Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter/desistierter schwuler Mann aus Malaysia, als Mann geboren, der sich ab etwa 2010 als nichtbinäre Transfrau identifizierte und nur begrenzt nicht-permanente HRT nahm, bevor ich desistierte. Meine Dysphorie begann mit drei Jahren, und heute verstehe ich meinen Transitionswunsch als verwoben mit BPS, sexuellem Missbrauch in der Kindheit, Mobbing wegen meiner Weiblichkeit und dem Wunsch, das zu werden, was die Männer, die ich liebte, und meine Täter wollten. Ich habe mein Geschlecht als männlich akzeptiert, sehe mich als geschlechtsnonkonformen schwulen Mann mit Geschlechtsdysphorie und bin in Therapie wegen BPS, PTBS, Körperdysmorphie und GID. Ich habe Suizidgedanken und depressive Episoden überlebt und sehe jetzt sowohl Transition als universelle Antwort kritisch als auch das, was ich für ein zunehmend sektenhaftes Mainstream-Trans-Narrativ halte, das mich online gejagt und gemobbt hat.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born male and have known since I was about three years old that I did not identify with my genitals — I remember telling my mother I did not like my penis and that I was not supposed to have it, and she spent a long time assuring me I was a boy and that there was nothing wrong with me. That feeling never left me; it only grew worse over time. I grew up feminine and was bullied relentlessly, called a cry baby and a sissy from a young age because I liked things girls naturally like, and it never stopped.
I was raised by conservative Muslim parents. My mother has been supportive of me trying to ease my gender dysphoria; my father only knows I am gay and does not mind that much, but he is not supportive of me being trans. I am their only child, disabled and mentally ill, so I have had to stay living with them. I come from Malaysia, where being openly trans is dangerous — people can be sued, imprisoned, or sent to rehab if caught, and there is essentially no government support or acknowledgment of trans or detrans health care even though gender dysphoria is acknowledged. Most medical transition there is done illegally and DIY.
I identified as a non-binary trans woman for the longest time, from around 2010 onward, but I did not medically or socially transition except on rare occasions because of how dangerous it was. I tried to live independently in the big city, socially transition, and work, but it ended badly and I almost killed myself. I have struggled with my mental health since I was about twelve, but was only officially diagnosed with Borderline Personality Disorder at twenty-five, by which point I was already openly identifying as trans, suicidal, and critically depressed. I also have PTSD, probable childhood sexual abuse, body dysmorphia, and was diagnosed with gender dysphoria/GID. Suicidality and emotional dysregulation are, in my experience, the core of the disorder.
For years I presented as androgynous — long hair, beautifying myself — but I stopped that once I became depressed and suicidal, and started presenting as male. I had put HRT on hold because I was scared of making the worst decision I could not live with. Eventually I did take some form of HRT, but not enough to cause permanent changes. I also experimented with DIY HRT knowledge in my circle and saw friends on it develop blood, heart, and kidney problems.
What moved me toward desistance was a slow disillusionment. My first love got married, and my intense desire to become a woman abated somewhat. I realized that my desire to transition was bound up with wanting to be what the men I loved would want — with my BPD, the need to please and find validation from a favourite person, and the fantasy of becoming what my abusers had told me I should be, since they said constantly that I was better as a girl or woman. I was a victim of childhood sexual abuse and terrible bullying for being gay. I came to see that my goal of becoming a cis woman, giving birth, and having a family with a man was one hundred percent impossible — no amount of surgery or HRT would let me have my own children from my own body, or make a man love me. I accepted that ideal is not reality.
I now consider myself a gender non-conforming gay man with gender dysphoria. I have accepted that my sex is male and that sex is a biological reality that cannot be changed; I do not delude myself that identifying as trans makes me biologically female. I have let go of wanting to transition, though the physical dysphoria is still something I have to get through. I have survived suicidal ideation and depressive episodes, and I believe I can get through this. I am growing a beard and learning to accept myself as a feminine male; I still dress more femininely when my dysphoria is bad, but most of the time I just go with the flow. I am on antidepressants, which have made my body balloon up somewhat.
I have been in therapy to help me get over my GID, dysmorphia, and BPD. I am critical of transition as a universal answer and believe it is not for everyone and is not a permanent, inevitable choice. I do not want trans people or detransitioners to be harmed or denied help, medical support, or basic human rights, and I was myself a leftist and liberal, though I am now neither conservative nor leftist liberal. But I am strongly critical of the current mainstream LGBT narrative, which I see as postmodern and increasingly cult-like — denying biological reality, silencing critics, and hounding detransitioners. I shared my detrans story and my view that we should be more careful with the gender thing, and was hounded on social media and called transphobic. Non-binary and queer people have bullied me online the most and treated me like a disgusting traitor, as though my experience were a nuisance to their existence. I compare this to my former religion, Islam, which functioned the same way: do not question, do not criticise, just accept the mainstream interpretation. I hate and criticise the ideology without hating the people, just as I am critical of Islam without agreeing with anti-Muslim bigotry. I believe nothing is above criticism — ideas do not have rights, humans do.