These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a 51-year-old detransitioned... no — I am a 51-year-old gender-nonconforming woman who has never identified as trans or detransitioned, posting in r/detrans as an outside observer. I was a childhood tomboy who claimed to be a boy and could have passed as male, but transition wasn't an option when I was young, and I'm glad it wasn't because I worry I'd have wasted my life 'chasing after a false reality.' I'm an engineer in IT, married to a supportive husband, childfree by choice, and happily gender-nonconforming with short hair, men's clothes, and hobbies like bass guitar, video games, and working on my Jeep. I'm critical of trans ideology, especially regarding children, and have been banned from several subreddits for my views. I'm in a good place now and wish I'd learned earlier to stop caring what other people think.
Full story
I was born female and I have never identified as trans or detransitioned — I'm a gender-nonconforming woman who has been posting in r/detrans as an outside observer, mostly because I recognize a lot of what people describe and I want to offer perspective. I've said repeatedly that I'm 'not trans or detrans, just highly gnc' and that trans identity came along too late in my life for me to ever consider it.
I'm 51 as of January 2020 (I said 'I'm 51 now' in a January 17, 2020 comment, and elsewhere in June 2020 I said I was '50+'). I look back on my own childhood and see a lot of the same patterns people here describe: I proclaimed I was a boy 'QUITE a lot' when I was younger, and I said I 'got a kick out of' claiming I was 'some kind of hybrid' — a sentiment I noted I hadn't heard many other people express. I looked like a boy when my hair was short and could probably have passed. My mother tried to force me into the 'girl' box when I was little and it didn't work. There was a brief period in late high school or early college when 'not fitting in' bothered me, but I worked through it and went my own way. Being trans simply wasn't a thing when I was young — I learned I was going to grow up to be a woman and there was nothing I could do about it, so I just did it.
I'm extremely gender nonconforming and always have been. Around age 21 I cut my hair into a buzz cut, ditched all the makeup, loaded up on cargo shorts and T-shirts, and stopped dating men for roughly the next 25 years. I work in IT/engineering — a male-dominated field — and I've reflected on how much of my career progress is tied to being childfree: 'I doubt I would have gotten as far as I have if it weren't for the fact that I'm childfree.' I also noted that I took everything thrown at me and never let myself fail, because people never forget a woman's failure in a male-dominated field, and that many of the men I work with have stay-at-home wives who do the cooking, cleaning, and laundry while I still have to do all of that too. I never had kids and I'm not sorry about it.
I'm married to a husband who does all the cooking and whom I describe as 'rather typical male (not too GNC).' I've used that to reassure GNC women that there are het/bi guys into their look. My hobbies are bass guitar, video games, Legos, working on and wheeling my Jeep(s), bowling, making jewelry (hammering and burning metal into gifts), and other things not considered 'girly.' I have very short hair, mostly wear men's clothes, rarely wear makeup, and don't wear dresses. My voice is rather deep for a woman — I get hassled in video game voice chat by guys trying to figure out if I'm a guy or a girl, and I just let it roll off my back. I get called 'sir' quite a bit if I don't talk, and I don't care. I've been told I could be the poster child for 'agender' — I don't experience myself as sexed or gendered in dreams, just 'me,' and I was surprised to learn other people do. I've said I could pretty easily pass as a guy if I wanted to, but I don't see the point. I don't 'feel like a woman' either — I've said none of us really do; we just know what it's like to be ourselves.
I was bullied and called horrible names when I was younger — 'dyke/man/androgynous/whatever' — but I've said that has all but disappeared as I've gotten older and I 'rock it out now.' I also realized only later in life that my childhood 'wasn't normal, and by many standards wasn't even that good,' which took gaining perspective to see. I've noted I 'came up with a 4' on some test and initially thought that was a good thing, which suggests some difficulty with self-assessment or emotional awareness.
I have never undergone any transition-related medical treatment. I did consider HRT after menopause but decided against it — reading discussions on r/detrans about long-term HRT made me 'glad I never opted for hrt after menopause.' I've expressed concern about puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones in adolescents, saying that staying on them too long could mean you'll 'never have a normal puberty,' with growth plates closing and bone density affected.
My main reason for participating here is advocacy and perspective. I worry that if I'd been born a decade or two later I 'would have gotten caught up in this nonsense,' and I've said I'm glad being trans wasn't an option when I was a kid because I worry I 'would've wasted a bunch of my life chasing after a false reality.' I'm critical of what I call 'trans ideology' and gender identity frameworks more broadly: I've said 'gender needs to get into the bin,' that male and female are 'states of being that nothing can change,' and that there's no such thing as gender — you don't have to choose one. I've been banned from multiple subreddits (including one for saying males aren't included in the definition of lesbian, and from a twox-style subreddit) for what I jokingly call 'terfiness.' I'm broadly supportive of people transitioning if they want to and detransitioning if they want to, but strongly opposed to anyone pressuring others to transition, and especially opposed to children making these decisions. I've recommended the BITE model to people questioning trans ideology. I've also pushed back on parents who affirm children's cross-sex identification, arguing a parent's job is to help children accept reality rather than confirm 'whatever delusion they may have at the moment.'
On the medical-conscience debate, I've argued that doctors should be free to choose which patients they treat — for instance a gynecologist treating only female patients — while also saying people who refuse to do their jobs out of personal views are 'in fact, assholes.' I've expressed sympathy for people who say they were 'groomed into the trans community.'
Overall I'm in a good place: I'm happier now than when I felt compelled to conform, I have a stable marriage, a career I'm proud of, and a lot of hobbies. My regret is not about transition — it's about the years I spent feeling I had to fit a mold before I learned to stop caring what other people think, which I wish I'd learned at an earlier age.