Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte, sich als nicht-binär identifizierende Person, weiblich geboren, die drei Jahre lang (2016–2019) Testosteron nahm und im August 2019 aufhörte, weil ich erkannte, dass ich größtenteils transitioniert war, weil mir nicht gefiel, wie die Gesellschaft mich als Mädchen behandelte. Nach dem Absetzen von T habe ich intensiv mit Bedauern und dem Hass auf mein Aussehen gekämpft, aber mit der Unterstützung meiner Mama, meines Freundes, meiner Schwester und meiner Freunde habe ich mir vergeben und fühlte mich im Oktober 2020 wieder gut mit mir. Zu den bleibenden Veränderungen, mit denen ich lebe, gehören eine vertiefte Stimme, ein kantigerer Kiefer und dickerer Hals, Gesichts- und Körperbehaarung und ein insgesamt androgynes Aussehen, das es mir unangenehm macht, mich als cis Frau zu identifizieren. Ich identifiziere mich derzeit als nicht-binär, benutze einen gewählten Namen und habe eine Mirena-Spirale. Ich habe in der Community offen über die Lücke zwischen den Versprechen der trans Community und meiner Erfahrung mit der Welt nach dem Durchgehen als Mann gesprochen.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female, and I identified as trans for several years before detransitioning. I first identified as non-binary, then as a trans man, and I took testosterone for three years, from 2016 to 2019, stopping in August 2019. I changed my name to Euan while I was identifying as trans (my mom said that's what she would have named me if I'd been born male), and when I detransitioned I changed it to Yewin because I wanted something more unique and non-binary.
The reason I transitioned, as I've come to understand it, was that I didn't "identify" with the way I was treated as a girl in society. I didn't like how society treated me as a female. I never used to hate how I looked before taking testosterone, but after stopping I began to despise my appearance. My voice sounds like a man's, my neck is thicker, my forehead is more pronounced, my jaw is more square, and I have hair on my chin, upper thighs, and belly. A year after stopping T I still had scruff on my chin. I described myself as permanently androgynous, "much to my chagrin."
In August 2020 I posted that I was seriously struggling with the decision I'd made. I wrote that I deeply hated myself and that it wasn't getting better. I asked for support. Afterward I talked to people who love me and whom I love, and we came to the decision that even if I don't find myself beautiful, I can start by believing that they think I am beautiful.
Looking back, I think the biggest thing that might have helped me would have been to take a step back from the all-supporting trans community — they are wonderful people — but I never had room or space to question whether hormones were making ME happy, because it was making so many people happy FOR me. Once I "passed" as male I stepped back from the community and found I had actually been perceiving the way the trans community supports and fawns over trans men as how society would. When I actually went out into the world I was distraught at how different it was. I felt alone, mistreated, lied to, and really lonely. It wasn't at all what they said it would be like. After detransitioning I stopped going to trans groups, trans events, and trans marches, and I stopped seeing my trans friends regularly.
I didn't choose to detransition exactly — I found out it wasn't right for me, so I stopped. I went through an intense phase of regret, which I came to see as a natural part of the process. I told others going through it that parts of your body will change, some parts won't, but after the grieving process you can learn to love yourself the way you are. I wrote: "I love myself, I made a mistake but I can't hate myself because I made the decision for me and I believed it was right. I forgive myself."
When I first started detransitioning, makeup was a life saver. My sister and my cis female friends helped me learn a lot, and I got a beauty routine down — wash your face, get a nice cleanser and moisturizer — which helped with depression. I also gained a bit of weight when I went off T, which helped redistribute to more feminine spots. I'm on the Mirena IUD, which made me a bit more emotional, especially the first few months, and gave me some breast growth after about four months. When I stopped T my hair texture changed and it fell out for months — every shower scared me — but it stopped falling out after 9-10 months and after 14 months off, baby hairs around my hairline were growing back.
There was an incident at work shortly after I stopped T: I was cleaning the bathrooms and waiting for a male coworker to leave the men's bathroom, and he told me I could just come in. When I said it wasn't appropriate, he said, assuming I was male-to-female, "well, I see you the way God made you." I confronted him later and gave him a lecture about how a truly loving Christian wouldn't say things like that; he apologized. I didn't mention I wasn't trans, because I feel a sort of solidarity with trans women and felt like I'd be throwing them under the bus. I've focused on who I was rather than what other people thought I was, because that's what got me started on T in the first place.
My mom was similar to a smaller degree in her reaction to my transition; all I had to do was talk to her and answer her questions, because she was too worried about me to actually ask. I've advised others in similar situations to sit down with family and answer their questions.
On identity after detransition: being identified as female doesn't bother me, but identifying MYSELF as female causes me dysphoria, panic attacks, and depressive episodes. So I find it easier to identify as non-binary — it's a lesser of two evils thing, because if I identify as a cis female I get misgendered frequently, given how androgynous I now look. I was 24 when I detransitioned and 26 at the time of writing in October 2020. I go by my chosen name; only my mom, my partner, and government-type people are allowed to call me my legal name, otherwise it makes me cringe.
I have a boyfriend who is supportive — he showed me a compliment someone left about me and said "LOOK SEE?? Now you can't argue!!!" I have five people in my life who love me to the ends of the earth, I'm healthy, I have my mom's smile, and my voice is rich and unique. In October 2020 I posted a two-year-off-T update saying I was "just really vibing today and feeling cute as heck in my own special way." I wrote: "if I could try and change my physical body to be what I want then I can change my mental image of myself too. I'm great. You're great. Fuck gender."
I've thought a lot about why people transition. I asked publicly how a world without societal gender norms would affect medically transitioning people, as "a person who transitioned for the wrong reasons." I've advised others that society is cruel either way — to trans folk, to cis folk, to detrans folk — and that what you focus on determines how you view it. I recommended the book "The Places That Scare You" by Pema Chodron, a Zen Buddhist teacher, which helped me sit with and acknowledge difficult feelings rather than suppress them. I've also cautioned others against having surgery to avoid doing the work of voice training, warning it might leave them with a voice they like even less. I've been supportive and encouraging toward others considering detransition, telling them their feelings are valid and that I forgive myself for my own decision.