All stories

Five years on testosterone, then misread as a trans woman

Female · Detransitioned193
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I'm a detransitioned woman (ftmtf) who medically transitioned with testosterone and top surgery starting at 18 for about five years, and has now been medically detransitioning for about two and a half years. Transition didn't fit because I realized I valued the social identity of being a same-sex attracted man more than being seen as male, cis men still sexualized me, and trauma — including sexual assault — fueled much of my original gender hatred. I have lingering physical effects (deepened voice, androgynous features) that make people misread me as a trans woman, plus depression, brain fog, and trichotillomania, but I have no regrets about detransitioning and significant regret about medically transitioning. I'm in a supportive long-term same-sex relationship with a nonbinary transmasc partner, and I advocate for visible, non-right-wing detransition narratives while encouraging cautious, therapy-first approaches to medical transition for others.

Full story

I was born female and identified as trans for about five years, medically transitioning with testosterone starting at 18 after wanting to since adolescence. I also had top surgery. I've now been medically detransitioning for about two and a half years and identify as a woman again, though I still go by a gender-neutral nickname and she/they pronouns rather than having a big conversation with my family about my original male name. What led me toward transition and then away from it is complicated. I now recognize that a lot of the hatred I had for my gender perception came from trauma, including sexual assault, and a block around that trauma. I also had significant body dysmorphia that persisted through transition, and I realized that presenting as an effeminate man didn't shield me from sexual harassment the way I'd hoped. Once I became truly 'passing,' I noticed that what I actually enjoyed was the social connection with other trans men and being able to frame myself as a same-sex attracted man rather than a same-sex attracted woman — I liked that more than actually being seen as male. Meanwhile, cis men who knew still treated me in sexualizing and condescending ways, and I started having a harder time creating authentic connections with women, who had previously been my primary social bonds. My feelings about all of this amplified immensely after being sexually assaulted by a transfem person, which left me with a lot of conflicting emotions. Medically, being on testosterone deepened my voice, which is one of the more persistent changes — I'm quite tall for female (5'9''), have androgynous features, and my voice still gets read as male sometimes, which leads people to assume I'm a trans woman rather than a detransitioned woman. Coming off testosterone, I noticed I cry a lot more now — while on T I'd rarely shed tears, just feel like I should but couldn't, and now I'm back to crying easily. I have brain fog but attribute that more to depression and sleep issues I've dealt with throughout transition and detransition. I also have trichotillomania, whose focus has shifted over time. I've grieved the loss of chest sensation after top surgery — implants wouldn't fix what I miss, but I've made some peace with it and noted small silver linings. Mentally, I've struggled with depression and sleep issues, and I've dealt with fixation and anxiety spirals around how I'm perceived. I've found therapy hard — finding someone prepared to engage with detransition has been a struggle, and my attempts have been discouraging. I've advised others to seek trauma-informed, non-gender-specific therapists before medical intervention, since unresolved trauma is what bit me and many other detrans people. Socially, I live in a very trans-inclusive area in western Washington (I'm an out-of-state transplant) and encounter trans people daily, which makes me feel more alone in my experience than ever. I resent being called 'he' and get anxiety over men's restrooms, but I also dread correcting people because I don't want to offend or be seen as attacking trans rights. I'm scared of being assumed to be conservative or part of an anti-trans agenda despite being solidly left-leaning. I'm bisexual and in a committed long-term same-sex relationship with a nonbinary transmasc partner, who has been remarkably supportive of my detransition — their support pushed me past my own judgments, and honest communication about my grief has helped me accept that their experience differs from mine. The people closest to me reacted with empathy and support. I have no regrets about detransitioning so far, though I have a lot of regret about medically transitioning. I've shared a photo comparison of myself pre-T, on T, and off T to show that change isn't always radical. I generally choose to be selective about what I share and where — I keep post history removed on this account and engage more openly on Tumblr with feminist content, though I get adverse responses outside that bubble. I believe detransition needs non-right-wing people in the spotlight so it stops being seen as propaganda, and I think the framing should be: socially do whatever you want, medically think about it really hard with a good therapist before making permanent decisions. I've gained dysphoria over not looking feminine after medically transitioning, but overall I'm moving toward being more open about who I am.