All stories

Never medically transitioned — but a coworker's comment changed everything

Female · Detransitioned75
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who grew up feeling I wasn't "female" enough and now believes that feeling was a normal response to unrealistic societal ideals rather than evidence I was meant to be male. I consider myself lucky to have gone through my experience before medical intervention was readily available, and I blame mental health professionals and doctors for not adequately warning people about the permanence of transition. A rude encounter with a trans coworker about four years ago was a turning point in how I viewed the issue. I am critical of transition for minors, of the erasure of gender-nonconforming women's spaces, and of a medical community I believe is afraid to study detransition or comorbidities. I advocate acceptance and non-surgical pain management for others in similar situations.

Full story

I grew up tomboyish — I never liked dolls and only played with boys, and from a young age I felt like something was wrong with me, like I wasn't "female" enough to be considered a girl. Looking back, I think that feeling came from constantly comparing myself to the idealized version of what society says a woman should be. I went through a phase of feeling that way about my gender, but I eventually came to see that nobody in the world is 100% gender conforming, and that not being 100% feminine is the most normal thing in the world. I feel strongly that the system failed me. I believe it was, and still is, the responsibility of mental health professionals and doctors to make sure a person won't regret what they're doing and to emphasize just how 100% permanent everything is. Transitioning, going through hormones, permanent surgery, and being a medical patient for life shouldn't be taken lightly. I'm lucky that I went through what I did before medical intervention was readily made available to people — that timing spared me from interventions I now think are handed out too easily. One turning point for me happened at work about four years ago, in a Zoom meeting with 15–20 people. One of the best software engineers at our company was speaking and said "...You guys can usually..." and was immediately interrupted by a coworker, a trans woman in a different department, who said "Don't you ever use 'you guys.' Use 'you people.' This is very important to me." I was shocked and thought it was rude. I do understand respecting people's pronouns, but I think respect goes both ways — you don't interrupt someone during a presentation to demand they speak in a way that suits you specifically. If the person had been offensive it would be different, but he was just talking normally. I've said that moment was when I started to feel differently about the entire thing. I've also seen what I consider erasure of gender-nonconforming women's spaces — I noted that even the lesbian subreddit is mostly MTFs. On transition more broadly, I think we should be cultivating a society that makes those choices unappealing, especially for minors and young people, in the same way cigarettes, alcohol, and pornography shouldn't be sold in or next to schools. We have to ask the hard question of what makes a child choose to become trans, the way we'd ask what makes a child smoke or do drugs. Those questions make people uncomfortable because raising a well-rounded generation is hard and takes more than just parents — it takes a village. I've also told someone that having an unstable sense of self that relies on gender identity, which is itself unstable, is a problem. And I've said the medical and behavioral science community is unfortunately afraid of touching this subject because it's rife with social baggage — if you publish any study implying transition isn't a 100% fix, or that transgender people may suffer from other comorbidities that influence their transness, you can say goodbye to your career. When I talk to others who are struggling, I encourage them to look around at ordinary women rather than celebrities — to go to a local grocery store and observe girls and women of all ages and races, and to judge them the way they judge themselves, including body shape, voice, and mannerisms, and not just the young pretty ones. That's how you see there is no right way to be a woman, and that if you're born a woman you are a woman. I also suggest discussing pain management without further elective surgery with doctors, and finding a therapist who can actually help with detransition if that's what someone is looking for — while being clear that a therapist can't solve everything and a lot has to come from within. Ultimately I believe acceptance is the only way to move on: accepting the mistakes you made and their consequences, telling yourself it's okay that you made those decisions, and accepting that you can still detransition despite surgery. I compare it to grief — it comes in waves and may not fully go away for a very long time.