Alle Geschichten

Fünf Jahre Östrogen, um einer fundamentalistischen Kindheit zu entkommen

Männlich · DetransitioniertTransition 38 → Detransition 422376
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin ein detransitionierter Mann, der fast fünf Jahre lang (mit 38 bis 42) mit Spiro und Östrogen als Transfrau lebte und 2022 die Injektionen schrittweise absetzte. Missbrauch in der Kindheit in einem fundamentalistischen Homeschooling-Elternhaus, internalisierte Männerfeindlichkeit und ein Selbstwertgefühl nahe null trieben mich zur Transition, vor allem weil ich geliebt werden wollte; fünf Jahre Therapie, Meditation, Psychedelika, spirituelle Arbeit und Kontaktabbruch zu meinen Eltern ließen mich stattdessen das zugrunde liegende Trauma heilen. Ich hatte nie eine Operation (ein geplanter Eingriff wurde durch die Pandemie abgesagt), und meine bleibenden Veränderungen sind Brustwachstum und soziale Verluste; Testosteron und Erektionsfähigkeit sind zurückgekehrt. Ich habe mich als detrans geoutet, mich aus meinem alten progressiven Freundeskreis zurückgezogen, bin zu meinem Geburtsnamen zurückgekehrt, habe einen neuen Job angefangen und konvertiere jetzt zum Katholizismus, bin pornofrei und fühle mich weitgehend im Frieden. Ich unterstütze die Ehrlichkeit anderer, kritisiere aber die Trans-Ideologie und rate zu innerer Arbeit statt Medikalisierung.

Vollständige Geschichte

I was born male and grew up in a high-control fundamentalist Christian homeschooling environment on the right. My parents were controlling and violent; they crushed my will and isolated me 'to protect me,' and I learned early that having unauthorized emotions was unsafe. I internalized a core belief that I was a broken failure, disappointment, and abomination — an identity I say my parents gave me. I also experienced what I later described as 'lots of forced submission as a kid,' which 'they called love.' I wanted to be lovable, to be soft and unmasculinized and unthreatening and accepted and loved and protected. A decade before my detransition I had a breakdown, moved back in with my parents, and was morbidly depressed, unemployed, and a hermit. I was briefly married to a woman — the sexual part was the only high-functioning part of the relationship — and I am divorced. I identified as bi/pansexual and then just queer; I was primarily attracted to women, though I also hooked up with men partly to get attention and affection without vulnerability or commitment. I never felt comfortable in gay male spaces. In my 30s (age 38) I began identifying as a trans woman. I think mostly I wanted to be loved. Contributing factors I've named include: internalized misandry and resentment toward men ('I didn't want to be any of the things I understood being a man meant'); the cultural narrative that straight white men are the root of oppression; wanting traits like sensitivity and kindness that I'd been taught were incompatible with being a man; a desire to turn back time and be soft again; wanting an identity that meant my existence was valuable and valid after a lifetime of feeling like I didn't matter; and wanting to dis-identify with the power and control I was raised to believe being a man was. My self-esteem was near-zero when I began considering I might be a woman. I now believe childhood abuse left me believing wrong things about myself at a core relational and self-image level. I changed my name (court-ordered) and my state ID and Social Security gender marker, but never my birth certificate. I did laser hair removal on my thick beard — my first step, between starting therapy and hormones. I was on spiro and estrogen for almost five years (age 38–42; sublingual, then intramuscular injections, then subcutaneous), stopping about three months shy of a five-year anniversary (4.75 years). I had a surgery scheduled in 2020 after three years of hormones; it was canceled due to the pandemic and I kept putting off rescheduling it. I never had any surgeries. I'm very glad I didn't. On hormones I lost aerobic fitness almost immediately, gained sixty pounds, and my cholesterol went from perfect to kind of bad. Involuntary erections and libido stopped, which was initially a huge relief because I resented and feared my sexuality. I trained my voice toward feminization from YouTube videos, practicing in my car. I completed a chaplaincy internship identifying as a trans woman at a 'very woke hospital.' My therapist simply affirmed me as trans because I had gender dysphoric thoughts, and told me my doubts — my 'internalized transphobia' — would go away; she later told me my identity issues were separate from my trauma issues, which I now believe was 'an ideological answer' and 'completely and totally wrong.' Conservative Christians told me I was delusional; affirmation-only social justice people praised my bravery. Neither helped me examine my gender beliefs. I came to see trans ideology as a belief system and deconstruct it. What moved me toward detransition: five years of therapy (EMDR, internal family systems, mindfulness, body awareness, CPTSD and self-soothing work), about three years of fairly intense meditation, roughly one year of psychedelics (shrooms and DMT), no contact with my family of origin for about two to three years, deep study of Hinduism, Taoism, Buddhism, and Christianity, and Benjamin Boyce's Evergreen videos. I also prayed for Jesus to heal me from my intense fear and had mystical-type experiences. I had been taking my weekly shot less and less consistently — one week late, then two, then three, then four, then five — and decided to see if I could tolerate testosterone coming back. I could. Chest hair came back without distress, erections returned, and 'she/her' stopped feeling right. I described it as waking up. I came out as detrans on Facebook, then largely disengaged — I took a leave of absence from my master's program, stopped going to my social justice church, deactivated Facebook, and withdrew from my old social circle. I started a new job after detransitioning, which has been great. I went back to my birth name. I live alone in Columbus, Ohio, with my cat, and I don't know any other detrans people locally, though I'd like to. I've been in a two-year master's program (chaplaincy-related), stayed sober from alcohol, and overcome several addictions. I was 42 days free from porn at one point, later 3+ months clean after most of my life in use/addiction. Physical recovery: three months after stopping, testosterone was around 300 (low end of normal male range); I've read full recovery can take six months or more. Testosterone and erectile function have come back and I'm praying fertility will too. Permanent changes: breast growth and social turmoil. My beard grows in patchy and stubbly — not enough to wear as facial hair, but smooth when shaved. I'm a little embarrassed when I think about how I look, but I don't read as feminine going about the world. Mental health: I've had intrusive thoughts for long periods, emotional flashbacks (I work with IFS to relate to them as 'parts'), and a past of morbid depression. I've also described CPTSD. I feel much more grounded in reality than ever, more whole than ever, and much of the distress has lifted. Sexuality now: I'm 43 and would say I'm attracted to women, not girls. I finally feel like being a man 'works' for me — I don't feel inferior, jealous, or insecure. I'm not dating and am not indulging in pornography, sexual fantasies, or masturbation, but I still have work to do on myself first and conceivably could get remarried. I'm in the process of becoming Catholic. I've found identity and refuge in Jesus. I feel complete relief from my gender identity crisis. I came out as detrans because I felt I owed people that much, but I've stayed withdrawn. I admire people speaking up but don't feel ready for the abuse. I've said 'Detransitioning is the successful outcome of my transition.' I advise others to do inner work rather than outer work, and I don't recommend adopting postmodern gender identities even without medicalizing. I'm still working on social maturity and being a good man rather than just a comfortable hermit.