Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein desistierter Mann, der kurz davor war, mit HRT zu beginnen, es aber nie tat, nachdem ich erkannt hatte, dass ich vor allem für Freundschaft und Akzeptanz transitionierte und dass es meine Depression nicht heilen würde. Ich habe desistiert, trage gelegentlich immer noch Overknees und arbeite an den Wurzeln meiner psychischen Probleme. Ich identifiziere mich nicht mehr als trans und finde meinen früheren Weg zur Transition peinlich. Ich sehe medizinische Transition kritisch, besonders bei Kindern, unterstütze aber Einzelne in beide Richtungen. Suizidgedanken, Selbstverletzung oder Versuche habe ich nicht beschrieben.
Vollständige Geschichte
I never actually started hormone replacement therapy, but I came very close, and looking back on that period disgusts me. In the years before 2022 I had fantasized about becoming female, and I came out to small groups of friends under a new name. I got a lot of support and felt accepted and happy for a time — I thought I was finally being true to myself. I was talking to a doctor about starting HRT and had an appointment set up, but I kept putting it off for a few weeks because I was hiding all of this from my parents. In the end that delay turned out to be the right decision: the people who had been supportive and made me feel welcome slowly stopped talking to me. That loss made me realize that even if I had gone through with transition I still wouldn't have been happy.
I ended up in a dark place after that, but I pulled through. I came to understand that I had been chasing a dopamine hit through the idea of HRT and transition, and that it wouldn't work. I also recognized that I had wanted to transition partly just to have friends and to be accepted — that I didn't like my body and thought maybe if I were female I'd fit in. After a long time I realized I was just as depressed as before and wasn't treating the root cause of my mental health issues. I have desisted and realized that being female wasn't actually me. I'm still working on my mental health.
I do still sometimes wear thigh highs and I like the way it feels, but I know now that transition isn't the answer. I've described my own experience as being 'guilty' of attempting to transition for social acceptance, and I look back at what I wrote and did during that period with disgust.
On the medical side, I never took hormones and had no surgeries, so there are no irreversible changes or fertility concerns from transition for me. I do think about voice: I work in a job where I voice things, and I've told a detransitioned woman that she sounds like a woman with a slightly deeper voice that I'd have no problem using for a female commercial part.
My views on transition for others are conditional and somewhat critical. I believe a very minute, infinitesimally small percentage of people — particularly those born intersex — genuinely need medical transition. I think everyone has some form of body dysmorphia to some degree, and that both body dysmorphia and being trans are mental illnesses with a deeper root cause that needs mental health support and treatment. I'm strongly against medical transition for children. My preferred approach is: don't transition medically, especially children, but be supportive of the person — because for some people it really is true, and if they detransition you have to be supportive of them too. I've also expressed concern that a large percentage of transgender youth don't identify as transgender as adults, that youths transition for friendship (citing UK studies), and that there is adult pressure and manipulation involved — describing the environment around youth transition as 'a cult with pressure from adults' and referencing algorithmic manipulation by China via TikTok as a destabilizing factor. I've commented that some groups seem 'transphobic' and also against people transitioning back, existing 'for chaos sake,' and I've said a particular outcome 'genuinely saddens' me.
I have not described any activism or advocacy work beyond commenting online.