These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Full story
I have spent a lot of time reading and arguing about autogynephilia (AGP) and autoandrophilia (AAP) on Reddit, and I want to lay out where I actually stand on this, because I think most people — both critics and defenders — get the theory wrong.
First, on my own situation: I am AGP. I've said so plainly when someone suggested I might be uncomfortable with the topic because of that. I'm also female — I've referred to myself as an AFAB person who at one point was trying to adopt a more feminine style and mannerisms, which I told someone to just explain to others directly. I have not, in anything I've posted, given ages, dates of coming out, dates of any medical steps, surgeries, or a detransition timeline. I've never described hormones, blockers, or surgical procedures of my own. So there isn't a medical chronology for me to give here beyond that.
What I do spend most of my energy on is correcting what I see as misconceptions about AGP. My position, stated repeatedly, is that AGP is real, backed by academic psychology, and considered a valid pathway to gender dysphoria. I've pushed back hard on the idea that AGP is 'strictly sexual' or that it's a fetish — a fetish, by definition, is a fixation on an inanimate object or a non-sexual body part, so AGP can't be one by definition. Blanchard introduced AGP as 'a male's propensity to be sexually aroused at the thought of being female,' but he did not say that trans women transition 'to get off' or 'as a fetish.' What he claimed was a connection between what these trans women reported and gender dysphoria in general terms. He didn't know the precise mechanism, and psychologists today don't have a clear answer either.
I've also argued that AGP is best conceptualized as a sexual orientation, not a paraphilia, quoting Blanchard directly: 'Autogynephilia might be better characterized as an orientation than as a paraphilia... for autogynephilic men, it includes the desire to achieve, with clothing, hormones, or surgery, an appearance like the preferred self-image of their erotic fantasies.' In psychology, a paraphilia just means an 'atypical sexual interest,' but in everyday language the term carries moral judgment, which is why it loses technical meaning. Most psychologists, I've said, view AGP as both a paraphilia and a sexual orientation.
I've cited specific prevalence figures: about 3% of AMABs have AGP, and about 60-80% of trans women in the west are AGP. I've recommended Anne Lawrence's work as a good resource, linked her 2011 paper on AGP being underappreciated, and also linked a paper on autoandrophilia and a conceptual overview at Queer Majority. I've explained AAP as the mirror phenomenon — an AFAB person attracted to the idea of being male — and noted it's hypothesized as a driving factor for some AFAB transitions, though less prevalent than AGP in males.
I've been quite combative with people who I think are mischaracterizing the theory. When someone claimed AGP is 'based in men who are misogynistic and see women as playthings,' I said AGP exists but that's not how psychologists view it. When someone compared AGP to a 'flavor' of serial killing, I pushed back with an analogy about racial profiling, arguing that grouping people this way based on an aversion is an emotional reaction, not a rational one. That comment got heavily downvoted (-19), and I kept arguing the point anyway. I've also defended against the claim that AGP is correlated with narcissism and comorbidities, saying Blanchard claims correlation with masochism and, I believe, to some extent autism, but not narcissism.
I've gotten into detailed arguments about pedophilia as well, taking the position that modern psychologists conceptualize it as an 'age-based orientation' and that the sexual interest itself isn't a direct cause of offending — lack of empathy, antisocial traits, and past trauma are the actual risk factors. I've said this is my understanding after reading psychology papers and articles related to gender and sexualities.
On the question of why some people have these attraction patterns, I've said nobody really knows — it's like asking why someone likes eating a particular food. I've noted there's a strong case for these interests being formed during prenatal development, and I've described the mechanism as the brain confusing being sexually attracted *to* something versus *being* that something — what the literature calls erotic target identity inversions. I've linked to a paper in the Journal of Sexual Medicine to support this.
I've also commented on Hirschfeld, noting that even he, interviewing thousands of crossdressers in the early 1900s, recognized that clothing itself wasn't the source and end point of arousal — there was a deeper reason, namely that these men are fundamentally aroused by the idea of adopting femininity. When someone asked whether Hirschfeld himself was a crossdresser, I said that was irrelevant to the point.
I've engaged with people asking whether having a sexual component means they can't be trans. My advice has been: only you know why you want to transition, and if in your mind the reason is something other than a sexual thrill, what's the problem? I've also said that having a fetish (by someone's own definition) doesn't prevent you from being trans.
I've cited Anne Vitale's three categories for gender dysphoric individuals (two for MtF, one for FtM, with a fourth small category for FtM) as already well-documented. I've also defended Blanchard's work generally, saying his papers hold up year after year with peer-reviewed papers building on them, and that it's those who don't work in the field who believe it's debunked.
I have not described my own mental health, trauma history, family situation, relationships, sexuality in terms of orientation, regret about any medical steps, or current quality of life. I have not described any advocacy beyond these online arguments. I have not mentioned suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. My posts are almost entirely theoretical/argumentative rather than personal narrative.