Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich wurde weiblich geboren, transitionierte als Teenager sozial, nahm mit 18 für zwei Jahre Pubertätsblocker und Testosteron, lebte etwa fünf Jahre als Transmann und detransitionierte um 2016, nachdem mir klar wurde, dass die Transition mich nie männlich machen würde. Ich identifiziere mich jetzt als detransitionierte, gender-kritische Frau: Ich bin mit einem heterosexuellen Mann verheiratet, habe einen Job, habe mit meinem Körper Frieden geschlossen und sage, dass ich nichts bereue, auch wenn ich gelegentlich noch Dysphorie habe und Fremde mein Geschlecht etwa 50/50 einordnen. Nach dem Absetzen von T war ich über ein Jahr klinisch depressiv, bin aber jetzt stabil und insgesamt glücklich. Ich glaube, dass verinnerlichte Misogynie die Hauptursache meiner Dysphorie war und dass Trans-Sein ein Bewältigungsmechanismus und kein angeborener Zustand ist. Ich möchte offen über Detransition sprechen, um anderen zu helfen, fühle mich aber nicht imstande, es öffentlich zu tun, aus Angst, als transphob abgestempelt zu werden.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was born female. I first experienced what I would later call gender dysphoria around age 12, when I had a crisis about 'stuck being female' — what I described as an 'oh no, I'm stuck being female, what an unutterably cruel cosmic joke' feeling. I wanted to be male from around age nine, fantasising about being the cool men in films and history — gangsters in Gangs of New York, characters in Lord of the Rings, Ancient Rome — rather than 'the one lady who I can't relate to at all.' I came out and socially transitioned as a teenager; my mother initially thought it was a phase and put me through pain, which I later felt guilty about. I was on puberty blockers for a while, started testosterone at 18, and took it for two years before stopping. I started passing after about a month on T. I identified as trans and lived as a transman for about five years before detransitioning; my detransition happened roughly five years before March 2021 (so around 2016), triggered by encountering, for the very first time, a woman who was living with dysphoria without transitioning. That prompted questioning that led me to detransition.
I detransitioned because I finally accepted that transition was never going to give me what I wanted, which was to be male. 'The only option left was to make peace with reality.' I believe misogyny is the main cause of my dysphoria, and I now identify as gender-critical. I don't believe anyone is 'actually trans' — for me, 'being trans' equals identifying as trans, and it's a coping mechanism for dysphoria rather than an innate state. I also don't identify as non-binary because I consider the whole concept of gender identity 'misguided and sexist'; to me 'woman' simply describes my body, nothing more.
Coming off T, my period returned after about a year, and it has since been lighter and less painful than before. When my first post-T period started, about a year after my last shot, it was a moving experience — 'some kind of pseudo-spiritual connection to other women and the moon and shit.' I was clinically depressed for over a year after detransitioning, though there were other contributing factors at the time. I had been very isolated and lonely at first, and found chronic loneliness more painful than I'd imagined, partly from friends graduating and moving away. It's been over five years now (as of early 2021) and I'm stable and happy overall, though I still have mood swings sometimes. I still have dysphoria, but it's manageable — 'those are occasional bad nights, not normal days.' On normal days I don't think negatively about my body and don't compare myself to men, though deep down I still want to look like a tall handsome man; I've trained myself to redirect those thoughts. I still get a roughly 50/50 split in how people read my sex, regardless of how I dress or wear my hair, five/six years off T. I still have a 'scraggly little beard.' I always wear sports bras; I'd like to be flat sometimes but worry that buying a binder would risk 'opening a door that leads me back to dependence and unhealthy ways of dealing with dysphoria.'
What helped me: realising as an adult that I probably wouldn't have achieved my childhood dreams anyway, which was liberating; reading second-wave feminist fiction (Egalia's Daughters by Gerd Brantenberg, The Female Man by Joanna Russ) and the Scum Manifesto to combat internalised misogyny; accepting my sex as a neutral biological fact; learning not to compare myself to men; and time. I lost friends for criticising trans politics and exited the capital-Q 'Queer Community' — six years ago when I was a student all my friends were Queer, and now that word is a red flag for me. A Mountain Goats song, Heel Turn 2, became about detransition for me and gave me strength in the early months.
I'm bi, and I'm now in a monogamous straight relationship. I met my fiancé online, as friends, the year after I came off T; I warned him before meeting in person that I was still 'normalising' from T and dressing very masc. He's straight, had little to do with the lgbt world, took it in stride, and we were dating within a few months. We're now married ('Detransed, got married, got a job'). I'd like to have children within the next few years. I work in a large team with mostly women who wear long hair/makeup — all except me and one butch lesbian coworker, who came out as they/them shortly after Ellen Page did, leaving me the odd one out again. Some people assume I'm a transwoman; I tell them my actual situation so they know what they're in for. I find it hard when people come out to me one-to-one; I handle it by staying warm and playful and not linking it back to myself.
I don't regret anything about transition/detransition. I detransitioned because I accepted transition couldn't make me male, and I'm now okay with my body — I stopped seeing myself as 'a deformed male' and started seeing myself as 'a perfectly good female.' I wish I'd had butch/GNC role models and discovered feminism sooner, but I think I had to go through transition to get where I am. I'm gender-critical and sceptical of transition, but I don't feel safe saying so publicly — it would be 'career & social suicide.' For Detrans Awareness Day 2021 I wanted to post a selfie or say something on my work Slack to normalise detransition, but couldn't bring myself to do it for fear of being labelled transphobic; instead I resolved to be more open in small groups and one-to-one conversations. I advise people with dysphoria that anyone has the potential to reconcile with their own sex, and I would never tell someone 'transition is the only option' for them.