Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein 62-jähriger schwuler Mann, der nie transitioniert ist; ich kam im Juli 2020 rein als interessierter Außenstehender in die Detrans-Community und stellte Fragen zu Transition und Detransition. Ich beschrieb mich als „keinen Cheerleader für Transition ODER Detransition“, mit Sympathie für Menschen auf beiden Seiten, aber einigem Unbehagen darüber, dass das „T“ an L und G angepfropft wurde. Ich stellte Rückfragen zu den Transitionen, Operationen und der Terminologie anderer (Detransitionierte vs. Desistierende) und wehrte mich gegen das, was ich als kognitive Dissonanz in Bezug auf Geschlecht im trans Diskurs sah. Ich bin nicht detransitioniert, nicht trans, und meine aktuelle Identität ist die eines nicht-trans schwulen Mannes.
Vollständige Geschichte
I am a 62-year-old gay man who has never transitioned or identified as trans. I came to the detrans community in July 2020 out of genuine curiosity, wanting to understand what leads people to consider themselves the other sex, what their therapy and medical process looked like, and what eventually moved them to reverse their transition. I explicitly said I was not 'transphobic' and asked people to bear with me on labels and semantics, because I had found candid exchanges on these issues nearly impossible to have.
I have been homosexual 'from the get-go' and have watched the social climate around gays and lesbians change radically over my lifetime. I described myself as 'no cheerleader for transition OR detransition,' with considerable sympathy for people going through it. I said I cannot personally conceive of wanting to change my sex, but noted that most people cannot personally conceive of being homosexual either, so I try not to disparage what doesn't compute for me.
I asked a number of clarifying questions in the community: whether a given poster was a biological female seeking to transition to male or the other way around, whether they had gone through sexual reassignment surgery, what the nature and extent of their earlier transition had been, and what 'desister' meant versus 'detransitioner.' I also asked people to define acronyms like ASD, CSA, GC, MCAS, EDS, and ME/CFS, since I said I was only 'semi-fluent in Acronym.' At one point I posted a question about originally-female trans people that turned out to be a highly sensitive topic; I later went back to explain I had not intended it as a prelude to a debate and was not trolling, and I respected the other person's decision not to engage.
I have some misgivings about what I perceive as the 'trans agenda,' but said that is tempered by 'a lizard brain understanding of what it's like to be shit on for who you are.' I have questioned the paradox I see in parts of the trans cohort: some deny the validity or existence of gender while others spend huge amounts of time, money, pain, and energy on a path that obsesses about gender. I called it, from the outside, an 'exercise in cognitive dissonance,' at times seeming Orwellian, while reminding myself that adults tend to ponder life's contradictions rather than be driven crazy by them.
On the 'LGBT' acronym, I said the Q confuses me because I don't know what it means, and that while I understand why T got 'grafted on,' it makes me uneasy because I don't see L and G being in the same tribe as T — 'perhaps friends and somewhat affiliated... but still different tribes.' On the 'queer community' label I said I frankly don't know what it means. I also pushed back on a poster who seemed invested in rigid dominant/submission archetypes, arguing that submissive people generally have a service mentality rather than wanting to be taken advantage of, and that people often conflate homosexual with homosocial, thinking of themselves as bisexual when they are really 'bisocial.'
I have not undergone any transition, detransition, hormones, or surgeries myself, and nothing in my posts describes dysphoria, coming out as trans, or a reversal. My involvement has been as an interested outsider asking questions and occasionally offering perspective from a lifetime of being a gay man.