Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die ab etwa 20 von männlich aus transitionierte, Hormone nahm und operiert wurde und es bereute; ich beschreibe mich als jemand, der in einem einsamen Dazwischen steckt, ohne den Wunsch, zu Testosteron zurückzukehren. Ich glaube, dass meine Transition aus einer psychischen Erkrankung entstand, dass ich damals eine echte informierte Einwilligung gab und dass die zerstrittene Scheidung meiner Eltern und ihre Vernachlässigung, die mich die Highschool ohne Freunde, ohne Hobbys und ohne Zukunftspläne abschließen ließ, während ich meine körperliche Transition vermisste, wesentlich dazu beitrugen. Ich bin scharf kritisch gegenüber Transitionsmedizin auf Basis informierter Einwilligung, gegenüber Online-Trans-Communitys, die Zweifel zum Schweigen bringen, und gegenüber Eltern, die Minderjährigen das Binden oder eine Transition erlauben, und setze mich stattdessen für Therapie, Medikamente, Fokus auf die Karriere und Diskretion über die eigene Trans-Vergangenheit ein. Seit der Detransition habe ich keine dokumentierten Suizidgedanken oder Selbstverletzung, auch wenn ich mit geringer Motivation, Konzentrationsproblemen, Angst und Haarausfall zu kämpfen hatte.
Vollständige Geschichte
I came to the detrans community in early 2019 as someone who had already transitioned and was living in an 'in between space' after surgeries and hormones. I was born male and transitioned to female around age 20, and by 2019 I was reflecting hard on what I had done to my body. I told others bluntly that surgery just replaces breasts and genitalia with scars and that my sex chromosomes remained xy. I described myself as occupying a lonely in-between space as a trans female, and I said I did not miss testosterone and did not want to return to life as a male.
I was very critical of the informed-consent model of transition medicine. I argued that doctors hurriedly cater to trans patients out of fear they will commit suicide, and that I had genuinely wanted testosterone and surgeries at the time — that nobody duped me, I simply wanted something different now than I did then. I told detransitioners who blamed their doctors that they should instead blame their mental illness, and that the transition resulted from that mental illness. I also noted that transgender medicine is a new field with doctors to help you switch but not yet to unswitch, and that some of us are high-risk patients because we keep changing our minds.
I was harsh but also pragmatic in advising young people questioning their gender. I told one person they sounded like a lesbian who just needed a breast reduction, and urged them to study something in college that would make money rather than spending their 20s on gender identity navel gazing. I advised others to use transition as a way to switch back, to go to college as their birth sex, and to accept that people would think they had been indecisive. I recommended puberty blockers as a way to postpone a decision for a 13-year-old, while elsewhere questioning why someone would make permanent changes based on whims that fluctuate day to day.
I was skeptical of online trans communities, warning that you will be blocked by the mods of trans subreddits if you mention detrans or second thoughts. I criticized a friend group where the poster, their boyfriend, and another friend were all MtFtM, asking if it was like playing Mr. Potato Head or a transtrender club, and whether they had started too young and malleable to know their own minds. I told one person their boyfriend was harsh for telling them to cut off their genitals when he had chickened out of his own surgery, and asked whether they felt safe among those people.
I focused a lot on parents of gender-questioning kids. I told a mother of a daughter who was binding to take the binder away, show the daughter the thread of replies, and require her to read them, warning there is no undoing the deformed rib cage that would result from persistent binding. I advised a firm 'no binding and no transitioning while you are a minor in my house,' while also acknowledging that a parental no only postpones transition until adulthood and does not address mental health. I suggested therapy and possibly medication, and even suggested hormone blockers as a possible compromise to postpone puberty. I recommended unplugging kids from the virtual world — sports camps, NOLS wilderness programs, Outward Bound intercept, National Guard Youth Challenge, military schools like Culver Academy — to build confidence through using their bodies to accomplish things.
I was blunt about my own family's failures. I wrote that my parents were remiss to let me graduate high school with zero future plans while they battled each other in a contentious divorce, and that they never noticed my physical transition, that I was bullied, that I had zero friends in real life, that I played no sports, joined no school clubs, and enjoyed no hobbies. I said such negligent people should not reproduce. I also criticized a parent who knew mental illness was prevalent in their family and reproduced anyway.
I dealt with my own motivation and focus problems after detransition. I acknowledged lacking motivation and focus, and encouraged seeing a shrink to find the right medication cocktail, being proactive about career goals, income, skills, and adventures. I noted that the surgery to remove breasts would cost money and asked whether human growth hormone injections could help me grow taller — I was clearly self-conscious about my height as someone who had gone through female puberty before transitioning. I recommended laser hair removal and electrolysis to deal with unwanted body and facial hair, and nioxin products for hair loss, plus antidepressants, hiking, and working out to lift my mood. I also experimented with CBD oil for anxiety.
I was angry at the medical establishment's inability to help detransitioners, saying they cannot just make things up and must admit when they do not know how to help. I noted that as more people go FtMtF or MtFtM, medical pioneers will start to address it, but that it is a new crisis with no medical school class for it when my doctor was a student. I told one person to take their ass to med school and become the change they wanted to see.
I followed news of the tide turning, sharing that I had seen a video about European health regulators wondering what they would do when all the angry, bearded women who regretted switching gender as minors rose up to blame the government. I worried that posts telling hard truths would induce reddit to shut down the detrans subreddit. I was dismissive of a trans man's suicide, saying he was mentally unstable and that by next Friday he would have switched back to considering himself female again, though I also said people who do not share the decedent's mental illness are least likely to care what their final gender designation was.
I advocated for privacy about one's trans past, telling a detransitioned person not to tell their mother-in-law anything about their past gender identity — that they were allowed a private life, and that as an adult they were accountable to no one. I suggested breast reduction rather than full mastectomy for someone wanting smaller breasts, and recommended Express camisoles with built-in shelf bras for flat-chested folks. I complimented others' hair, undercut, necklaces, and style, and encouraged advancing education now that gender was less of a priority.
I was interested in one poster's spiritual practice, asking about the meaning of their necklaces and t-shirt and later recommending becomealivinggod.com forums for more Horus devotees. I also asked about endometriosis treatment when someone mentioned it.
Overall I came across as someone who had been badly served by transition medicine and by negligent parents, who had learned through harsh experience, and who wanted to spare others — especially young people — from making the same mistakes, while also believing that adults who choose to transition after full deliberation have the right to do so and bear responsibility for their own choices.