Alle Geschichten

Ein Jahrzehnt als trans identifiziert – und die Entscheidung, nicht zu transitionieren

Weiblich · Desistiert613
Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.

Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.

Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.

Zusammenfassung

Ich bin eine detransitionierte (nie medizinisch transitionierte) butch-lesbische Frau, die sich fast ein Jahrzehnt lang als trans identifizierte, nachdem ich die trans Identität mit 13/14 um 2008/2009 entdeckt hatte, mich aber letztlich gegen die Transition entschied. Heute identifiziere ich mich als maskuline, geschlechtsnonkonforme Frau, die mit den Pronomen sie/ihr zufrieden ist und nach Jahren der Therapie dankbar dafür ist, nicht transitioniert zu haben. Meine Dysphorie führe ich darauf zurück, dass ich ein maskulines, schwules Kind war und Körperbildprobleme hatte, die ich in einen trans Rahmen gelenkt habe, und ich sehe die Geschlechtsdysphorie in der Kindheit heute als eine häufige Phase bei schwulen Kindern. Ich habe keine Operationen, Hormone oder aktuellen Suizidgedanken beschrieben, wobei ich Suizidgedanken hatte, als ich glaubte, trans zu sein. Ich stehe Menschen, die wirklich dysphorisch sind, im Großen und Ganzen wohlwollend gegenüber, sehe aber kritisch, wie die Transition vorangetrieben wird, und unterstütze aktiv andere, die die Transition hinterfragen.

Vollständige Geschichte

I have been gender nonconforming for as long as I can remember. As a kid I told other children I was a boy, I cried when my parents put me in Catholic school where the uniform was a dress, and I used to dream I had a penis and wake up crying when it wasn't true. I was always very masculine in my hobbies and fashion, I never fit in, and I got along better with boys growing up. I was also miserable and hated myself for most of my life. When I was 13 or 14, around 2008/2009, I discovered what being trans was, and I put everything into it. I started hating new things about myself and wanted to kill myself over it for years, because nothing else was making me less miserable, so it must be that I was trans — it made sense, I was always masculine, right? I thought I was trans for nearly a decade. At the time, the goal was to pass and live a stealth life. Being gay was not the only reason I transitioned, but it made it easier to justify to everyone around me. As I got older, the dysphoria lessened. I was a more masculine girl and still miserable and hated my body, but it stopped being about being female — it was more about how females are treated and what was expected of me, especially since I never fit in. I also have a naturally high testosterone level; I'm a lesbian and I have much more of a beard than most cis women, and I'm pretty masculine in general. I don't think the testosterone itself was the issue, but the hardships that come with being a masculine female caused me to want to transition. I also think I had other body image issues and placed them into the trans basket to legitimize them and not be a "hysterical insecure girl." Eventually I lost weight, grew older, and realized I hated myself either way. Transition is hard, and if you already know it's not going to make you happy, it's not for you. I did not transition. What helped me most was remembering that pronouns never became a big deal to me until they became a big deal to everybody else — for as much as I thought I was a man for nearly a decade, the specific focus on pronouns is a very recent thing. I also found it helpful to reject the idea of "feeling" like a woman: I don't feel like a woman, I just am one. I simply do and dress how I like and I'm female, that's it. My framework became: I'm female, therefore I'm a woman; anything else is unnecessary for me. I also reinterpreted my childhood sex dysphoria as a pretty natural phase a lot of gay kids experience — myself included — and it saddens me that it's become "evidence" of the "innateness" of transgenderism now. I never thought about it until I became convinced I was trans, then I just used it as evidence to further my belief. It took years of hard work and therapy to get to where I am now. I am comfortable being a butch lesbian now, at a place of acceptance I never thought I could achieve. I am incredibly masculine in looks, mannerisms, and hobbies, I'm gay, but I go by she/her because that's simply what I am. I only wear pullover/sports bras because they're easier and get the job done, and I always wear men's swim trunks with a long sleeve rashguard rather than a bikini top. It's been over a decade without therapy now and I'm so grateful I didn't transition. I don't have any recorded surgeries, hormone use, or medical complications in what I've shared. I have not described any current suicidal ideation; the suicidal thoughts I mention were during the period when I believed I was trans. On transition for others, I'm supportive of people who are genuinely dysphoric but cautious: "Trans is something you do, not something you are. Dysphoric is what you are. If you don't want all the side effects HRT brings, I would say don't do it." I've told people there is nothing wrong with being gender nonconforming and gay — "We are good the way we are." I've also commented critically on trans spaces, saying lots of trans people and spaces are fueled by male entitlement, "rebranded as a fight against 'transmisogyny'," and that anybody threatened by the existence of detransitioners is probably on their way to becoming one. I've been active in online detransition and gender-critical discussion, offering support and advice to dysphoric and questioning people.