All stories

Estrogen's permanent changes, and the gym to undo them

Male · Detransitioned118
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man, 28 as of September 2021, who previously took estrogen and now identifies as male and says I am okay with manhood. Estrogen left permanent subcutaneous fat and skin changes I try to counteract through working out, and I have familiarity with chest surgery options for residual glandular tissue. I have become sharply critical of trans community culture, comparing it to a religion and viewing both activist and stoic trans identities as insecure. I have not described mental health conditions, family dynamics, or explicit regret, but my efforts to reverse HRT's effects suggest dissatisfaction.

Full story

I am a detransitioned male who lived as a trans woman for a period and then returned to identifying as a man. I am 28 years old as of September 2021, and I finished a post-grad program some years earlier. I recall that around 6-7 years before that point, while I was in college, I was still working through my understanding of myself — I have said that as a teen I did not fully appreciate or understand myself, but that now I am okay with manhood and enjoy the power of masculinity. I took estrogen at some point for a significant enough duration that it left lasting physical effects. Specifically, I described fat changes in the subcutaneous layer that do not fully reverse because the fat cells remain permanently — I noted that even at bone-thin weight my skin has a different texture than a man who never took estrogen. I described these as 'cherubic' effects left behind by HRT, and I now work out to counteract them: increasing vascularity and muscle tension, reducing fat, and highlighting bone structure. I have also discussed chest development from estrogen and advised someone else that glandular tissue from estrogen does not go away with weight loss and that surgery is the only way to achieve a normal chest, recommending an incision through the pigmented areola rather than a pectoral incision — which suggests I have direct familiarity with this surgical question, though I have not explicitly stated that I had chest surgery myself. I have become quite critical of trans community culture. I described a person from my college who was extremely extroverted and overshared, who became even more extreme after going trans and led the main trans club, including an incident where he asked lesbians if it was okay for him to identify as a lesbian. I observed that most trans people are obsessed with being trans and thinking about the word 'trans' constantly. I also critiqued two attitudes I see as flawed: trans people who make being trans and activism central to their personality, and a reactive phase where trans people pretend not to think about being trans and appear stoic — I said both come from insecurity and pecking-order establishment and neither seems genuine. I compared trans identification to a religion psychologically and emotionally, arguing that some western leftists simply replaced religion with another ideology their brains treat as religion. I have also commented on the dating dynamics of FtMs, noting that on Grindr it seems mostly FtMs looking for each other, with high-sex-drive individuals seeking hookups while acting picky about 'no chasers no straight guys.' I questioned why people would think FtMs are 'better' than butch women, since most people including lesbians find butch women more attractive than men with vaginas. Overall I appear to have detransitioned, reclaimed a male identity, and now view my prior transition and the broader trans movement with significant skepticism and criticism. I have not described specific mental health diagnoses, trauma, family dynamics, sexuality details, or explicit regret language, though my efforts to reverse estrogen's physical effects and my critical stance suggest dissatisfaction with aspects of what happened.