All stories

Tumblr told her she hated womanhood — so she transitioned

Female · DetransitionedTransition 14 → Detransition 201.5K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who identified as a trans man from about age 14, socially transitioned, and took testosterone for roughly a year in college before detransitioning around age 20. I now recognize I transitioned out of internalized sexism, an abusive feminine-role upbringing, and a toxic online Tumblr community that told me my hatred of womanhood meant I was trans. I deeply regret the years and money spent on transition, though I've learned to accept my deep voice and my identity as a butch masculine woman. My former trans friends shunned and call-out-posted me when I detransitioned, while my gay and straight friends supported me. I want young girls to know it's okay to be a masculine girl without transitioning, and I'm wary of being used by either side's political agenda.

Full story

I was born female and grew up in an abusive household that pushed me into very feminine roles. I had really awful confidence and a poor sense of self worth in high school, and I was always naturally more masculine. I hated being pushed to be feminine, hated being seen as 'weaker' or 'inferior' as a woman, and I associated women with inferiority and men with being better, stronger, cooler. When I was around 14, I told an online Tumblr friend group how much I hated being forced into feminine roles, and they told me I must be a trans man because no real woman would hate feminine stuff that much. That's when it 'clicked' for me that I was a trans man, and I immediately started going by he/him pronouns. I asked a friend to buy me a binder. From roughly ages 14 to 19 I was convinced by online communities I was trans because I was a boyish-looking girl. I later realized what I really wanted was the power and status that came with being a hot, handsome, well-off, confident man. I identified as a trans male for about four years of my life before physically transitioning, and I was even a truscum during that time, hating people I considered 'fake trans.' I withheld physically transitioning until I was 18 and moved out of my parents' home, partly because of growing up in an abusive household. I started testosterone in college, about a year and a half before I began detransitioning, saving for top surgery while paying tuition and rent. I spent years of my life and a lot of money I could have used for tuition, rent, and therapy for my abuse and trauma on transition. I read something about testosterone lowering IQ on Tumblr, and that was the first thing that made me drop T. When I moved out, found a good job, and built a new supportive group of friends, my confidence picked up and I became happier — but I realized I was happier because of my environment, not because of being on T. I still hated who I was. It took me months of self-meditation and thinking to realize my trans identity had been forced onto me by an online community because I was a self-hating teen with rooted sexism and biases. I asked myself whether I needed to be a man or merely wanted to be one, and that helped me come off T. I began detransitioning about a year before late 2019, approaching my two-year detransition anniversary around then. When I started asking to be referred to as she/her again and no longer identifying as a guy, friends in the trans community I had known for years instantly blocked and shunned me, and one group made a Tumblr call-out post about me. It was a traumatic time. My gay friends and even my straight friends were actually supportive. I legally changed my name and last name and kept it, since my full original name had been given to me by a 'pretty damn garbage person.' Physically, I didn't look like a man and didn't look like a woman — I looked like a strange in-between who got regularly called an 'it.' My voice is still deep, but I've learned to accept and love it, helped by knowing women with naturally deep voices. I got therapy for my body dysphoria and realized I had only transitioned because I hated women. I moved to the city where I saw a lot of butch lesbian women and that's where my real identity clicked — I realized I was just a masculine woman, and that was okay. I came to accept I was a butch masc woman who had been shamed into thinking that was a bad thing to be. I deeply regretted the years and money spent on transition. I have big body image problems. I considered making a video about my experience but worried about being doxxed or attacked by people on both sides. I work in an industry with a lot of LGBT people in a big city with many trans men and monthly pride events. Around December 2019 I discovered a coworker, an FTM who had been on T about a year like me, was also detransitioning and identifying as female again, which made me feel less alone. I don't have any butch lesbian friends — every one of them is genderfluid, nonbinary, or has come out as a trans man. I'm atheist. I'm politically liberal. I've spent a lot of time on Reddit defending detrans experiences against what I see as silencing from both the trans community and conservatives with agendas.