All stories

Passed as a trans man until a birthday stopped her

Female · Desisted199
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted female person who lived and passed as a trans man pre-T before a significant birthday made me reconsider. My dysphoria has returned to a dormant state, and I've found life as a butch woman easier than life as a trans man. I avoided surgery and hormones partly over document concerns and poor surgical options, and I've said my transition journey was traumatic and violent. I have struggled with suicidal ideation throughout my life, though I currently feel happier and more socially connected than before. I support freedom of choice about transition while being critical of absolutism in both directions.

Full story

I was born female. My body was naturally masculine from childhood — I remember wearing jeans and having 'the weird flappy bits at the sides where you're supposed to have hips and thighs' — and then at 16 I kept the straight up-and-down bone structure but grew very large breasts (GG-cup), which I experienced as 'flesh millstones' and hated from the start. I began medical transition because I finally understood it was okay to change my body if I felt I'd be better off in another one. I lived and passed as a trans man — pre-T, without voice changes — and I describe being male as 'an alienating, violent experience where all the rules were different and I was continuously on the bottom of the world,' vulnerable and powerless, feeling far less masculine while presenting male than ever before or since. I paused and then desisted. A significant birthday was the catalyst for me to reconsider. I stopped making an effort to present as the opposite gender, reconnected with old friends, and told no one. I had been putting off my life until after I transitioned, and since transition wasn't moving forward, neither was my life. I was in the 'middle space' — physical, social and emotional pain, unable to pursue a normal life as either a man or a woman. I had been isolated. Since desisting, my dysphoria has largely gone back to the dormant state it was in before I thought hard about it. I can socialise and make new friends without worrying about how my voice is perceived, rather than being quiet and withdrawn. I kept the wardrobe of the opposite gender — nobody has noticed and I look great. People still use the pronouns I offered them during transition, so much so I had to alert someone when they changed. I've noticed people feel much more at ease around me as a nonbinary or desisted person than as a binary trans person. I did not pursue top surgery, though I seriously considered it and researched post-mastectomy experiences extensively, including how women hide a flat chest and whether bras can be worn over scars. I pursued a radical breast reduction instead, but surgeons told me they could only bring me down to roughly a C-cup for blood-flow reasons. I currently use a Bravissimo minimiser bra that reduces my F-cup breasts to looking like a C and 'feels like a binder,' which let me stop binding. I have not had any surgeries. I have not mentioned hormones as having been started. Documents are one of the chief reasons I have not gone further with medical transition — I don't want to live in a halfway state or with the consequences of not-very-good surgery, and I describe my transition journey as 'traumatic and violent.' In my country it is difficult to get top surgery if you don't identify as male. My GP in the UK told me early on that testosterone would mean losing my uterus. On contributors: my anarchism is relevant to why I haven't shifted my views — to me it was fine to transition and then detransition, because we are free beings. I feel very masculine in my relationships with women; it's in relationships with men that I feel uncomfortably feminised. I've said career paths can be far harder if you're female. I'm sceptical of online absolutism in both directions and warned against being flooded with absolutist responses. On adversity: I was assaulted and lingered with it for about a year; when I approached the police it was beyond the statute of limitations. I concluded the pain was located inside me and reaching outside myself to calm it only created ripples that came back on me; I found the ability to reach inside myself and calm myself, and I've recommended DBT. I have struggled with suicidal ideation my whole life; these days the more people are in my life and the busier I am, the better I feel, to the point of a happiness and self-respect that was unimaginable before, though I'm sure I'll feel suicidal again as it's a mental habit. On reproduction: I was very skeeved out by childbirth, huge breasts, lactation, and pregnancy, but when I met my partner and we built a home together I wanted to have his child. I have decided to adopt and find that acceptable. I now describe myself as desisted, and I've said people should be free to live as they feel they are, that detransition isn't right for everyone, and that transition can be one response to a life crisis.