Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine heterosexuelle Frau, die nicht trans ist und nie transitioniert ist; ich bin 2019 r/detrans beigetreten, um Menschen zu unterstützen, die sich zur Transition gedrängt fühlen. Ich war als Kind ein Tomboy, entwickelte mich früh und bekam unerwünschte männliche Aufmerksamkeit, und hatte mit Hypothyreose und anderen hormonstörenden Erkrankungen zu tun, die erheblichen Haarausfall verursachten, dazu Phasen schwerer psychischer Tiefpunkte. Ich trete entschieden gegen medizinische Transition von Jugendlichen ein, mit dem Verweis darauf, dass die Gehirnentwicklung erst mit 23–25 abgeschlossen ist, und teile praktische Ratschläge zu Gesundheitsuntersuchungen, Korrekturen von Krankenakten, Haarentfernung und Dankbarkeitsübungen. Ich habe keine Transitionsreue, da ich nie transitioniert bin, bereue aber verlorene Zeit in meinen eigenen dunklen Phasen. Ich bleibe aktiv als unterstützende Verbündete von Detransitionierenden.
Vollständige Geschichte
I want to be clear from the start: I am not trans and I am not detransitioned. I joined r/detrans in 2019 purely to support people who are struggling or who are worried about being railroaded into transition. I have never taken hormones or had any gender-related medical procedures, so my story here is not one of medical regret but of how I came to care about this issue and what I have shared about my own life along the way.
Growing up, I was, in my own words, "all tom-boyed out." I wanted more boy toys than girly stuff, was heavily into action and narrative, and had no interest in taking care of a baby or pretending to bake. I thank God my parents didn't freak out about it. I was a tomboy who didn't want to break anything except bad guys' noses. I also developed early: I remember that developing ahead of my peer group as a teen brought totally inappropriate attention from men, which I described as "beyond disgusting" at 11 or 12. I have thick forearm hair, which I was self-aware about as a kid and definitely did not appreciate as a teen. I identify as a straight woman.
I have dealt with serious medical problems of my own. At some point I got really sick without realizing how sick I was — I was hypothyroid, plus "a bunch of other serious stuff that was messing with ALL of my hormones." My hair started falling out in handfuls, which freaked me out, and it stayed thinned for years, especially on one side of my head. I tried biotin (ineffective), Regenix shampoos and topicals (helped thicken what I had), and Viviscal (actually helped). Ultimately I had major surgery for my illness, after which the hair fell again from the stress on my body, and it took over a year to somewhat come back. It is now about 99% fixed, though I still have issues only I notice. I have also personally corrected medical records and surgical orders, which informed my practical advice to others about getting records amended.
I have also been through dark psychological periods. At one point I got so far down that I could not think of ONE thing I was grateful for. It took me an hour to come up with five things I was truly grateful for. I started a daily numbered list of 5 things, then 10, and my life improved; it put my mind on winning instead of failure. I have struggled with not giving myself credit for progress. I also mentioned having "had to figure out myself" practical advice about recovery, and I congratulated someone else on resolving an eating disorder, implying I understand that territory. I have dealt with stress, overwhelm, and periods where I felt I could not get out of my own way.
My involvement in r/detrans has been almost entirely as an advisor and supporter. I have repeatedly argued that minors cannot make these decisions: children under 18 are not held accountable because of incomplete brain formation (not finished until about 23-25) and raging hormones; 15 "is not an excellent period of clarity or suitable for adult decision making"; and I said bluntly that I don't understand how it's legal to suppress a teen's hormones based on talking to the child. I posted news stories supporting this, including a Canadian father fighting so his 14-year-old daughter couldn't start testosterone, a BBC project on detransitioning, and a Southern state outlawing puberty blockers and surgeries under 19 (that post got 409 points). I shared a pull quote from the BBC piece about a therapist who immediately used male pronouns and said he'd never been so sure anyone was trans, deliberately hoping it would "ring bells."
I have given a lot of practical guidance: break problems into smaller pieces; decide not to decide until you've evaluated your health with blood work, hormone levels, sleep, and blood pressure; treat basic depression first; get to rehab if you're using alcohol daily; then look into feelings about sexual identity. I recommended Walk-In Labs as a cheap way to order your own blood tests at Quest or Labcorp without a doctor's note. I advised people on correcting medical records (start with the easiest, like insurance check boxes; expect an addendum rather than erasure), on choosing a new name (traditional over modern, honor family, consider letter preferences), on facial and body hair removal (Veet, Oil of Olay facial remover, don't scrub), and on gynecomastia being linked to marijuana use.
I have been open about my own views, including some I flagged as opinion: I believe intense attraction to the opposite sex has links to wanting to express oneself in that context, and I speculated that a poster's awkwardness about her own physicality plus desire to penetrate might connect to childhood physical abuse. I also corrected my own comment later, clarifying I meant "intensely physical sex" not pain or BDSM. I believe the brain science shows male and female brains are not wired the same, but I'm skeptical of vague ideas like "masculine energy," arguing it can't apply to all men and some women, so a different adjective is probably in play.
I have been critical of what I see as political capture: I talked to a university teacher friend who has a lot of "they's" in her class and is bothered by the construct but defensive about the programming she must follow; I said I'm not sure telling people they can "change" their biological gender is helpful; and I pushed back when others accused posters of homophobia, saying people are being hurt by radically and prematurely changing. I also referenced the David Reimer case — the boy whose penis was damaged in circumcision and was raised as girl — as a cautionary tale, calling it a civil rights violation and criminal act if the boy didn't want it.
I have been through my own share of hardship and have tried to be a steady, one-day-at-a-time presence for others. I have not experienced transition or detransition myself, so I have no transition-related regret, but I do regret lost time in my own life when I was too overwhelmed to function, and I carry some residual effects of my illness (thinner hair than it was). Currently I am a straight woman who supports detransitioners and is cautious about youth medical transition, active in online communities as an ally rather than as someone who transitioned.