Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich begann mit 17, mich als trans zu identifizieren, und startete die HRT, ließ mir kurz vor meinem 18. Geburtstag mit Zustimmung meiner Eltern und auf Empfehlung meiner Therapeutin eine doppelte Mastektomie machen und habe dann mit 19 detransitioniert, als ich merkte, dass die HRT meine Dysphorie nicht linderte. Heute bin ich eine detransitionierte Frau im Großraum New York, arbeite in der akademischen Forschung und lebe mit anhaltender Geschlechtsdysphorie, mit der ich mich vermutlich lebenslang auseinandersetzen muss. Ich hatte eine Brustrekonstruktion mit Gewebeexpandern und kämpfe mit einer Stimme in männlicher Lage, habe mich aber gegen Stimmtraining entschieden, weil ich es als schädlich für meine psychische Gesundheit empfand. Ich war als Kind Opfer von Missbrauch und bin den größten Teil meines Lebens immer wieder in Therapie gewesen. Ich plädiere für ein differenzierteres Verständnis von Transition und argumentiere, dass sie keine Universallösung für Geschlechtsdysphorie ist und manchen Menschen nicht helfen wird.
Vollständige Geschichte
I started HRT at 17, and with my therapist's recommendation and my parents' consent I had a double mastectomy later that same year, just before my 18th birthday. I detransitioned at 19. I began HRT at age 17, and with the recommendation of my therapist & consent of my parents I received a double mastectomy later that year, just before my 18th birthday. I detransitioned at 19 (and I'll turn 24 next month, for context). I've been working remotely with a psychologist in the UK for the past few years (as I've found it much easier to find a UK-based professional who's working to delve into the issues underlying my struggles with gender identity -- for context, I'm based in the greater NYC area). I've given her my consent to have an anonymized version of my story used at multiple medical conventions across the UK. I could've kept mine, but I wasn't happy with the way they were shaped by the original surgeon who'd performed my mastectomy (or where the grafts would sit after implants were added) so I requested for them to be removed. Tissue expanders are standard practice for delayed reconstruction after mastectomy, regardless of the original purpose of the mastectomy. I have them in right now, lol. I would press it without hesitation. I detransitioned when I realized that HRT did nothing to ameliorate my dysphoria, not because my dysphoria spontaneously resolved itself. (I suspect dysphoria is something I'll be managing for the rest of my life, though I hope that I'm wrong.) I attempted voice training off and on again when I first detransitioned but ultimately decided that the vague goal I was working toward wasn't worth the harm to my mental health that that sort of scrutiny towards my own speaking caused me. As I can tell all research around VFS surgery has been exclusively conducted on MTF/AMAB patients so far, so it's unclear how helpful those surgeries could even be for us (though it's been on my radar for years as well). I've been able to live as a woman for about four years now despite my male-register voice (and my own hatred for it). I know there are a lot of us here in NYC. I detransitioned seven years ago and I'm still so jealous of my cis people so viscerally it sometimes feels like an actual wound. I'm working in academic research in a topic I've loved for years and I've just this year finally established a real social group who understands me as a dysphoric former-transsexual and finds that the least interesting thing about me. I will always want to be in a different body. I didn't detransition because I suddenly stopped wanted that, I detransitioned because after years of hrt I realized I would never be able to live stealth and that trying to do so ultimately only exacerbated my dysphoria my making me hyper-cognizant of all the ways I didn't pass and would never be biologically male. I suspect I will never be happy with my sex or my body as long as I live. There is no world in which I wouldn't rather be male than female but at least right now I would rather be a dysphoric female able to work on the things I do and have the friends that I have than be a dead person (which is a markable improvement from where I was just a few years ago.) That website's a shit-show. The entire concept of having a list with links to people you've never interacted with but presume to have opposite beliefs as you is actually bizarre (doubly so because they have me listed by my legal name instead of my current name, while purporting to stand self-identification as a human right...?) As a detransitioner who's been through years of therapy I feel like the problem isn't determining whether or not you're "trans" (by whatever nebulous metrics that necessitates), it's determining whether or not HRT will alleviate your particular brand of dysphoria. In many cases therapists are taught to affirm HRT as an immediate solution for gender dysphoric patients which in some cases does us a great disservice: throughout history there have been (and always will be) gender dysphoric people who can't/don't/won't be helped by transition and pretending otherwise is just silly. I'm (also?) a childhood abuse victim who's been in and out of therapy for most of my life. I think the experience of transitioning makes us hyperaware of the subtle tells of human sexual dimorphism. I never felt that I passed but there were multiple times acquaintances were genuinely surprised to find out I was trans back when I was living that way; on the other side, I tend to catch on when people are trans much quicker than others. This was the primary factor behind my detransition. I didn't detransition because I stopped seeing myself as/wanting to be a man, I detransitioned because living as a transgender male made me hyperaware of all the ways in which my body differed from a biological male's and ultimately that worsened my dysphoria significantly. I'm glad that transition helps some people but it's disingenuious to pretend it's a one-size-fits-all cure (or that those of us for whom it didn't work must have never been actually dysphoric, not "real" trans people, right-wing plants, etc). I felt the exact same as you before transitioning. I'm a dysphoric woman and I always will be. It sucks, but it's absolutely not a death sentence. As a fellow Christian I just think you should be mindful of where your words are needed and how they might be interpreted when the issue at hand is as nuanced as this one.