All stories

Nineteen years as a man, no hormones, still parsing it

Female · Desisted189
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman: I identified as trans for about 19 years (roughly 17 as a closeted transman starting around 2000, then about two years as non-binary), never medically transitioned, became gender critical in 2019, and now publicly identify as a woman. My dysphoria and identification as a 'bisexual man trapped in a woman's body' began around age 12, shaped by early sexual assault (first before age two), being shunned for being female, exclusion from boys' activities, and later sexual assault as an adult. I attribute my return to identifying as female largely to misogyny I observed in the LGBT community and to questioning the weaponization of trans identity. I still sometimes feel pulled toward my 'old self' internally and find detransition discourse confusing at times. I remain strongly critical of medical transition, especially for children, and have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm.

Full story

I was born female. I identified as trans for about 19 years — roughly 17 of those as a closeted transman (starting around 2000 CE) and about two years as non-binary/genderfluid — before becoming gender critical in 2019 and going back to identifying publicly as a woman. I never medically transitioned, despite having dysphoria for about two decades. The reasons I did not medically transition were practical and personal: it was not cost effective for someone living in poverty; the only long-term way to take testosterone was injections, and I am so afraid of needles that I joke I would have died from medical neglect had I been diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes; Chaz Bono once said testosterone made it 'impossible' to follow his female friends' conversations, and I'm 'on the spectrum' and needed every bit of my ability to analyze social situations for my own survival; I believed my gender identity was no one's business; and I went into sex work 11 years before writing that (around 2008), reasoning that if I had to be 'trapped in a woman's body, might as well get something out of it.' I was on Title XIX (Medicaid) and would have qualified for T under today's standards, but I'm glad I never transitioned young. I live in Iowa and noted that the only people on T there were 'rich kids who are still on their parents' health insurance.' My gender identity began early. I remember being the only girl in many activities in elementary and middle school — tae kwon do, flag football — and being the only bisexual person I knew. I got shunned by my guy friends around fourth/fifth grade because I was female. Around age 12, because the friend I was in love with said she wouldn't be with me because I was female, I started saying I was a 'bisexual man trapped in a woman's body' — 'and the more I said it, the more I believed it.' I was resentful that I wasn't allowed to wrestle in middle school because there weren't 'enough girls for a different team,' and that I had to wait until junior year of high school to play football, and only the single-game 'powder puff' version. As an actor I pursued male roles, including one that put me in a constricting pencil skirt rather than slacks, and I played the Stage Manager in Our Town. Adversity and trauma were significant. A history teacher would call me to his desk for no reason when I was 11; another girl told me he did it so he could look at my ass. I was sexually assaulted for the first time when I was younger than two (the memory is gone, but a videotape of my second birthday confirms the assault). I had no resources other than Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP) affirmations. I said this trauma 'definitely influenced me to perform toxic masculinity and claim I wasn't a girl.' Even after I started identifying as male, I did not come out publicly until a 'friend' sexually assaulted me during a private dance — I was obligated to do it because the dancer would get paid double — and the bouncer gave him the tape as 'his birthday present to himself.' The last time I saw him, he bragged about still masturbating to it. What made me identify as female again was how misogynistic I found the LGBT community, both online and in the scene. I wanted to point out in feminist groups that specific trans women were using infantilizing and objectifying language, and was met with huge backlash rather than gratitude — even though at the time I didn't yet identify as female, I had educated myself about the subtle ways NLP is used to dehumanize women. I coined the term 'TERD — Trans-Exempting Restrictive Dickhead' for what happens when you call out misogyny in the trans community: you get misgendered to devalue your opinion, told you have 'internalized transphobia,' or labeled a TERF, invalidating your identity and lived experience. Around 2016 I watched what I called 'baby trans' people play the victim when called out on problematic behavior; the more I saw people weaponize the trans identity, the more I questioned it myself. I became gender critical in 2019 and went back to identifying publicly as a woman that year. I also described earlier relief: in the late 2000s on OKCupid I was 'genuinely relieved that having Pansexual as an option meant I didn't have to worry about being MURDERED for being GNC/having body hair as a female.' I lived for years saying 'I wish I were a man' multiple times a day, being read as a man from behind every few years due to obscuring my sex with clothes and movement, being rejected from romantic relationships for being the wrong sex, and thinking I was completely alone for nearly two decades. In November 2019 I posted asking whether others still feel parts of their trans identity popping up in everyday life. I wrote that I still have days where I identify internally as my 'old self,' but feel I can't be genderfluid/a man because of how deeply sex discrimination is ingrained in politics and because gender nonconformity has always existed — 'I don't need a trans identity to speak on my own personal experiences being gender nonconformative... except I do? Ugh.' I asked whether detransitioning makes people feel their years spent thinking they were trans are being dismissed, and whether that has to do with how the trans/LGBT community is set up online 'to be a discriminatory cult.' I distinguished self-identified transgender people from transsexuals, noting my experience is less traumatic emotionally and physically than those who medically transitioned, while still asserting I suffered dysphoria for 19 years. I hold strongly critical views of medical transition, especially for children: I don't support medical transition of children and don't even support psychiatric treatment before age 25, when the brain is fully developed. I have speculated that the mainstream transgender narrative is being pushed 'specifically to sterilize the generation that was raised to see through their imperialist lies,' citing vague DSM-V criteria, shareholder primacy in corporate law governing pharmaceutical companies, and conflicts of interest undermining the Hippocratic Oath. I described trans communities as functioning 'like a cult' that isolates young people from other sources of validation so they 'sit down and shut up.' I've also expressed views that the medical industry pushes pills rather than teaching self-soothing. I have been sexually assaulted (first before age two, and again in adulthood during a private dance), and I've dealt with ongoing trauma reminders. I've given extensive advice to others about trauma recovery using affirmations ('it's over, I am safe, that's in the past'), grounding exercises using the five senses, and self-soothing, emphasizing 'go easy on yourself, no matter what. You deserve forgiveness, it's not your fault.' I've described myself as living in poverty, on Medicaid, and working in sex work. I've been active in the local theatre community. I have not described any surgeries, hormone use, or fertility concerns since I never medically transitioned. I have not described a specific therapy that helped or hurt me, nor a particular moment of exposure to detransition communities. I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. My current identity is a detransitioned woman (gender critical, publicly identifying as a woman since 2019), though I report occasional internal pull toward my 'old self.' My attitude toward transition for others is critical, particularly regarding children and regarding medical transition generally; I have not described formal advocacy or activism beyond online posting and making a video about femicide.