Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter schwuler Mann (früher als trans Frau, MTF, identifiziert), der ein paar Jahre lang, mit Unterbrechungen, Östrogen und Blocker nahm und von heute auf morgen aufhörte. Ich war von früher Kindheit an feminin und wurde ab etwa zwölf durch Online-Trans-Aktivismus gegroomt, outete mich mit achtzehn und begann nach einem hastigen Dreißig-Minuten-Termin mit Hormonen. Mein erster Detransitionsversuch wurde durch Gruppendruck und Schuldgefühle vereitelt, was zu zwei weiteren kurzen Hormonphasen führte, bevor ich endgültig aufhörte und begriff, dass ich in einer Sekte gewesen war. Heute lebe ich als femininer schwuler Mann ohne Dysphorie, erkenne, dass meine Transition von internalisierter Homophobie und Scham über meine Weiblichkeit getrieben war, und finde langsam ein gesundes Gleichgewicht mit femininem Ausdruck. Mich belasten weiterhin das bleibende Brustwachstum (etwa ein B-Körbchen) und der Verlust meiner Jugend, und ich setze mich für Detrans-Stimmen, explorative Therapie vor der Medikalisierung und den Schutz von Kindern vor Gender-Medizin ein.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and I am a gay man who detransitioned after years of identifying as a trans woman (MTF) and living as a woman. My femininity was apparent from very early childhood — I had feminine interests, a feminine voice, walk and mannerisms, all my friends were girls, and I was often mistaken for a girl. One of my clearest early memories is telling my parents I wished I was a girl, which I later realized I only said because they told me I couldn't do certain things or wear certain clothes because I was a boy; they spent the rest of my childhood trying to change my feminine behaviour, which intensified my shame. I was also developing an attraction toward men and felt deeply ashamed of it. I got unfiltered internet access at around age ten, and from roughly age twelve I was exposed to trans activism online — being repeatedly told my feelings meant I was really a girl, that anyone who disagreed was a bigot, and that the qualities people had shamed me for were now celebrated. I now describe this as being groomed or indoctrinated from a young age; by the time I turned eighteen, going onto hormones felt like a given, and I say the damage was long done even though I was technically an adult.
I came out first among my friend group as the 'true trans' one, and before long my entire friend group adopted the trans identity; a few years later they all desisted, though it took me longer because I was the only one who went as far as taking HRT. I never took testosterone — I was on estrogen and blockers. I was prescribed estradiol and blockers after a first visit with a doctor that lasted about thirty minutes, during which years of mental health and body image issues were not acknowledged; I had hormones ready to pick up by the end of the day. The doctor did not go over side effects and I had to remind her to do a physical exam, to which she replied, 'i guess i should.' She now runs her own clinic with even fewer checks and balances. I also had a deep gut feeling of mistake on the day my name was legally changed and on the day I started HRT, but I chalked it up to 'internalized transphobia.'
I fit what is described as HSTS (homosexual transsexual): feminine from childhood, and when I came out and transitioned it 'just made sense' to a lot of people. But one early sign of unhappiness was an utter disgust I felt whenever I tried to view myself in any sexual manner; I thought I'd grow into it through transition but never did, and I began missing my male sexuality so much it felt like a piece of me was missing. On estrogen I felt essentially sexless — this helped me realize I had to quit. I also developed breast growth to roughly a B cup, which I can't afford to have surgically removed and don't want the scars from; I experience body horror every time I look down in the shower, and I've dealt with breast growth pain. Otherwise I'm lucky that you can't really tell I was on hormones.
My first detransition attempt happened when I wasn't ready to embrace being a man; when I stopped hormones I identified as nonbinary. A former trans friend insisted I was 'taking on a transphobic identity' for physically detransitioning and believed I should make my body more androgynous, and some friends couldn't accept me being non-conforming without it being medicalized. I wrote a long message in my notes app apologizing to the trans community and promising to keep advocating for their rights, but it meant nothing — I was still labeled a transphobe and friends distanced themselves. I ended up back on hormones for five months out of guilt, then went off again; later I retransitioned again and after six months went back off HRT and finally realized I was in a cult. I quit cold turkey with zero withdrawals, other than perhaps feeling more tired for a while. As of mid-2024 I was around nine to ten months off HRT after being on and off for a couple of years, and my libido returned to normal within about a week of stopping.
I never went to therapy before transitioning because I assumed they'd just tell me what I wanted to hear, but in hindsight I think someone saying 'slow down a bit and let's figure out what caused you to feel this way' could have saved me a lot of pain and lost time. I've asked other detransitioners about reversing legal changes — name, gender markers on ID and birth certificate — fearing an expensive road ahead. I've asked about compression shirts for my chest, being clear I don't want anything that restricts breathing. I've also asked how long after stopping estrogen it takes for the extra tissue to dissipate, wondering at nearly ten months off if there's still hope of them getting smaller.
I experienced being targeted by detrans fetishists: after posting here I received multiple DMs from men posing as detransitioners, including one claiming to be a detransitioning MTFM who'd had 'the surgery' and asking if I had it; their histories showed activity in castration and forced-detrans fetish subreddits. I also received a 'reaching out' welfare message from Reddit after my first post here, which had called out people illegally providing hormones to minors.
On causes, I now believe my transition was driven by deeply internalized homophobia, strict gender roles, and shame about my femininity and same-sex attraction. I said things like 'I wish I was a girl' because I was told I couldn't do girl things as a boy, and I transitioned because it was easier than living as an openly feminine gay man. I also envied the ability to find a partner and live a normal life without homophobia or being seen as 'other.' I now identify as a feminine gay man without dysphoria, recognizing that what I have is shame for my femininity rather than dysphoria. When I first detransitioned I distanced myself from femininity to be accepted as a man, but I now see that as repression in the opposite direction and am bit by bit finding a healthy medium — it's okay to wear makeup for a special occasion without needing it every day. I feel I'm learning to be myself for the first time instead of performing stereotypes.
I'm critical of how the wider gender-critical/right ecosystem treats detransitioners, noting many detransitioners get pulled into a right-wing rabbit hole and that it feels more like we're being pushed into it than pulled, making community hard to find when you haven't fallen for the propaganda. I disagree with conservatives on most things but say they're the only ones giving detrans people a voice right now. I wrote a post arguing that detrans voices need to be heard and that some people latch onto the anti-gender-ideology movement out of hate rather than a passion for women's, LGB and detrans rights, calling out gender-critical accounts that label gender-nonconforming men as fetishists or perverts without proof, since strict gender roles are what led me to transition. I also pushed back on a detrans poster who called drag 'freakish,' arguing that labeling feminine men as wrong contributes to the culture that caused many to transition, while agreeing kids should be kept away from all-ages events. I don't attend pride events anymore, saying they're trans-focused, corporatized and a party for virtue-signaling straight people that no longer represents me as a gay man. I've expressed that LGB without the T makes more sense to me now than it did before detransitioning, and that sexuality is real — having a penis is a base requirement of my homosexuality, not a 'genital preference.' I've also said I felt pressure to pretend to be bi for years to seem 'progressive enough.'
I've described the loss as my entire youth — my teen years through turning twenty-two, all gone — and said it sent me into an identity crisis when everything I believed came crumbling down, shaping my worldview, making me paranoid that everyone, even those trying to be supportive, were bigots out to get me, and making me scared to go into public because I'd been convinced I was at risk of being harassed or killed at any turn. I said none of that goes away just because you drop the identity, and that it feels like learning to be human for the first time. I've said I spent nearly half my life believing I was meant to transition, made that identity my entire personality for years, and permanently damaged my body before realizing it was a lie, and that being told detransitioners were 'never trans' is a slap in the face. I've expressed jealousy of another detrans man whose chest had recovered, saying I'm 'stuck here with these b cups for life.' I've also noted that even at peak trans delusion I never wished for a period and saw through 'fake puberty' as nonsense. I've been told by others that I look much happier and healthier since detransitioning, and congratulated on a successful detransition.