Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die sich einst als binärer trans Mann und kurz als nichtbinär identifizierte, aber desistierte, nachdem ich erkannt hatte, dass ich geringes Selbstwertgefühl als Teenager und verinnerlichte Misogynie für Geschlechtsdysphorie gehalten hatte. Ich nahm nie Testosteron und hatte keine Operation, und ich finde es jetzt freudvoll, eine Frau zu sein, kleide mich aber weiterhin maskulin und arbeite in einem männlich dominierten Bereich. Ich habe BPS und habe darüber nachgedacht, wie kognitive Dissonanz meine frühere Überzeugung von der Dysphorie aufrechterhielt. Ich bin kritisch gegenüber der heutigen Transgender-Bewegung und medizinischen Eingriffen an intergeschlechtlichen Kindern und unterstütze andere in der Detrans-Community aktiv.
Vollständige Geschichte
I grew up clearly extremely masculine, even as a tomboy, but I never felt anything about being uncomfortable with being a girl. I was a very short girl with a pretty big chest, and I was overweight as a teenager, and I mistook the low self-esteem and lack of confidence that came with looking, in my words, like 'a shapeless bunch of curves that aren't even good curves' for gender dysphoria. The more I bought into the idea that I definitely couldn't possibly be female, the more excuses I coughed up to insist I was male — even exaggerating stories to ignore the growing cognitive dissonance when people pointed out that 'that's just a nerdy hobby, girls can be nerdy too' or that liking men's clothes doesn't make anyone a man.
At one point I had the crushing realisation that what I had been supporting was traditional gender norms, which hurt a lot because I thought I was pro-woman and progressive. I had been touting that because I liked things a lot of men enjoy, dressed masculinely, and was in a male-dominated education, this proved I was male. I had to face the fact that subconsciously I simply didn't think I, a woman, was capable of liking 'boy's toys' or traditionally masculine hobbies — that I had trampled on every woman who fought to do men's jobs. It was not that I wanted to be a man; I was scared of being a woman. I was scared people wouldn't take me seriously if they saw me, a woman, in STEM, liking extremely nerdy things, or dressing so masculinely I looked quite male. I genuinely didn't believe there were plenty of women just like me who simply didn't care.
I also entertained identifying as nonbinary for a while, but only because I thought 'sure, I'm not male, but I'm just not a woman.' I actually hate that phase of my life more than the phase when I identified as a binary trans man — I was essentially doing 'I'm not like other girls... because...' with extra steps. I had to kick it and stop believing that being woman is shameful, disgusting, bitchy, or emotional.
I never went through the irreversible effects of testosterone or had top surgery, and I now realise that had I done so, my life would have gone down the drain, because being a woman is extremely joyful to me now. I still dress to the point of being mistaken as male, enjoy extremely nerdy things, and pursue a career in a male-dominated field. I have facial hair that I've never shaved or hidden — I never noticed how prominent my moustache was until a girl I was seeing told me she loved it, at which point I had desisted fully. I like the androgyny it gives me.
I have experienced BPD, which I understand involves a hollow sense of self and jarring lack of identity that makes one latch onto something to feel they have a role in life. I've discussed how cognitive dissonance sustained my former conviction about dysphoria, including deliberately exaggerating stories about how dysphoria was felt on my body. I've reflected that the contemporary transgender movement is a re-invention and doubling down of traditional gender norms, and that many young people conflate low self-esteem and the brutality of girlhood under patriarchy with gender dysphoria — with the reverse being cis women goaded into boob jobs and fillers, both driven by hate of women.
I have been active in the detrans community, offering support and reflections to others, including welcoming an intersex person and discussing my own discomfort with intersex being included in the LGBT acronym. I've expressed strong views against performing life-altering surgeries on healthy intersex children and against the medicalisation of vulnerable young people, and I hope detransition — especially detransitioning intersex people — gets more honest coverage. I have also been in a relationship with a woman. I currently identify as a woman and am at peace with it.