All stories

From furiously debunking gender critical arguments to agreeing with them in three months

Female · Detransitioned908
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who passed easily as a man but detransitioned because continuing to transition reinforced the false representation of womanhood that had made me transition in the first place. I spent time furiously 'debunking' gender critical arguments before coming to agree with them within about three months. I have spent over a decade in detrans spaces and reject the concept of gender identity while acknowledging only two sexes. I am critical of youth gender medicine and shared the Missouri investigation into a pediatric transgender center in detail. I do not report suicidal ideation or self-harm in this transcript.

Full story

I was born female. I first came to question the gender system and my own identification around the time I was already in the detrans process — by the time the subreddit I later posted in was created (before late 2022), I was already detransitioning. Before that, I had identified as trans and passed easily as a man, but one thing that convinced me to detransition was the realization that maintaining my transition only reinforced the false representation of womanhood that had made me transition in the first place. During and after my detransition I spent a lot of time 'hate reading' gender critical blogs and writing long responses 'debunking' TERF arguments for an imaginary audience — quoting things out of context and deliberately misrepresenting what those writers actually meant. It took me less than three months to come to terms with the fact that they kind of had a point. I now describe myself as a woman because I am female and human, and I say there is no special 'lady fEeLz' — I only know I'm a woman because I was made aware I was female early on. I also reflected that I had been operating under the false belief that 'man' and 'woman' were genders rather than masculine and feminine, and that I thought 'social construct' meant 'self-construct'. I feel the discourse around trans identity deliberately plays on people's faulty assumptions, and that my misunderstandings would have been quickly rectified if discussion of sex and gender weren't so intensely suppressed. I have also suggested to others considering testosterone that there is no rush and they should stop as soon as possible if they have doubts. I have spent more than a decade in detrans spaces and say I have never witnessed anyone there dehumanize, defame, or condone violence against people who describe themselves as transgender; I argue that disagreeing with trans-identified people is not transphobia and that identity is not sacrosanct. I am critical of the medicalization of gender, particularly of minors, and I shared the Missouri Attorney General's investigation into the St. Louis Children's Hospital Transgender Center in detail, calling it a possible 'watershed moment'. I am skeptical of for-profit US medicine and medical associations, critical of GLAAD-style messaging, and I reject the concept of gender identity while acknowledging there are only two sexes (sex defined by gametes, with DSDs still being male or female). I do not consider myself aligned with figures like Matt Walsh, though I think his documentary exposes the ideological basis of 'gender medicine'. I also shared a long feminist essay drawing parallels between anorexia and gender dysphoria as forms of flight from 'grown-up femininity', saying it would resonate with other detrans people, especially women. I do not describe myself as regretting transition explicitly in these posts, but I express haunting regret about having supported a movement that limits women's freedom of association.