Αυτές οι ιστορίες έχουν συνοψιστεί χρησιμοποιώντας AI.
Στο Reddit, οι άνθρωποι συχνά μοιράζονται τις εμπειρίες τους σε πολλαπλά σχόλια ή αναρτήσεις. Για να καταστήσουμε αυτές τις πληροφορίες πιο προσβάσιμες, το detrans.ai συγκεντρώνει όλα αυτά τα διάσπαρτα κομμάτια σε μια ενιαία, ευανάγνωστη περίληψη και χρονοδιάγραμμα. Όλα τα system prompts σημειώνονται στη σελίδα prompts.
Μερικές φορές η AI μπορεί να παρουσιάζει ψευδαισθήσεις ή να αναφέρει πράγματα που δεν είναι αληθή. Αλλά γενικά, οι συνοπτικές ιστορίες είναι ακριβείς αντανακλάσεις των αρχικών σχολίων των χρηστών.
Περίληψη
Είμαι μια γυναίκα που ακύρωσε τη μετάβαση, η οποία ταυτιζόταν ως trans άνδρας για χρόνια αλλά ποτέ δεν μετέβη ιατρικά, αν και έφτασα κοντά. Η δυσφορία μου πήγαζε από εσωτερικευμένη μισογυνία, ένα σύμπλεγμα «δεν είμαι σαν τα άλλα κορίτσια», δυσφορία φύλου, αυτοανδροφιλία που ενισχύθηκε από πρώιμη έκθεση σε πορνογραφία, παιδικό τραύμα από μια ελεγκτική μητέρα και σεξουαλική επίθεση. Ακύρωσα τη μετάβαση μέσω της δικής μου έρευνας στον ριζοσπαστικό φεμινισμό και μιας διαδικασίας αποκλεισμού που έδειξε ότι κάθε σύμπτωμα δυσφορίας είχε πιο πιθανή αιτία από το να είναι trans. Είμαι στειρωμένη (αφαίρεση σαλπίγγων και εκτομή ενδομητρίου NovaSure το 2023) και εξακολουθώ να εμφανίζομαι πολύ αρρενωπά, με αποκαλούν συχνά «κύριε», αλλά δεν επιθυμώ πλέον να με βλέπουν ως άνδρα. Ακόμα παλεύω με την AAP και υπολειμματική δυσφορία φύλου, αλλά βρίσκομαι σε πολύ καλύτερη κατάσταση, και μιλώ ανοιχτά για την κριτική μου στη gender ιδεολογία στο διαδίκτυο παρά τις αντιδράσεις και τους αποκλεισμούς.
Πλήρης ιστορία
I was born female and grew up in a household dominated by my mother, a self-proclaimed helicopter parent with whom I have a lot of emotional enmeshment. I didn't really have a father figure until I was about 14, and I was never interested in calling him my dad. My mom always took great pride in me being her 'mini me' and has lashed out at me at every stage of my development when I needed independence and agency. She'd always say she'd accept me no matter what I looked like, but her behavior never matched — she damn near had a breakdown and called me at work to berate me when I got my septum pierced at 23. Anytime I express discomfort that requires her to change her behavior, she responds with extreme defensiveness to the point where I end up consoling her and my needs remain unmet.
From a young age I rejected anything girly or feminine because femininity was associated with weakness and inferiority. I was told if I kept 'failing' at being a girl maybe I wasn't a girl at all. I had deep-seated internalized misogyny and a 'not like other girls' complex. Combine that with a lot of sex dysphoria — wanting a dick, hating my period, having a naturally low voice for a girl, having tons of body hair — and it was really easy for me to believe I was 'truly' a boy. I also have clinically diagnosed ADHD and was on meds for it for a while. I have sensory issues that made performing femininity uncomfortable — I don't wear foundation, concealer, or contour, and I have trouble with a lot of women's clothing fabrics.
I identified as a trans man for years. I never medically transitioned, though I was very close. I had what I like to call 'Pinocchio syndrome' — I wanted to be a real boy. I had a gender therapist who, when I asked probing questions, would only affirm me and tell me I was valid in wanting to be a man; she played dumb and never tried to get to the root cause of my dysphoria. I had to get to the root of my dysphoria on my own after I desisted because she was so unhelpful. I bound my breasts (which bruised my ribs) and packed, and I was hyper-aware of how I walked so my hips wouldn't sway. I told trans friends to cut off their families if they didn't accept them. I had doubts the whole time but figured it was due to a lack of understanding on my part and went even harder trying to make sure I wasn't accidentally transphobic.
I also have autoandrophilia (AAP), which I've had pretty much my whole life, well before it mutated into part of my dysphoria. In my sexual fantasies I default to a male body, and I've felt that way since I was about 11. I'm bisexual with a strong preference for men. My AAP stems from frustration with my sexual 'role' as a woman — penetrative sex has always been painful for me even when enjoyable — a desire for more control during sex, internalized biphobia (I believed the 'correct' way to have sex with a woman was to be a man), and some wire crossing due to my attraction to men. I was sexually assaulted in high school by my then-boyfriend, which I realized not too long ago. I also found porn at 9 or 10 when friends bypassed the school computer filter, and I've watched it most of my life. The male POV focus and the ease with which men seemed to orgasm intensified my jealousy and my AAP.
I desisted a few years before 2022 (I was desisted by early 2022 and turned 30 that year). What moved me toward desisting was a process of elimination: every single dysphoria symptom had a more likely cause other than being trans — misogyny, childhood trauma, sexual trauma, porn, rigid gender roles, patriarchal social norms. I started reading radical feminist sites (I read 'terf' sites and realized they made a lot of sense; I was in radical feminist spaces and left Ovarit about two years before late 2022) and realized just how much of how we define womanhood hinges on flimsy patriarchal nonsense. I realized that being a woman isn't a performance or something I needed to 'learn' — it was something I already am. I realized femaleness is not an identity but a reality, like being short or black; I can't opt out of it. I also realized I was greedy — no amount of surgery or testosterone would give me a real dick and balls, so why fight a losing battle? Being trans was also just tiring.
I never got rid of my masculine clothes after desisting — I actually got even more masculine. I did get rid of my binders because they were uncomfortable and made my ribs sore; sports bras flatten me enough. I have a unisex name so I never changed it. I have a partially shaved fade haircut and wear men's pants because they're comfy, made well, and have roomy pockets. I get 'sir'ed and 'they'd often, ironically more often than when I was actually trying to pass. A woman called me 'sir' and a Disney World worker didn't know what to call me. I enjoy giving society the finger when people assume I'm trans or non-binary and I tell them no, I'm a woman — I don't 'identify' as a woman, I just am.
In terms of medical procedures, I got my fallopian tubes removed and an endometrial ablation (Novasure) in November 2023 because I can't stand the idea of getting pregnant, I hate having periods, and I'm not interested in being on birth control. I haven't bled since. I'm sterilized and childfree. My ability to get pregnant was one of many reasons I resented being female.
Mentally, I've unpacked a ton of internalized misogyny — it's still a work in progress but I'm in a much better place than I was four years before 2022. I found power in my femaleness by realizing being a girl isn't being weak; it's society's perception of women that's fucked. I realized my dislike of being female didn't make me special — talk to any woman and she'll bring up something she dislikes about being female. I still have some sex dysphoria (I hate my period and get sharp pains when I ovulate) but no longer have gender dysphoria because I no longer wish to be seen as male. I still have moments of resentment, but for the most part I've made peace. I still struggle with AAP — it's been an uphill battle and the most difficult part of desisting, though it's gotten a bit better; I can now at least fantasize without my brain defaulting to a male body, but only in specific scenarios. I also still struggle with internalized homophobia/biphobia at times.
I work in healthcare, in IT. My job had a mandatory presentation on gender identity for over 400 people telling everyone they have a gender identity, and I can't bring up what's wrong with it without risking my job. I've gotten a three-day site-wide ban from Reddit admins for describing the DARVO abuse pattern in trans activism. I've had comments removed for being 'hateful.' I've had trans people stalk my profile and reply to all my comments. I've been told I must still be trans because I'm GNC.
Currently I'm a desisted woman — I don't identify as a woman, I just am one. I'm a gender abolitionist and a radical feminist. I consider myself very left-leaning, and detransition made me more radically left-leaning because trans ideology is fundamentally conservative. I still present masculine and get misgendered regularly, which is irritating but I understand people are doing it because TRAs will pop off over someone using their eyeballs. My relationship with my mother remains complicated; she still feeds old hyper-feminine photos of me into ChatGPT and sends me the feminized renderings even after I've asked her to stop, which makes me dysphoric in a way I haven't felt in a long time.