Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde männlich geboren, habe vor etwa einem Jahrzehnt nach 8 Monaten HRT in meinen frühen Zwanzigern von Mann-zu-Frau-Transition detransitioniert und identifiziere mich derzeit als Mann, der nicht maskulin ist. Ende 2022 kehrten meine Dysphorie und eine schwere depressive Episode zurück, nachdem ich trans Communities auf Reddit und 4chan ausgesetzt war, und lösten die Angst aus, „schlafwandelnd in die Retransition zu geraten“, obwohl ich das rational nicht will. Meine ursprüngliche Dysphorie führe ich auf Trauma im Teenageralter, Isolation und das Scheitern an Männlichkeit zurück statt darauf, im falschen Körper geboren zu sein, und ich identifiziere mich seit meinem 13. Lebensjahr als AGP. Ich vermute, dass ich Autismus oder eine zwangsgetriebene Gender-Fixierung haben könnte, und meine Dysphorie wirkt wie eine Obsession, die mit Depression schlimmer wird. Ich sehe die moderne trans Kultur weiterhin kritisch, unterstütze aber die Freiheit Erwachsener zu transitionieren, und ich fürchte immer noch, später im Leben erneut zu transitionieren.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male, and I'm 34 years old as of this writing in February 2023. My gender dysphoria began around age 16-18, soon after my first major depressive episode, during a period of extreme social isolation and internet addiction. Looking back, I believe the original dysphoria was mostly caused by trauma from not acting manly enough and from that extreme isolation during identity formation as a teenager — the female persona was, in my own words, "a cope to fit in."
I first medicalised this at 23-24, when I was on MtF HRT for 8 months and lived part-time as a woman during some of those months. I stopped after that because I felt better and resumed living as a man, though the desire to be a woman never fully went away — it just caused me much less distress. I detransitioned about 10 years before this post (so around 2013). I tried living as a man who isn't masculine, but it didn't bring me many friends or lovers.
For many years I didn't think about transitioning at all, until about two years before this post (around 2021) I started taking DHT blockers again to avoid balding — I don't consider this real HRT, but it made me feel a little better and lowered my already-low libido further, which I prefer. Then, about four months before this post (around October 2022), intense dysphoria resurfaced along with a major depressive episode. Around that same time I began lurking trans pages on Reddit and, worse, the /lgbt/ board on 4chan — a site I normally avoid. I called that "a very terrible mistake." Those spaces pushed the idea that dysphoria can only be cured by transition, or else you're doomed to transition late or commit suicide. I saw timelines of people who transitioned at the age I once did with great results, and I felt envious and started thinking I should have kept transitioning. After a few months I stopped browsing those sites and felt somewhat better, but the harm was done.
I want to be clear with myself: I don't really want to retransition. My rational brain knows transition won't solve anything, because the problem comes from my brain, not my body. But the emotional part of my brain keeps screaming at me, and I fear "sleepwalking into retransition" someday, even 30 years from now. I feel like I missed the ship — that everyone like me (unmasculine AMAB people) is transitioning early and getting happier while I stayed at the bottom of the social hierarchy. Trying to act more masculine never worked and made me feel the worst; my personality isn't feminine exactly, but it's soft and not interested in most guy things.
On sexuality: I've been told I'm AGP and I accept that, technically, since age 13, though I never desired to crossdress and only wore women's clothes after starting HRT, and I never liked sissy pornography. I never felt much desire to have sex with people of either sex; I feel strong attachment but I'm unsure if it's romantic. My libido was always low and I prefer it that way.
Mental health-wise, intense dysphoria for me always arrives with a major depressive episode, and I don't know which causes which or if they share a source. I suspect I might be autistic, or possibly have some form of OCD that makes me fixate on gender — I'm terrified I could have either. I obsess about whether behaviours will be seen as feminine or masculine. I don't know for sure if I even have clinical gender dysphoria; in an FAQ I described it as "more like an obsession" that only feels really bad when I'm depressed. I cope by focusing on other things and by accepting there are things I can't change.
My reasons for having detransitioned, which I listed in April 2023, were: total lack of social support (everyone stopped talking to me or was openly hostile, and my family couldn't sleep at night and blamed themselves); fear I couldn't pass, especially given my height, though my face was decent; not actually feeling like a woman trapped in a man's body, but like "a loser who wanted to be a woman because I failed as a man"; disagreeing with the trans community and finding them closed to different ideas; the exhausting effort of feminising my mannerisms; the catty, gatekeeping behaviour of trans women toward each other; the constant, frustrating work of voice and makeup training; being told I wasn't acting enough like a woman by the same people who'd said I wasn't acting enough like a man; the pressure to learn everything fast as someone with low energy; disgust at the trans community's obsession with transitioning children; and the trans community's low view of gender-nonconforming people of their natal sex.
Currently I identify as a man who is not masculine. I don't hate trans people, but I'm critical of modern trans culture: I think the modern narrative is based on 50-year-old stereotypes, that gender identity and gender dysphoria aren't innate, and that in at least 90% of cases being trans is caused by external factors. I support adults being free to transition if they want, but I'm against minors on HRT. I think transition is escapism for many people — a chance to become a new person while the core personality stays the same. I also believe AGP is a real, unusual sexual orientation, not a dangerous fetish, and that it can lead to dysphoria through "falling in love" with an idealized female self, especially when other life problems exist. I shared an article arguing gender dysphoria exists but isn't the same as being trans, and that reframing dysphoria as a physical rather than mental-health problem caused the rise in transition and detransition. I try to advise others to think very hard before doing anything to their body, to stay away from 4chan, and to remember it's fine to be gender-nonconforming without transitioning. My fear of retransitioning after 40 persists, but I accept I can't control how I'll think in the future.