telling people, to work out what's genuinely best for them rather than framing detransition around societal expectations, and to find a good therapist (mine doesn't even specialize in gender stuff and has been the best I've had). I'm critical of both political sides using detrans people as pawns, and I strongly oppose figures like Matt Walsh, whom I called a hatemonger who doesn't give a damn about detrans people and uses us as props; I worry broadly worded anti-trans laws will impact detransitioners too. I believe the only path out of the trans feedback loop is acceptance — integrating both the parts of being male you're running from and the feminine parts of yourself, like a finger trap that only releases when you push your fingers together.