Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin ein detransitionierter/desistierter Mann, der eine schwere Identitätskrise durchlebte, über zehn Jahre dreimal fälschlich als bipolar diagnostiziert wurde, dreimal einen Suizidversuch unternahm und schließlich korrekt mit einer Borderline-Persönlichkeitsstörung diagnostiziert wurde. Eine Notizbuchübung aus der Persönlichkeitspsychologie – seitenweise Fakten über mich ohne Erwähnung von Geschlecht aufzuschreiben – gab mir ein stabiles Selbstgefühl und steht im Zentrum dessen, wie ich heute andere berate. Ich bin scharf kritisch gegenüber der Gender-Ideologie, „identifiziert als“-Rahmungen, der Transitionsmedizin-Industrie und durch soziale Medien getriebener Selbstdiagnose, und ich plädiere für unverblümte Ehrlichkeit statt Bestätigung für Menschen, die eine Transition erwägen. Ich habe ein DBT-Programm abgeschlossen, nachdem ich es dreimal abgebrochen hatte, und glaube fest daran, die Arbeit zu machen, statt auf Veränderung zu warten. Ich lebe derzeit als Mann und bin in der Detrans-Community eine direkte, kritische Stimme, auch wenn ich die Geschichte von drei Suizidversuchen und einer BPS-Diagnose mit mir trage.
Vollständige Geschichte
I am a man — that is how I have lived and identified for years now, and I want to be clear about that up front, because it shapes how I read and respond to people in this community. I came to this subreddit through my own identity crisis, and I have done a lot of thinking about how I got there and what I wish someone had told me.
I was misdiagnosed three times as bipolar. It took ten years from the first diagnosis, and three suicide attempts, before I was actually diagnosed correctly with Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). That long stretch of wrong diagnoses and wrong treatments is one of the reasons I am skeptical of diagnoses handed out in 2022 — I tell people here that a diagnosis has to be taken with a grain of salt, because most of us on this sub were misdiagnosed and misled into thinking we had something we didn't. I also went through a DBT (Dialectical Behavioral Therapy) program, which I quit three times before I finally went back and took it seriously. That experience taught me that waiting for things to change or waiting for a miracle just makes things worse — you have to actually do something.
During my identity crisis I did an exercise recommended by a personality psychologist that changed my life. I got out a notebook and a pen and actually sat down and figured out who I was, writing facts and only facts: on the left side of the page everything I liked in life, on the right everything I hated, then on the next page everything I wanted, then the people who loved me, then the people who were just acquaintances. I wrote and wrote until I had four pages of words. When I looked at it, I realized that was who I was — nothing on those pages had to do with gender, and neither the word masculine nor feminine appeared anywhere. Having something concrete like that let me swat away ideas I used to think made me 'me', because they weren't on the list, so I knew they weren't real. I recommend that exercise to others here who are struggling with identity.
I also tell people bluntly that I myself was a villain while I was in my identity crisis, which is why I don't judge others who behave badly in theirs. I wish someone had been blunt with me before I made the mistakes I made. Instead, people tried to tiptoe around me, validate the stupid things I did, and make me comfortable with the dumb ideas I had. They thought they were helping me and I thought they were supportive, but it was all wrong. Someone should have told me the truth and forced it down my throat. That is what I am trying to do for others here — do for them what I wish someone had done for me.
I have a sister who competes in women's bodybuilding, and a brother. Two weeks before one of my comments, my sister asked my brother and me to carry furniture into her new place — she got the boxes and we got the things that weighed hundreds of pounds. I mention this when I argue with people about physical capability and the expectations placed on men.
I am quite critical of the ideology I believe led many of us here. I think terms like gender dysphoria, internalized misogyny, and patriarchy are, in my words, 'all bullshit designed to help us cope with our suffering and give us an answer as to why we are so unhappy' — it's easier to blame an invisible force than to look within and start fixing the things within ourselves that need to be fixed. I see identity politics, misogyny/patriarchy thinking, and transitioning children as all under the umbrella of a disturbing belief system, and I say that adherence to a certain ideology is what got us here in the first place. I am also deeply skeptical of the medical and research establishment around transition: I point to a 2010 study showing that people who transition have higher suicide rates, attempts, and hospitalizations than their counterparts, and I find it suspicious that in ten short years all the studies say the opposite and cite ludicrously low detransition rates. I have shared a Project Veritas video arguing that trans medicine is a $200 billion industry where top surgery alone brings in $40,000 each, and I called it 'disgusting and manipulative.'
I take a hard line on the concept of 'identifying as' something. I argue that identifying as or with something is not based on reality, is not tangible, and is not real — one can identify as anything, a shoebox or a toaster, and nothing tethers the identifying to reality, so the individual is quite literally roleplaying, which is a childish practice that should stop early in life. I contrast 'I am Jessica, and I identify with masculinity' (wrong) with 'I am Jessica, and I like sports, playing video games and hate makeup' (right). I think identities built on malleable concepts become brittle, and that broken identity is a staple in terrible mental disorders like Borderline Personality Disorder and Gender Dysphoria.
I am blunt with people considering transition about what to expect: it will feel wonderful at first; anytime you don't pass will feel terrible; friends and family will walk on eggshells; many people will judge your character before you speak; your dating life will become much harder or non-existent; changes from surgery or hormones are often irreversible and the regret if you change your mind cannot be captured with words; you will always need to put on an act in public; most people will never truly see you as the gender you're transitioning to; and your friend groups will likely need to be composed of 'woke' people who will turn on you if you don't play the part. I also tell people going the other direction that testosterone will not give you a male body, and I describe at length the expectations on men — being willing to fight physically, giving and taking harsh playful insults, participating in physical tasks, initiating conversations, doing things alone, and not talking about feelings openly.
I argue that transition is fundamentally about how other people perceive you: 'ALL TO CHANGE HOW PEOPLE PERCEIVE YOU' — you change how you dress, talk, and carry yourself, get surgery, sacrifice fertility, go into debt, throw away friends, all so that other people know. I have been sharply critical of people I see as self-diagnosing multiple disorders and seeking sympathy rather than help, telling one person 'Stop sitting around feeling sorry for yourself and take control of your life.'
I try to be fair to people across the political spectrum. I push back when people here assume the worst about someone with opposing political views, arguing that someone on the opposite side can be capable of empathy and may feel bad that so many young people are suffering. I say that 'hate think' and negative thinking is what got many people on this subreddit into this position in the first place — everyone listened to one side and vilified the other, and the one side convinced them to do terrible things to themselves. I acknowledge that my own opinions were worse than any I've heard from the 'Right' I used to hate so much, and I don't want to be dehumanized because I was wrong.
As for where I am now: I live as a man, I have a stable sense of self built from that notebook exercise, and I am engaged in this community partly as a form of advocacy — I want to be the blunt voice I never had. I do not describe myself as currently in crisis, though I carry the history of three suicide attempts and a BPD diagnosis. I am critical of transition for young people and for most people who come here, but I frame my stance as being realistic rather than hateful, and I try to meet people where they are even when I am harsh.