Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte/butch-identifizierte Frau, geboren 1978 in Brasilien, die nie medizinisch transitionierte, aber lange an ihrem Geschlecht zweifelte, beeinflusst durch körperlichen, sexuellen und emotionalen Missbrauch in der Kindheit durch meine Mutter, einen distanzierten/missbrauchenden Vater, eine durch hohes Androstendion bedingte Maskulinisierung als Teenager und Einflüsse aus Medien und Internet. Nach einer ausgiebigen Therapie wegen komplexer PTBS habe ich mich als maskuline Butch-Lesbe mit einer Ehefrau, einem anständigen Job und Hobbys eingependelt, und meine verbliebene Dysphorie bewältige ich durch natürliches Bodybuilding, Meditation, Zen-Lektüre und gute Ernährung. Ich unterstütze grundsätzlich körperliche Selbstbestimmung, sehe medizinische Transition aber skeptisch, rate anderen aktiv von Hormonen/Operationen ab und ermutige zu traumainformierter Therapie. Operationen, Hormone oder medizinische Komplikationen im Zusammenhang mit einer Detransition habe ich nicht beschrieben, da ich nie Testosteron genommen habe. Ich bin am Leben und engagiert, nachdem ich um das Alter von 17 eine suizidale Phase überlebt habe.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born in Brazil in 1978, and back then nobody talked about trans people — there were a few "travestites" living underground, TVs were filled with machismo, gays appeared only as jokes, and women were always shown as "sexual." My father had a previous marriage that produced one son and three daughters; the son turned out to be gay and the three girls were very feminine and heterosexual. My father later divorced his first wife and got my mother pregnant with me. My mother told me when I was young that my father had wanted a boy. She let me play with all kinds of toys and would say things like "boys' toys are more fun" and "being a woman sucks." My male cousins had privileges I did not.
One day I found my father's stash of Playboy magazines and got hooked; I remember clearly thinking "I can only have a girlfriend if I become a man." My mother used to say "lesbian is a cuss word, don't ever say that word in front of anyone." On the other hand, my mother did things to me that can be considered sex abuse but were excused as "medical necessities." I have described my mother as a classical homophobe closet case. In another comment I wrote plainly: "Yes I have a history of childhood trauma. Mom was abusive physically, sexually and emotionally. Father was sometimes distant sometimes emotionally abusive. I hated him more that I hated her however." I said it wasn't clear to me at the beginning of therapy because my mother's sexual abuse was subtle, but after months of therapy it became obvious, and I wrote that "Oedipus complex definitely happened in my case," preferring Alice Miller's writing to Freud's overall.
As a teenager I had high androstenedione and developed some masculine characteristics, which I was happy about, but I felt like I wasn't enough. I have a naturally flat chest, nether parts a bit bigger than average, and I'm above-average muscular for a woman. When I was in my late teens the internet arrived and I discovered that lesbians were normal people — the old text chats were a revolution. The desire to become a man was always in the back of my mind, though. Contrary to what I expected, I managed to have girlfriends and eventually a wife while being a masculine woman.
When the transgender "wave" started I questioned myself constantly. I had serious discussions with many people and it never really made sense; I could never find a definitive "reason" why I should transition. I never went on testosterone. The main reason I didn't go forward was that I would never have a functioning penis, plus all the unknown risks of hormones and surgeries — "I didn't want more complications, I wanted a simpler life." After a lot of therapy I settled down, realizing I can be a masculine woman and that's okay. I now feel I can project my masculinity more strongly as a woman than I would if I transitioned, because masculinity in a woman stands out immediately.
I have CPTSD and spent a long time questioning my gender and the meaning of life. Now I spend my time doing what I like and what is healthy for my body; when unhealthy thoughts show up I use meditation and read Zen books (Hardcore Zen helped me). I do deep breathing and gratitude practice each morning, meditate about 20 minutes, and read about CPTSD to understand trauma. My dysphoria improved after I started natural bodybuilding and calisthenics — after four years my chest muscles are big enough that they make my breasts look smaller, and my shoulders are now slightly wider than my hips. I take vitamin D, zinc, omega-3, and sometimes essential amino acids.
I identify as a butch lesbian; I use a masculine name on Reddit and just tell people I'm a butch lesbian when they get confused. I have a wife who loves me, a decent job, and hobbies. I like being queer. I've never had issues with bathrooms — I say "I have a vagina" if someone objects, and my feminine voice helps. I've used krav maga successfully against a handsy situation and a pickpocket. I carry things to defend myself and I'm not afraid to die, because psychopaths can be insistent.
I'm generally supportive of bodily autonomy — I think everyone should be free to pursue body modifications without having to define themselves as trans or any gender — but I'm skeptical of transition as a solution and critical of the medical pathway. I've advised others against hormones and surgery, encouraged therapy with trauma experience, meditation, exercise, and good nutrition, and told people they don't owe anyone an explanation for changing their mind. I've discussed religion critically, saying the Old Testament is full of prejudice and recommending Buddhism, Taoism, Witchcraft, Candomblé, or atheism for people suffering from gender dysphoria, homophobia, and misogyny. I've said "we need an FTM explosion to happen in order for a detrans explosion to happen" so experiences become clearer for everybody. I've been open about conversion therapy being torture — "Therapy is not supposed to convert anyone to anything."
I've been active in supporting LGBTQ+ people in crisis, telling one suicidal person "We need you alive to help the LGBTQ+ community" and sharing that I was in a similar position at 17 and that thinking about the community kept me going: "If I died it means that the fascists won. No way. I'm 43 now, still alive, still weird. I won people's respect through study and work."