All stories

School tech by day, skeptic of the magic fix by choice

Male · Detransitioned211
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned person who now offers cautious, critical advice to others questioning transition, drawing on my own experience of using transition as an apparent fix for depression. I believe genuine gender dysphoria is rare, that most people who seek transition are reaching for an intoxicating fantasy of a magic solution, and that transition should not happen before mental and emotional maturity. I hold a critical view of the medical science, arguing it cannot truly change someone into the other gender. I work as a school computer tech and am active in tabletop gaming communities. I have not disclosed specific medical details, ages, or a current identity label in this transcript.

Full story

I came to this community after having been through my own version of this, and I try to offer perspective to others who are questioning. I remember being in a similar spot myself, and I tell people who are uncertain about transition that they should first ask themselves whether they are capable of loving the aspects of themselves that would remain the same even if they changed their gender — whether they can have affection for who they are and for the majority of their physical existence. My own view, which I state plainly, is that if you cannot answer yes to that, transition will not soothe the hurt; it will make it worse. I speak from experience when I say that actual gender dysphoria is rare, and that it got latched onto as a popular edgy thing because of how romanticized mental illness and depression are these days. For those who are genuinely depressed, I believe it got latched onto as a potential solution — just like binge eating or compliment fishing, or other unhealthy habits a depressive person reaches for, either desperately in defiance of, or unaware of, the fact that they have to take responsibility for their own happiness and healing. I recognize the intoxicating fantasy that it's not their fault and that if they could just do X or Y everything would be better, because I lived it. On the medical side, I hold a critical view: I say that people who are genuinely trans are a tiny percentage of the population, and of them, an even smaller percentage should transition, and that transition should not happen before mental and emotional maturity. I also argue that even among those who should transition, they should consider not doing so, because the medical science involved is not terribly good yet — it won't make you into the other gender, it will make you something, but not the other gender, and what some people need may simply not be possible right now. Outside of transition-related topics, I work for a school as the computer tech, which means instead of getting summers off I get summer overtime, and end of the school year is amazingly hectic for me. I'm also into tabletop gaming — I do a lot of custom content, both kitbashing and homebrew rules, and I've asked others about voice training because I'd love to sound closer to that. I try to be supportive and encouraging to people reaching out, and I appreciate when others put effort into helping the community, even on topics that aren't of direct concern to me.