Diese Geschichten wurden mit KI zusammengefasst.
Auf Reddit teilen Menschen oft ihre Erfahrungen über mehrere Kommentare oder Posts hinweg. Um diese Informationen zugänglicher zu machen, sammelt detrans.ai alle diese verstreuten Stücke in eine einzige, leicht lesbare Zusammenfassung und Zeitlinie. Alle System-Prompts sind auf der Prompts-Seite vermerkt.
Manchmal kann KI halluzinieren oder Dinge behaupten, die nicht wahr sind. Aber im Allgemeinen sind die zusammengefassten Geschichten genaue Reflexionen der ursprünglichen Kommentare der Nutzer.
Zusammenfassung
Ich bin eine detransitionierte Frau, die sich ab 17 (2014) als nichtbinär identifizierte, nachdem ich auf Tumblr in trans Räume geraten war, ein Jahr lang (2021–2022) in Australien mit fast keiner Abklärung Testosteron nahm und Anfang 2024 mit 27 detransitionierte. Ich bereue die HRT, bin aber größtenteils im Reinen damit und gehe mit verbliebenen PCOS-bedingten maskulinen Merkmalen per Laser-Haarentfernung um. Ich lebe jetzt vollständig als Frau und fühle mich überwiegend abgeschlossen damit, halte meine Vergangenheit aber geheim und bin immer noch befangen, wenn ich männlich aussehe oder klinge, und weil ich ein Jahrzehnt normaler Entwicklung verloren habe. Ich kritisiere die schnelle Hormonvergabe, medizinische Transition bei Minderjährigen und das „Egg“-Narrativ, unterstütze aber weiterhin die Selbstentfaltung erwachsener trans Menschen.
Vollständige Geschichte
I was a pretty standard young girl and teenager — I had some body image issues but nothing I would have called gender dysphoria. I was a bit of a tomboy as a child: I liked video games and woodwork, wasn't interested in girly things, and I remember being maybe 4 or 5 and playing pretend as a dragon but insisting I was a GIRL dragon. I was very firmly a girl, had no other trans tendencies, and had no issues with puberty in a gendered way.
As a teenager I was heavily into Tumblr and got involved in trans spaces, and I had a number of trans friends. Around 2014, at 17, I started thinking "well, I guess I don't *feel* like a woman?" and began identifying as nonbinary. I kept that identity until early 2024. In hindsight I often wonder what my life would have been like if I never got into those spaces as a teenager — I don't think I would have been trans.
I went on testosterone in 2021, at about 24, after being on a waitlist for that appointment for roughly a year. I'm in Australia. My intake was a brief appointment with a nurse, then I saw the prescribing doctor the same day, and after a blood test I had the prescription. I had expressed clearly that I didn't intend to be on T for more than a year or two, that I wasn't keen on fully transitioning and just wanted some changes and then to stop. I don't think I said anything that implied I was unhappy with my body or showed the usual indicators of dysphoria — I might even have said I don't experience dysphoria, though it was a while ago and I can't be certain. Neither the nurse nor the doctor paused to suggest I talk to someone first. At the time I was just like "yeah nice", but looking back I think it's crazy that no one thought to slow things down.
Because I have pre-existing PCOS I already had a lot of androgenic features before T, including a not-insignificant amount of facial hair, and Italian heritage on top of that, so T really amped those aspects up. I passed almost exclusively as male after starting. I only stayed on T for one year (2021–2022), because I never had a desire to fully transition to male. My voice only dropped the slightest bit but was already a bit low. I continued identifying as nonbinary for a little over a year after stopping T.
I never really *disliked* how I looked when I was presenting as masc, but over time I began to realise it probably just wasn't right for me — after all, I'd never had any issue being a girl before, and I couldn't see why I was still keeping it all up. By then I was already pretty disillusioned with the trans narrative, and I had stopped outing myself as trans/nb well before detransitioning: I'd stopped sharing pronouns and stopped announcing that I was trans. I detransitioned in early 2024, at 27.
The detransition wasn't a big emotional decision and I wasn't sure at all. I'd been having doubts for a couple of years but pushed them down whenever the thoughts came up because they scared me, until I felt I couldn't ignore them anymore. I started conducting little experiments — small outings to the shops dressed as a girl to see how I felt, and two weeks of work placement during my university degree presenting as a woman the whole time, in places that were inconsequential and where I'd never see anyone again so there was no pressure. I still wasn't getting a clear answer — I couldn't tell whether any discomfort was about not feeling attractive, nervousness about passing as a woman, or actual dysphoria — so I decided to try presenting as a woman full time, knowing I always had the option to go back. From there I just continued as I was. It was still difficult for a long time: I was unsure whether it was what I wanted, insecure about my appearance and voice, and scared of what it all meant. But over time a lot of that faded. I was still "me" and didn't change as a person at all.
It's now been close to two years since I detransitioned and it's still a strange position to be in. Because of the PCOS I still struggle with masculine features — broad shoulders, narrow hips, more body hair than most women — though it's also a bit of a blessing because I can blame things like hair on that. I get laser on my face and the hair there is mostly gone, and most of the other T changes were negligible enough. I do regret going on HRT; I was having second thoughts when it was prescribed, but I said at the time I was prepared to face the consequences and I am at peace with that decision.
The hardest part is the 10-year gap — almost my entire adult life — that I feel I have to keep secret from new people I meet. It's a past I'm not proud of and it's explaining I don't want to have to do, but innocent questions make it hard to navigate: "you used to dye your hair? can I see pictures?" or "where did your nickname come from?". I'm ultimately happier presenting as a woman than as a "boy", but I'm self-conscious all the time, worried I look like a man or sound like one. I feel like I don't understand how to be a woman, I feel alien, and dating as a straight woman feels foreign. I think I have a pretty face but I don't feel beautiful, and I don't feel like a man would want someone like me. I feel like I skipped a decade of development and now have to live as an approaching-30-year-old with the mentality of a teenager. I've been a bit jealous of the 18–22 year olds on the sub who still have most of their 20s to live out more normally.
I've mostly moved on with my life, but it's always there in the background — something I have to contend with and that most people wouldn't understand. I don't think about gender much anymore; I present the way that makes me happy and I'm actually quite feminine now, though there are no rules against being GNC. Nothing in my life is really defined by my gender.
On related issues: I have no problem with trans people identifying however they want — I'll use names and pronouns (except neopronouns) and I'm happy to interact on a superficial level — but I'm not interested in getting close to any of them again because 99% make it their entire personality and are annoying about it, an opinion I formed well before I started considering detransitioning. I take issue with the "groom-y" nature of insisting anyone who questions their identity must be trans, the whole "egg" thing, because it pushes people in rather than giving them space to explore, and distracts them from other possible reasons they feel different — social class, disability, weight, and so on — that they mistake for dysphoria. I'm very much opposed to minors medically transitioning, and even 18–25 people are still figuring themselves out; it's easy to get sucked into a community for belonging and then to prioritise fitting in over the consequences of hard-to-reverse bodily changes. I also think detransitioning is a trans issue and that dismissing it as "only a tiny percentage" is a way of refusing to acknowledge it happens and shutting down genuine discussion. I've been critical of how quickly hormones were prescribed to me and of the pressure to steamroll through everything.
In giving advice to others I've said it doesn't have to be a "mistake" — it can just be time spent experimenting and exploring identity — and I've recommended getting away from social media and focusing on the real world, because a lot of the gender noise fades when you're just living your life. I think of people like us as "late bloomers".