All stories

Top surgery at 24 — then detransitioning without becoming a woman

Female · Detransitioned575
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned female who identified as trans/nonbinary for about three years and detransitioned not because I came to feel like a woman, but because I hated being trans more than anything. I started testosterone and had top surgery around early 2021, then in April 2021 committed to a slow detransition — going off T after my COVID vaccine and working back toward she/her. I repeatedly said being a man felt closer to who I actually am, and that I knew I wasn't a woman, so detransition was about escaping the shame and stigma of being trans rather than reconciling with womanhood. I struggled with motivation and part of me wanted the detransition to fail. I had considered conversion therapy and imagined that if I could believe I deserved violence for being trans I might be able to stop.

Full story

I was born female, and for a long time I genuinely loved it — I described myself as a lesbian, a feminist, someone who "took no shit," and I got a lot of joy out of being the kind of woman I was. I never hated being a woman before I started questioning whether I was trans. That questioning began after puberty; I didn't start thinking I was trans until after puberty, and once I "realized" I wasn't a woman, being mistaken for one stopped feeling good and turned into disdain. By January 2020 I was identifying as nonbinary (with, I said, a slight male lean) and had been posting in r/detrans for a while. I was in DBT and had been in therapy for about a year, but it hadn't helped my dysphoria — sometimes it made me more inclined to think I was trans. At that point I had an upcoming appointment to start testosterone and was on a waiting list for top surgery; in my country the wait for top surgery was about four years. I hadn't taken any medical steps yet, and I noted that everything so far was reversible. I was torn: I wanted to start T, but I also felt that being a girl would give me a much better life. I kept saying I wanted to cancel the appointments but couldn't bring myself to do it. My hatred of being trans was intense and central. I wrote that being nonbinary was "especially embarrassing and fucked up," that being trans made me feel like "a fucking monster of a human being," and that coming out felt shameful. I couldn't be stealth as a nonbinary person — either I got misgendered or I had to correct people, which felt worse. I hated the infantilization and pity I felt people directed at trans people; that was one of the biggest reasons I wanted to detransition. I also said a lot of trans people annoyed me and I didn't want to become like them, and I found the community embarrassing. In June 2020 I posted asking how to tell real dysphoria from a lesbian's disconnect from womanhood, since so much femininity revolves around performing for men. I wondered whether my dysphoria was gender dysphoria or just that disconnect. In September 2020 I posted asking how to find conversion therapy, saying I'd wanted it for years and needed to be told how and why to stop being trans. In a comment I mused that maybe if it caused me pain I'd understand better why being trans was bad. Later, in March 2021, I again raised the idea, saying that if I could get it into my head that I deserved violence for being trans, maybe I could stop — while clarifying I didn't think other trans people deserved violence. I did start testosterone at some point in this period, and I wanted its effects — I said I wanted a lot of the changes and to pass more, and that the face and body shape changes made me feel "objectively good inside and Right." I also wore a binder. Presenting in a way people would read as a girl (usually just not wearing a binder) made me panicky; I'd get so anxious I couldn't go out the door and had to change back. Trying to identify as a woman made me dissociate or gave me bad anxiety. I also said that if I stayed on T I'd never feel cis, and that I might need to take a break from it, force myself back into womanhood, and then possibly take it again "for the right reasons." Around March 31, 2021 I mentioned possibly having post-op depression, and on April 21, 2021 I said I'd had top surgery a month and a half earlier — so top surgery happened around late February/early March 2021, despite my earlier belief that it was four years away. My silhouette had changed a lot and I wasn't always sure I recognized myself in the mirror. I did generally like how I looked if I'd done my hair and eyebrow makeup. On April 20, 2021 I posted that I was finally committing to detransitioning. I'd been hating being trans for about three years and had tried to detransition many times before, but never in a way that would last. Previously I'd thrown myself into makeup and feminine clothes I hadn't even worn as a woman, which was too shocking and I'd always gone back to being trans. This time I planned to go slowly: back to they/them, then work toward she/her, present however I wanted, and stay on T briefly while adjusting everything else before slowly going off it. I said I planned to wait until after my second COVID vaccine dose (T being immunosuppressant) before stopping T, and then talk to my doctor. I noted my doctors were good and hadn't judged me when I mentioned detransition. Crucially, I was not detransitioning because I'd come to feel like a woman. I said repeatedly that being a man felt closer to who I actually was — not just the freedom to act masculine, but "being" a man that felt right — and that I knew I wasn't a woman in my head. I was detransitioning because I hated being trans more than anything. I also admitted I struggled with motivation, that a large part of me wanted the detransition to fail and to go back to being trans, even though that had never happened in my three years of identifying as trans. I had a partner who dressed similarly to me (we both had the look before meeting). I was easily distracted and didn't like talking about my problems to people I knew. I was in therapy/DBT but resistant to asking for help, seeing it as weakness. I considered myself a lesbian. As of my last posts in May 2021, I was still in the early stages of detransition, on T, and hating being trans.