All stories

Contralto to baritone, and no one warned her

Female · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 11 → Transition 16196
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I'm a detransitioned female who identified as a trans man from 2017, was on testosterone on and off for about 3 years, and by 2022 stopped HRT while choosing to stay socially FtM because I don't care much either way anymore. I don't pass, my dysphoria and anxiety were severe, and I've had suicidal thoughts in the past that improved once my anxiety was treated. I have permanent changes including a deepened voice (contralto to baritone) but believe my fertility has returned with regular cycles. I regret how much of my life transition has complicated and I'm critical of how doctors and the trans community downplay irreversible effects. I currently live as a detransitioned woman socially in some respects while still using a masculine social role out of convenience.

Full story

I am from Brazil and was born female. My earliest memories, around age 4, are of me deliberately lying about my preferences — saying my favorite color was pink because girls were supposed to like pink — and avoiding anything "boyish" because I thought I had to perform femininity. As soon as I learned to read at 5, I read girls' magazines and followed them religiously. It took me years to realize not all girls were faking it that hard. When I figured out at 11 that people weren't constantly performing a personality, I had a huge identity crisis and no idea who I was. Puberty hit hard a couple months later and my first gender dysphoria symptoms began, mostly body-focused — having breasts upset me even when they were small and nobody noticed. I kept up the hyperfeminine act until I couldn't anymore. When I started presenting more masculine and got gendered male for the first time at 16, everything clicked and my dysphoria increased "a million times." I've wondered if I'm a case of ROGD. I was into radical feminism for a few months before I started identifying as a trans man in 2017. I never wanted to be trans — it always felt like a red flag that I hesitated so much — but my dysphoria felt unbearable. I went to therapy for about 2 years (roughly ages 17–19) before starting medical transition, seeing two therapists because I moved cities. My second therapist specialized in transgender patients; she thought transition would help but didn't rush me and explicitly told me I didn't have to take hormones if I wasn't ready. She also referred me to a psychiatrist, who prescribed medication for my general anxiety disorder. That relieved my suicidal thoughts and what I'd thought was gender-related social anxiety but actually wasn't fully that. I started testosterone around 2019. My T history has been on and off: about a year straight, then 6 months off, then another year and a half, then off again — roughly 3 years total with about 6 months off in that span. During the pandemic I went off T for 9 months and it was the worst period for my dysphoria: my smell reverted to a female scent and my hairline started lowering again. I hate taking any medicine generally — I've never taken a painkiller for a headache and once quit anxiety meds cold turkey against psychiatric advice (they were causing digestive issues; my panic attacks did go away permanently). The thought of being on hormones for life terrifies me, and I worry about fertility, though getting pregnant is the most dysphoria-inducing thought I have. I've wanted a hysterectomy since I was 14, years before identifying as trans. I tried twice to present as a masculine woman instead of a trans man. The first time, about a year after coming out (after moving for college), lasted only 2 days because it was unbearable. The second time, about 6 months on T when I needed a job, lasted about 2 months before I got hired at an LGBT-inclusive company — the job I still have — and quit the female-presenting one. I don't pass at all: I'm very short, my bone structure doesn't help, and my beard is hidden by mandatory masks. I'm bisexual; when I dated cis men people saw us as gay men, and now with my girlfriend everyone reads us as a lesbian couple. I don't mind being called butch or a dke — it feels off but doesn't offend me — and I actually feel somewhat safer being read as a lesbian than as a gay man because of lower violence risk. Friends and family use my chosen name and he/him, but I feel like I'm living a lie when society sees me as a woman. As a non-passing trans man I feel I get the worst of both worlds — "either a dke or a fggot." By mid-2022 I had stopped HRT (3 months off at that point) but chose to stay socially FtM because going back would be too much bother and I don't really care either way anymore. My voice is permanently deeper — I was a contralto before T and now sit in baritone range; after vocal training I recovered almost 3 octaves like pre-transition but shifted lower, and I'll never hit those high notes again. My periods have returned (coming back 1–8 months after last shot depending on T levels), and I've had regular cycles and ovulation for a couple months, so I think my fertility is back to normal. I'm not sure whether I'll ever pursue pregnancy given how dysphoria-inducing it is; I'll probably adopt but would like biological kids too. I now advise others considering HRT that it has too many irreversible effects to risk without being certain, that they should address trauma and other issues first, and that they can always start later. I recommend therapy with someone not affiliated with a gender clinic, getting out of online echo chambers and "ultra queer spaces," and consulting doctors about fertility. I'm critical of how doctors and the trans community sugarcoat medical decisions and hate that discussing downsides is now called transphobic. I've told people to look into detransitioners of their gender who had SRS and are happier now, and that switching to HRT with one's own biological hormones is possible even after surgery. I don't think transition is right for everyone, nor is detransition — it doesn't look the same for all people.