All stories

A decade as a gay man, never once passing

Female · Desisted49
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who identified as a gay man for about a decade but never medically transitioned and never passed. I now understand my dysphoria and desire to masculinize as rooted in internalized misogyny, homophobia, and envy of men — including envy over how fat men were treated versus fat women. I have never had surgery or hormones, so there are no irreversible medical changes or fertility concerns to report. I am currently in a butch/femme relationship with a partner who finds me attractive as I am, which I describe as transformative, and I now advocate that childhood sex dysphoria is common in gay children and that accepting who you are beats trying to change it. I continue to work through the underlying causes of my dysphoria and describe myself as still having mental health struggles, though older and knowing myself more.

Full story

I was a very sex-dysphoric child and have always been masculine in general. I found out what being trans was around 2009/2010, when I was a teenager, and I put everything into it. Knowing there was a 'way out' made my internal dysphoria — probably rooted in misogyny — ten times worse, because it was easier to say my 'transness' was the reason I was miserable instead of facing all the things I already hated about myself. I identified as a gay man for years. For a long time I thought I was attracted to men, but it took me a while, and some unpleasant sexual experiences, to recognize that I wasn't actually attracted to them — I was envious of them. I think I was reconciling my homosexuality with how unattractive I found the idea of being a lesbian: 'I'm still gay, but a man now,' that kind of thing. Internalized misogyny and homophobia were definitely part of it, though I'm still figuring out all the underlying causes. I also used to be really fat — 'tlc special fat,' as I put it — and I envied the fact that fat men were treated better than fat women. That connection only became clear to me years after losing weight and growing older. Envy played a large part in my own desire to escape my body. I never medically transitioned, and therefore never truly passed. I never fit in as a man. I did not look like them, I did not act like them, and the more men I surrounded myself with and tried to emulate, the more I realized you are not 'actually' something you have to force yourself to be. I did this for a decade. Nobody ever saw me as a man. One of the biggest things for me in not medically transitioning — and something that took me a while to fully accept — was that I was never going to be a man, only a transman, which are very different things. What helped me was realizing that childhood sex dysphoria is pretty common in gay children. Thinking back to how I was as a child only reinforced my then-current state of mind of 'I am trans and always have been' — but I wasn't; I was masculine and always have been. I don't 'feel' like a woman, I just am one. I am now in a 'heteronormative' butch/femme relationship, and finding somebody who thought I was sexually attractive as I was, as my body was, was transformative for me. There is nothing wrong with, or disgusting about, being a butch woman. In my opinion it's always more damaging to try and change who you are rather than accept it. I've spent time advising younger people considering transition: I tell them they can always transition when they're older and their brain is more developed, but detransitioning is much harder, and I've urged them to make sure they don't have an idealized view of what transitioning entails.