All stories

Four years of estrogen, and only the social part was a mistake

Male · Detransitioned810
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned (socially) male who transitioned MtF, medically and socially, for over four years and who now identifies as male again while deliberately continuing HRT because it improved my mental health. I regret social transition most of all — the misreadings, hugboxing, and isolation — but I do not regret the medical side and I am non-op by choice, convinced surgery would be a mistake. I came to believe my dysphoria rooted in being a naturally feminine boy in a culture not ready for me, and that believing in 'born trans' ideology railroaded me into transitioning. I'm critical of transition for others, consider myself a feminist and leftist, and advocate for more nuance and honesty in how dysphoria is discussed. I have no reported suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts since detransitioning.

Full story

I was born male, and I remember experiencing gender dysphoria as young as age 6 — I identified as a girl from around that age, was naturally feminine as a child, and my friends were all girls. I now describe myself as having fit the 'perfect candidate' or ideal narrative for transition: persistent lifelong dysphoria, not a fetishist, naturally feminine. I transitioned medically and socially for over 4 years (as of late 2024), and I was 33 years old in December 2024. I transitioned MtF. I socially transitioned in a college setting. In hindsight I see that as my biggest regret. Almost everyone around me interpreted my transition in a cultural/stereotypical way rather than as a medical one — they thought I 'identified as a woman in the sense that women like dresses, makeup, and other stereotypically feminine things,' rather than understanding I wanted to treat gender dysphoria. When I kept dressing basically the same except for women's jeans instead of men's, people assumed I was repressing some desire to wear skirts. People either walked on eggshells around me or viewed me as 'a flamboyant gay man with she/her pronouns.' I couldn't tell whether I passed, because allies saw trans identity as a cultural social thing and didn't understand why my goal would be to look female. I found the hugboxing infuriating — everyone just used whichever pronouns they thought I wanted to hear, which I experienced as lying and gaslighting. I never felt at home in the trans community; I tolerated it because few people understood why I'd want to be on HRT. I found instead 'a community of very insecure individuals who can't handle reality.' I have persistent and lifelong dysphoria that previous attempts haven't let me escape. I've been diagnosed with autism, though I'm skeptical of that diagnosis due to unaddressed trauma, and I'm working with a therapist to try to figure out what I haven't yet come to terms with regarding my childhood. I've said I can't claim I grew up as a little girl, though it wasn't quite as simple as growing up as a boy either. On medical transition: HRT improved my mental health and I fully intend to persist with it. I do not regret medical transition. However, after 4 years I concluded that passing as a cisgender woman seems less and less likely every day — HRT turned me into someone who 'almost' passes but fails upon closer inspection. I suspect I have body dysmorphia of some kind, because sometimes I look in the mirror and see a woman and other times I see a man, so I've judged passing by how people refer to me. I am non-op by choice, convinced surgery would be a mistake; SRS is 'very much off the table' since I've accepted I'll never have a normal female body. I've cited concerns that HRT may be less healthy than the trans community claims, can kill libido, and can cause infertility. My social detransition has been gradual. Instead of coming out as a social detransitioner, I started saying I 'don't like to label myself' rather than saying I'm a woman, settling into androgyny. My plan was to not socially detransition until I got a new job, to avoid awkwardness, and to ID as male in the workplace. I've considered calling myself nonbinary in friend groups because I've pulled off androgyny so well that some people think I'm male and some think I'm female — but I ultimately went back to identifying as male while staying openly gender nonconforming. I dislike labels generally, calling them 'a lazy way to make assumptions about other people.' I've described my social detransition as 'an evolution in how I understand my place in the world,' and said stress dropped significantly once I stopped trying to pass. What moved me toward social detransition: I realized transition wasn't working as I'd hoped and faced a choice — dig in my heels hoping to eventually feel 'complete' as a woman, or accept there are things I can't change. I chose to accept and work with what I have. I came to believe that 'developing a female identity was just an unhealthy way of coping with a culture that wasn't ready for men like me' — in my case, my culture punished me for being a naturally feminine man whose friends were all girls. I also came to believe that believing some people are 'trans' in itself railroaded me into identifying as trans and transitioning. I've said I healed by 'acknowledging that trans identity is an ideology.' I got permanently banned from another detrans sub, which I believe was because I identified as transmed at the time; they confirmed it was because I'm transmed. That ban disillusioned me and pushed me to post here. Over time I've actually moved away from transmedicalism — I now say I've become more 'tucute' as I've gotten more 'transphobic,' believing gender identity is fluid and that a trans person is anyone who considers themselves one, because thinking of yourself as trans can lead to developing a trans identity. I've been banned from multiple trans spaces for being 'a bit too honest.' I generally don't share these opinions offline because it would hurt my social life, but I try to explain the potential problems with transition — what HRT can and can't do, what can go wrong socially — rather than telling people they're mistaken. I believe many people start thinking they're trans due to growing up religious or having internalized misogyny or misandry. I've written a long list of reasons not to transition for someone considering it, and I've DM'd with people considering transition. I consider myself a feminist and a leftist, though I acknowledge the right tends to be more open to discussion about trans issues than liberals. I've said no-one should transition, while insisting I don't wish harm on trans people. I've also advised other detransitioners that detransitioning is nobody's business but their own and their doctor's, and that they don't owe anyone an explanation. Current status: I identify as male, remain on HRT, am non-op, and am openly gender nonconforming. I consider myself a social detransitioner rather than a medical one, and I'm critical of transition for others while acknowledging it helped my dysphoria somewhat.