Alle Geschichten

Eine Psychiatriepflegerin auf r/detrans und was sie nicht ausspricht

Weiblich · Detransitioniert422
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin Psychiatriepflegerin und wurde auf r/detrans aktiv, wo ich detransitionierende und geschlechtlich verwirrte Menschen beständig unterstütze und offen sage, dass mein Beruf in diesem Bereich keine wirkliche Ausbildung hat. Ich sehe die Transgender-Bewegung eher als Ideologie denn als medizinisches Thema und glaube, dass das Feld der psychischen Gesundheit Patienten im Stich gelassen hat, indem es keine harten Fragen stellt. Ich habe langjährige persönliche Erfahrung mit Testosteron angedeutet und gesagt, ich nähme es „mein ganzes Leben lang“, aber einen vollständigen Zeitverlauf von Transition oder Detransition habe ich nicht dargelegt. Ich ermutige zu Therapie, Geduld und dazu, die Scham rund um Sexualität aufzulösen, und rate Menschen, fünf Jahre zu warten, bevor sie eine Transition erwägen. Anfang 2023 bin ich der Community weiterhin unterstützend und engagiert verbunden.

Vollständige Geschichte

I have been a practicing psychiatric nurse for a living — I use the handle crazypsychnurse online, and I really am a psych nurse. I came to the r/detrans community not primarily to tell my own story but because I kept running into people who were confused about their gender and had nobody to talk to, and I found that I could relate to their confusion in a way I couldn't fully explain. I told one person directly: 'I really try to emphasize with people who are confused about their gender but it's really hard when you can't relate to your own experiences. I can definitely relate to your experiences, confused and no one to talk to especially.' Over late 2022 into early 2023 I posted steadily, mostly thanking people for sharing and offering practical encouragement. I told people things like 'Let the past stay in the past, don't dwell there. You get to make your future by the choices you make now, just do the next right thing,' and 'Yes you can go back to being you ... its going to be a bit awkward but you can.' I tried to normalize the fear of going back: 'Your life won't be ruined. Your friends and family will forgive and you will be able to move on. There may be some talk behind your back and maybe to your face but you can deal with that.' I also pushed back on the idea that being a tomboy or gender-nonconforming as a child is a problem: 'A lot of girls participate in boys activities ... we used to call them tomboys and considered it normal. People will mostly forget and you can move on.' Professionally I have become quite critical of how the mental health and medical fields have handled gender questions. I wrote: 'The transgender movement feels to me more like an ideology than a psychiatric/medical issue.' I argued that when social workers or medical professionals do ask appropriate questions openly, they are called transphobes and can face serious consequences, and that 'the SW/medical community as a whole has let our patients down by not being willing to ask those tough questions.' I acknowledged it is hard, maybe even impossible in some situations, to push back. I shared that a friend and colleague has a young daughter who recently announced she is FTM and that the father is struggling with how to be a loving father without supporting her transition, while the mother openly supports and encourages it. When someone described a clinician's failure I said flatly, 'He should loose his license, at the least.' I have been direct with people in crisis. When one poster described OCD, a transgender obsession, and said they needed to check into a mental health facility or kill themselves, I asked whether the OCD was diagnosed and whether it shows up in other areas, told them they sounded like they had gender confusion, and urged: 'Talk to someone who will help you resolve this confusion ... if you are suicidal get help, death is final.' I followed up with 'No! You are confused ... from what you said maybe it's related to your OCD.' I have also been open about the limits of my own training. I asked a poster, 'What should/could I do as a mental health nurse to help you through the darkness?' and admitted: 'This isn't a subject that we have learned about because it's a new thing. What little I know I gathered from a few patients and the internet. We are in the same position as you ... fumbling in the dark ... and those who claim otherwise are just making it up as they go.' I encouraged others to build the resources that don't exist yet, telling one person they were 'articulate and have the experience, knowledge and education to begin developing those resources' and that they had 'a unique opportunity to provide what you sought for others.' On personal questions I have been somewhat guarded but there are hints. In January 2023, responding to a discussion about testosterone, I wrote that I was 'still struggling with the idea of t being addicting probably because I've been "taking" it all my life,' which suggests long-term personal experience with testosterone. I have also counseled people on shame around sexuality and identity, asking one whether being gay felt shameful while being trans did not, and whether 'the only path without shame' was to be heterosexual, telling them that shame has to be resolved and that 'the easy way out is an illusion.' I have recommended therapy — ideally one therapist covering all linked issues — and being honest with that therapist rather than only anonymous Reddit posts. My overall advice to people considering transition has been cautious: 'You shouldn't. Wait 5 years, if you feel you need to transition then do so. Meantime explore who you are.'